Post Your Team Here

[TerryTait]

B: Goddard, C.Cornes, Adcock, Ellis, Raines, S.Hill, Maguire, (Suban, Quinn)
M: Judd, Cooney, Swan, Mitchell, J.Selwood, Cousins (Davenport, Robinson)
R: Koshitzke, Ottens (Currie, Pyke)
F: Franklin, Deledio, Fevola, Mooney, Lucas, Higgins, Yarran (Gumbleton, R.Healey)

1. want to get rid of fev but dont know who else to get
2. will hill, yarran and maguire be playing round 1

and any ideas on how i could upgrade

cheers

If you downgraded Fev to Lucas it should free up about 120k and you could upgrade a cousins to corey or a selwood to hodge

 

[s1bbald]

B: Goddard, Fisher, Gilbee, Adcock, Myers, Houlihan, Hill (Broadbent, Smith)
M: Judd, Selwood, Gibbs, Cornes, Hasleby, Rich (Beams, Robinson)
R: Cox, Ottens (Lobbe, Currie)
F: Pavlich, Deledio, Brown, Cloke, Lucas, Higgins, Yarran (Brown, Ballantyne)

Any thoughts would be greatly appreciated.

 

[Baker_for_PM]

Brendon Goddard Bachar Houli Adam McPhee Bret Thornton Nick Malceski Andrew Raines Stephen Hill

Shaun Burgoyne Bradd Dalziell Chris Judd Peter Burgoyne Brent Staker Brent Reilly

Dean Cox Brad Ottens

Nick Riewoldt Aaron Davey Matthew Pavlich Brett Ebert Ryan Houlihan Sean Rusling Chris Dawes

Matthew Broadbent Nick Suban Daniel Rich Sam Blease Jackson Trengove Matthew Lobbe Steele Sidebottom Aaron Cornelius

advice/help would be handy

 

[s1bbald]

advice/help would be handy

Looks to be a high risk/reward factor. I'd be looking at getting 1/2 more consistent scorers in the backline, maybe getting rid of Dalziell (unless you want the risk/reward factor to stay high). Shaun Higgins has to come under consideration for your forward, as does a Yarran or Ziebell, allowing to upgrade one of your mid-tier forwards to a much more consistent one.

 

[camdent]

Had a 2nd go. As you can't half tell, have a massive dislike 4 ruckman other than Cox, but at 600000, mids are better value

Backs - Hodge, Goddard, Carrazzo, Embley, Mackie, Houlihan, Hill, Suban, Petrenko

Mids - Bartel, Judd, Pendlebury, Murphy, Masten, Rich, Dangerfield, Swift

Rucks - Nic Nat, Trengove, Currie, Meesen

Forwards - Pavlich, Deledio, Didak, S.Johnson, Porplyzia, Rioli, Gumbleton, Ballantyne, M.Brown

Nic naitanui wont be playing round 1 and will be lucky to get a game

 

[Newton Blues]

Backs: 1.Goddard, B 2. Fisher, S 3. Gilbee, L 4. Cornes, C 5. Houlihan, R 6. Raines, A 7. Hill, S

Bench: Suban, N. Perenko, J


Midfield: 1. Judd, C (Capt) 2. Selwood, J 3. Gibbs, B 4. Hasably, P 5. Masten, C 6. Rich, D

Bench: Ziebell, J. Dangerfield, P

Rucks: 1. Cox, D 2. Mcintosh, H


Bench: Currie, D. Meeson, J


Forwards: 1. Pavlich, M 2. Deledio, B 3. Brown, J 4. Didak, A 5. Lucas, S 6. Higgins, S 7. Skipworlth, H

Bench: Gumbleton, S. Grant, J



There my team what you guys think who should i change biggie?

