port and eagles trade

[Ford Fairlane]

Would Port except #18, Butler + Seaby for pick 4??

Kerr i doubt will want to come to adelaide if he leaves WC

Tell you what. We'll give you Krakouer, Deluca and #22 for #2. How does that sound?

 

[Janus]

Good luck with that

If there was a deadset gun of the above ilk, they'd be going 1 or 2 and not slipping to 4.

Like Lance Franklin?

 

[SS_Fury]

that trade would rip port off...i believe Pav was also pick 4 was he not?

 

[ArdentEagle]

I wouldn't want us to trade Butler anyway, we'd get nowhere near his value. He's one of the few midfielders we have left who has poise and doesn't just grab it and kick it ala Priddis or Steinglein

 

[Masten2McKinley]

2 rubbish players + a 2nd rounder does not equal pick 4

try again

hahaha becasue Butler and Seaby are rubbish,

Butler - was a star in our premiership year before going down with OP and missing 07 and most of 08, he will come back stronger.

Seaby - may not be the greatest ruckman but far from rubish holds his own for a back up ruck when cox is out

and WCE wouldnt do that btw

 

[Obeanie1]

trade him now while he has value because yet another injury plagued year will see him delisted?

It's not like Port (and everyone else) don't know this, that's why he has no value at the trade table..

Correct.....ATM.

If he can play 15+ games next year things might be different.

As to people wanting to trade Butts F@#$@!%!% off.

Grrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr!!!!!!!!!!!!!

We share the same surname and I luuuuuuuuv it when the commentators shout BUTLAAAAAAAAR!!!!!!!!!

 

[Nater]

How bout we trade Pettigrew, Surjan and Pick 22 for pick 2????

Seriously unless its Kerr (who's grandfather/father played in a Port premiership) you aren't going to get pick 4. We are basically garunteed Watts, Nat, Rich or Vickery all of whom will be better than Buttler/Seaby combined.

 

[postmanpav]

port might accept pick 18 plus mckinley for pick 4 but the eagles wouldnt give up mckinley unless it was a straight swap: mckinley PORT pick 4 WC

 

[Nater]

port might accept pick 18 plus mckinley for pick 4 but the eagles wouldnt give up mckinley unless it was a straight swap: mckinley PORT pick 4 WC

See above post!

 

[Ebert80]

port might accept pick 18 plus mckinley for pick 4 but the eagles wouldnt give up mckinley unless it was a straight swap: mckinley PORT pick 4 WC

Why would Port do that!! We already have Ebert and Motlop, as well as Gray who can play a similar role deep in attack. There's no way we'd do that.

I doubt Port would even give up their second pick for McKinlay.

 

[Gunnar Longshanks]

You people have lost your marbles.

Ridiculous trades being suggested from both sides of the fence.

I know the finals can be boring for sides not involved, but seriously, some of the chat in this thread is beyond stupid.

Stop fantasising and get a grip.

 

[PAFC_1]

hahaha becasue Butler and Seaby are rubbish,

Butler - was a star, down with OP and missing 07 and most of 08, he will come back stronger.

Seaby - may not be the greatest ruckman

You proved it, they are both rubbish