Port Adelaide lose by 3 points after a wrong Goal Review against the Crows in the dying stages

[parano1a]

Need snicko for ones like that.

 

[RandB]

Still 2 minutes to go. Melbourne could have coughed up 3 games in that time.

 

[catpremier 07]

Ollie wines snap which ended up as a torp was worse

 

[RU_]

 

[Mr_Moogle]

 

[Doashuey]

If we don't use the camera angles that SHOW the ball hitting the post..... utter farce.

This is the most gutted and cheated I can remember feeling at a game. Incl last years Shuey final.

Except you weren't cheated in that one.
Only watched on the phone but to me it looked like it passed the other side of the post. Couldnt believe the call but put it down to viewing on a tiny screen.

 

[Kangaroos4eva]

Good on Jenkins for being honest, shows great character.

 

[Blackas87]

So you're saying Adelaide would have won anyway. Cool. On the other side of that argument, Port could have also got another goal themselves. So your reasoning is flawed big time tbh.

You should work as a goal review specialist

He did not say Adelaide would of won, He said we have no idea.

 

[jerry springer]

farcical

 

[Greasyrhys]

Stupid comp run by stupid people

 

[Doashuey]

Wow! After seeing the replay RU put up and zooming in the ball.most definitely passed the wrong side of the post. And clipped it too Id say. either way that was an absolute shocker.

 

[Demonic Ascent]

Clearly? Watched all the replays and still can't tell. Umpires call.

It clearly passed in front of the post, went through for a point never mind if it hit the post or not. Do you have HD Foxtel or standard? It can be pretty hard to tell if it's not in HD.

 

[Redline]

Clearly? Watched all the replays and still can't tell. Umpires call.

Obviously I am biased but I don't see how anyone can tell. Jenkins can't.

What makes me think it's a goal is not one person from the Port cheer squad stood up as it went through. If it hit the post they would of based on human behaviour. Sounds stupid but thats my theory.

Great game.

 

[Rack Watts]

Imagine if the AFL had HD slowmo cameras like every other professional sport?

 

[Brain Power]

Even if it did we have no idea if it cost them the game. Play would have completely changed after that moment

Adelaide would’ve won regardless. They were better.

This kind of equivocation is bullshit and lets the AFL wriggle off the hook too easily, virtually guaranteeing that this will keep happening. Hopefully the media (and Port) stick the boot in.

 

[Righteo]

Wow! After seeing the replay RU put up and zooming in the ball.most definitely passed the wrong side of the post. And clipped it too Id say. either way that was an absolute shocker.

You may need to zoom is more because it definitely passed in front of the post. Probably clipped it though.

 

[King Elvis]

How is an inconclusive score review any different to a dodgy HtB or free kick paid in the dying minutes?

The angles I saw were hard to make a call either way, but Jenkins would be the best judge.

Unlucky, and I’d be pissed if I was a Port fan, but that shit happens all of the time.

 

[TGFC]

Wow! After seeing the replay RU put up and zooming in the ball.most definitely passed the wrong side of the post. And clipped it too Id say. either way that was an absolute shocker.

It passed on the right side of the post. If the ball went behind the post then it would be a point

 

[Scorpus]

It's weird. From the front on angle, it looks like the ball passed in front of the post for a behind

From the "live" angle used on a slight angle, slowed down, it clearly goes behind the post for a goal. The reverse angle also shows it going through for a goal

Don't know whether it hit the post

 

[Macpotata]

'' Adelaide would have won regardless ''

haha! That's why they were trailing with barely a minute left in the match.

 

[Demonic Ascent]

Obviously I am bias but I don't see how anyone can tell. Jenkins can't.

What makes me think it's a goal is not one person from the Port cheer squad stood up as it went through. If it hit the post they would of based on human behaviour. Sounds stupid but thats my theory.

Great game.

Zoom in on the gif posted by RU_ clearly went through the points.

Agreed, great game, great round so far

 

[RU_]

You may need to zoom is more because it definitely passed in front of the post. Probably clipped it though.

What?

 

[King Elvis]

Zoom in on the gif posted by RU_ clearly went through the points.

Agreed, great game, great round so far

What?

Clearly went through the goals, but appears to have deflected.

 

[Gavin Excell]

Obviously I am bias but I don't see how anyone can tell. Jenkins can't.

What makes me think it's a goal is not one person from the Port cheer squad stood up as it went through. If it hit the post they would of based on human behaviour. Sounds stupid but thats my theory.

Great game.

You aren't bias

You are biased

 

[blue harvest]

Even if it did we have no idea if it cost them the game. Play would have completely changed after that moment

Exactly. A million things happen every game, like Margetts calling advantage. Unless it's the last play of the day like Shuey then there's not much point talking about it.