 

[Biggie]

Backs: 1.Goddard, B 2. Fisher, S 3. Gilbee, L 4. Cornes, C 5. Houlihan, R 6. Raines, A 7. Hill, S

Bench: Suban, N. Perenko, J

Backline, man that is gorgeous. Again Im no rookie starting in the backline fan but shit sometimes you have to take those calculated risks

Midfield: 1. Judd, C (Capt) 2. Selwood, J 3. Gibbs, B 4. Hasably, P 5. Masten, C 6. Rich, D

Bench: Ziebell, J. Dangerfield, P

Not a Masten SC fan he can turn it over and is a awful kick at goal. But he may turn it around in 09 and looks set for a decent yr as long as Kerr is next to him and bloody Fletcher and Priddis get out from under his feet...Gibbs could be a great pick in 09 Selwood is great, Judd is Judd lets be honest

Rucks: 1. Cox, D 2. Mcintosh, H

Bench: Currie, D. Meeson, J

Gorgeous

Forwards: 1. Pavlich, M 2. Deledio, B 3. Brown, J 4. Didak, A 5. Lucas, S 6. Higgins, S 7. Skipworlth, H

Bench: Gumbleton, S. Grant, J

No rookies here, so the rookie in the backline is negated.Dont rate Didak as a SC'er, Brown can burn you....other than that its very good...

There my team what you guys think who should i change biggie?

Man have I started something here?? Im no Superstar you know. lol

Great effort NB, one of the better sides I have seen. For mine there is better value in the forward rookies but if Hill can notch 70-80 for 8 weeks you'll be laughing. Bench is good at the Ruck, forwards and Mids, backline like most of us is a worry

Good luck.

 

[Ya Can't See Me!]

Backs: Bowden - Gilbee - Burgoyne - Cornes - Birchall - Myers - Hill
(Suban - Okeefe D)

Mids: Hodge - Judd - Dal Santo - Murphy - Selwood - Rich
(Swift - Zieball)

Rucks: Warnock - White
(Currie - Trengrove)

Forwards: Reiwoldt - Pavlich - Brown - Franklin - Higgins - Yarran - Gumbleton
(Hogan - Brown M)

Rucks are weak yes thinking of weakening even more i have used this stradegy effectively in the past, any thoughts would be appreciated.

 

[Baker_for_PM]

Looks to be a high risk/reward factor. I'd be looking at getting 1/2 more consistent scorers in the backline, maybe getting rid of Dalziell (unless you want the risk/reward factor to stay high). Shaun Higgins has to come under consideration for your forward, as does a Yarran or Ziebell, allowing to upgrade one of your mid-tier forwards to a much more consistent one.

Cheers ill have another tinker and see what i come up with i like a bit of rish tho not much of a game without it

 

[torq]

First effort...

B: Enright, Gilbee, M Clarke, Adcock, D Merrett, Grimes, Hill (Trengove, Heath)
C: Judd, J Selwood, Palmer, Boak, Masten, Rich (Dangerfield, Muston)
R: Hille, Maric (Leuenberger, Meeson)
F: Harvey, Pavlich, Didak, Fevola, Ebert, Higgins, Veszpremi (J Grant, C Hughes)

Clueless

 

[DanA]

First effort...

B: Enright, Gilbee, M Clarke, Adcock, D Merrett, Grimes, Hill (Trengove, Heath)
C: Judd, J Selwood, Palmer, Boak, Masten, Rich (Dangerfield, Muston)
R: Hille, Maric (Leuenberger, Meeson)
F: Harvey, Pavlich, Didak, Fevola, Ebert, Higgins, Veszpremi (J Grant, C Hughes)

Clueless

Backs:
- I don't like Enright because he is comming off a stunning year and I can't see improvement. I'd look at downgrading 60K to the Chad.

- Merritt is one of the best spoilers in the competition, that doesn't score in supercoach. Better is Raines, Houlihan or at 70k less Petterd looks promising.

Midfield:
Is ok

Rucks:
You know every team will have cox by then end of season so might as well pick him up now and save the trade.

Forwards:
Good but Ebert?? There's better choices around that price. I'd probably spend a touch more and go Lucas.

 

[premiers2000]

BACKS: Gilbee, H.Shaw, C.Cornes, Lockyer, Malceski, Houlihan, Dempsey EMG Hill, Suban

MIDS: Judd, S.Thompson, J.Selwood, Boak, Masten, Rich EMG Dangerfield, Swift.

Rucks: Cox, McIntosh EMG Vickery, Sellar

FWDS: Deleido, J.Brown, S.Johnson, Fevola, Lucas, Higgins, Gumbleton EMG T.Walker, Ballantyne

any advice would be great. thanks

 

[Hurleys Hawkers]

Cornes Lockyer Mackie Malceski Smith Raines Pettard (Hill Broadbent)

Judd Pendlebury Selwood Sewell Kerr Rich (Dangerfield Beams)

Cox McIntosh (Currie Trengrove)

Delidio Richardson Didak Johnson LeCras Higgins Hentchel (Gumbleton Ballantyne)


Thinking about dongrading maybe Pendles for Reilly and then upgrading JW Smith for a bit more stability in the backline. May even do this for the forward line by trading Delidio and upgrading someone. Not too sure who though because Hentschuel Higgins and LeCras are all at a great price and I can see them going up a fair amount..

Thoughs??

 

[WOTTAMACHINE]

Backs: Goddard, Cornes, Houli, Myers, R Houlihan, Raines, S Hill (Cheney, S McKernan)

Centres: Judd, J Selwood, Sewell, Boak, M Rosa, Rich (Dangerfield, Swift)

Rucks: Cox, Petrie (Trengrove, Currie)

Forwards: Franklin, Deledio, Pavlich, J Riewoldt, Vezpremi, Yarran, Ziebell (Ballantyne, M Brown)

I have $350K left in the bank.. I believe having a few $$$ in the bank is very important for when you trade the cash cows..

Thoughts?

 

[stefoid]

Wonameeri? (OK, cant spell)

thoughts at $356000?

ready to play midfield for the dees?

 

[Yancankick]

Rvised Team. Not so top heavy, any major problem areas??

BACK: Hodge, Goddard, Gilbee, Cornes, Malceski, Raines, S. Hill (Hurley, Dawson)

MIDS: Judd, Kelly, Gibbs, Ward, Rich, Dangerfield (Davenport, Steven)

RUCKS: Cox, McIntosh (Currie, Sullivan)

FORWARDS: N. Reiwoldt, Pavlich, Franklin, Chapman, Higgins, Delidio, Zeibell (Grant, Gumbleton)

Bit thin in the mids I know but they the biggest scorers so I'm hoping Rich and Dangerfield will play and from what I've heard they both will.

JUDGE ME!

 

[s1bbald]

Bit thin in the mids I know but they the biggest scorers so I'm hoping Rich and Dangerfield will play and from what I've heard they both will.

I think you could pick better bench players in your mids also, Dayne Beams and Mitch Robinson have to come under consideration.

 

[Shut up Flanders]

Please comment my team

Backs: B.Goddard, S.Fisher, L.Gilbee, C.Cornes, T.Lockyer, J.Adcock, R.Houlihan (J.Petrenko, A.Kite)

Mids: C.Judd, S.Thompson, N.Dal Santo, P.Hasleby, S.Higgins, D.Rich (D.Beams, M.Robinson)

Rucks: D.Cox, H.McIntosh (D.Currie, J.White)

Fwds: M.Pavlich, M.Richardson, B.Deledio, S.Lucas, P.Veszpremi, C.Yarran, M.Brown (S.Sidebottom, S.Gumbleton)

I think its a pretty well balanced side. My forwards are my weakest area, but i chose to make it there because thats where the most reliable rookies are in terms of possible game time. Anyways enough of my rambling, what are your thoughts??

 

[BangersAndMash]

Ok, so... New at this - first year for SC so be gentle! But seriously, any advice would be appreciated. Here goes..


B: Gilbee, L - Fisher, S - Wojcinski, D - Hill, S

Cornes, C - Gilbert, S - Raines, A

Int: Trengrove, J - Rance, A


M: Judd, C - Cross, D - Rich, D

Selwood, J - Hasleby, P - Coughlan, M

Int: Hartlett, H - Swift, T


R: Cox, D - Hille, D

Int: Kreuzer, M - Currie, D


F: Reiwoldt, N - Harvey, B - Franklin, L - Gumbleton, S

O'Keefe, R - Ziebell, J - Sidebottem, S

Int: Nahas, R - Thorp, M


Your thoughts?
Cheers

 

[JLoh]

Backs Goddard, Gilbee, Chad, Birchall, Malceski, Raines, S.Hill
(Emg: Broughton, Suban)

Mids Bartel, S.Burgoyne, Nicky Dal, Young, Skipworth, Rich
(Emg: M.Robinson, Ziebell)

Rucks Cox, Ottens
(Emg: Meesen, A.Graham)

Fwds Pav, Buddy, Richo, Stevie J, Alwyn Davey, Higgins, Yarran
(Emg: J.Grant, Gumbleton)

Ne thoughts/opinions on this team?
Cheers

 

[JTRx]

Hi all,

This is my first time playing SuperCoach and here's my first effort for a team:

Backs: Goddard - Newman - Cornes - McPhee - Wojcinski - Petterd - Hill
(Suban - Rance)

Mids: Bartel - Judd - Black - Griffin - Morton C - Rich
(Swift - Dangerfield)

Rucks: Hille - Ottens
(Currie - Spencer)

Forwards: Harvey - Franklin - Richardson - Porplyzia - Davey Aa - Higgins - Ziebell
(Gumbleton, Schoenmakers)

Any thoughts appreciated.

 

[Newton Blues]

new look team...

Backs: 1.Goddard, B 2. Fisher, S 3. Gilbee, L 4. Cornes, C 5. Malseki, N 6. Raines, A 7. Hill, S

Bench: Suban, N. Rance, A


Midfield: 1. Judd, C (Capt) 2. Selwood, J 3. Gibbs, B 4. Hasably, P 5. Masten, C 6. Rich, D

Bench: Ziebell, J. Dangerfield, P

Rucks: 1. Cox, D 2. Mcintosh, H


Bench: Currie, D. Meeson, J


Forwards: 1. Pavlich, M 2. Deledio, B 3. Brown, J 4. Didak, A 5. Lucas, S 6. Higgins, S 7. Watts, J

Bench: Gumbleton, S. Grant, J


In: Watts, Malseki, rance

Out: Houlihan, Skipworlth, perenko

what you think of the changers biggie worse or better?

 

[Quicky]

Hi all,

This is my first time playing SuperCoach and here's my first effort for a team:

Backs: Goddard - Newman - Cornes - McPhee - Wojcinski - Petterd - Hill
(Suban - Rance)

Mids: Bartel - Judd - Black - Griffin - Morton C - Rich
(Swift - Dangerfield)

Rucks: Hille - Ottens
(Currie - Spencer)

Forwards: Harvey - Franklin - Richardson - Porplyzia - Davey Aa - Higgins - Ziebell
(Gumbleton, Schoenmakers)

Any thoughts appreciated.

I think thats a pretty strong team, one of the best first year teams i've seen posted. I think McPhee is overpriced (just my opinion) I like Wojcinski but think he is coming off an injury so could be a bit risky. Hill is not guaranteed to be playing.

I think your midfield falls away a bit. Griffin C Morton and Rich is a bit risky all together. I'd take a punt on two and try to get a more solid player as the third. Remember Black broke his hand so he is under an injury cloud - he's likely to drop in value at the start of the season so you can pick him up cheaper later. I'd look at someone cheaper than Black like Kerr and invest the rest of that Money into probably Morton to get a less risky player.

The rest looks alright to me

 

[newbie_help]

Hey all!

Been asked by to post my team so here it is!

Backs: Gilbee, Adcock, Cornes, Malceski, Raines, Petterd, Hill, S.

Midfield: Judd, Selwood, Masten, Rich, Hasleby, Pendlebury

Midfield: Cox, Macca

Fwds: Richo, J. Brown, Lucas, Higgins. Didak, J. Reiwoldt, Yarran

So what does everyone think? I haven't added bench players as these are still up in the air (plan on having cash cows)

What are your thoughts on Petterd? (any good), Richo? J. Reiwoldt?

Feedback is welcomed!

 

[RevDog]

Backs: S Fisher, L Gilbee, C Cornes, J Adcock, N Malceski, D Myers, S Hill
(EMG: A Rance, N Suban)

Centers: C Judd, S Pendlebury, J Selwood, R Griffen, P Hasleby, D Rich
(EMG: D Beams, M Robinson)

Rucks: D Cox, H McIntosh
(EMG: J White, D Currie)

Forwards: M Pavlich, B Deledio, J Brown, T Cloke, S Lucas, S Higgins, C Yarren/ J Ziebell
(EMG: S Gumbleton, M Brown)

I've got $37,500 in the bank after my latest adjustments. I need some advice on Myers and Cloke, should I get either of them or are they a no go?