Opinion Predict the top 10 in the 2021 B&F
- Thread starter bergholt
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Thread starter
- #4
Early votes
14: Crouch, Sinclair, Steele, Wilkie
13: Membrey
12: Howard
11: Webster
10: Higgins
9: King
8:
7:
6:
5: Hill
4: Billings, Dunstan
3: Jones, Marshall, Ross
2:
1: Butler, McKenzie
0: Battle, Byrnes, Bytel, Clark, Coffield, Highmore, Long, Ryder
Looks like the top 9 is locked in so far, number 10 could be contentious though.
14: Crouch, Sinclair, Steele, Wilkie
13: Membrey
12: Howard
11: Webster
10: Higgins
9: King
8:
7:
6:
5: Hill
4: Billings, Dunstan
3: Jones, Marshall, Ross
2:
1: Butler, McKenzie
0: Battle, Byrnes, Bytel, Clark, Coffield, Highmore, Long, Ryder
Looks like the top 9 is locked in so far, number 10 could be contentious though.
- Oct 2, 2010
- 21,313
- 77,880
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Missing 3 and being subbed off in 2 might cost him top 5, but his career revival was one of the good things this year. Sets us up nicely next year to have both him and Paton.
- Aug 1, 2015
- 731
- 1,679
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
1. Steele
2. Sinclair
3. Howard
4. Membrey
5. Crouch
6. King
7. Wilkie
8. Jones
9. Higgins
10. Marshall
2. Sinclair
3. Howard
4. Membrey
5. Crouch
6. King
7. Wilkie
8. Jones
9. Higgins
10. Marshall
goodie23
Tragic Saint
Veteran
St Kilda - Marcus Windhager Player Sponsor 2023
St Kilda - Marcus Windhager Player Sponsor 2022
St Kilda - James Frawley Player Sponsor 2021
Saints Pledge Contributor
St Kilda - Doulton Langlands Player Sponsor 2020
St Kilda - Robbie Young Player Sponsor 2019
St Kilda - Nathan Freeman Player Sponsor 2018
1. Jack Steele
2. Cal Wilkie
3. Jimmy Webster
4. Dougal Howard
5. Max King
6. Jack Sinclair
7. Jack Higgins
8. Tim Membrey
9. Brad Hill
10. Brad Crouch
2. Cal Wilkie
3. Jimmy Webster
4. Dougal Howard
5. Max King
6. Jack Sinclair
7. Jack Higgins
8. Tim Membrey
9. Brad Hill
10. Brad Crouch
hayes
Brownlow Medallist
1. Steele
2. Webster
3. Sinclair
4. Wilkie
5. King
6. Howard
7. Crouch
8. Hill
9. Membrey
10. Higgins
Webster’s year massively underrated. I had him in the Newnes/Acres category at the start of the season but he was unbelievable this year. Still think he’s an overrated kick but even when we were getting flogged every week he rarely got beaten. Toss up between him and Sinclair for second spot.
2. Webster
3. Sinclair
4. Wilkie
5. King
6. Howard
7. Crouch
8. Hill
9. Membrey
10. Higgins
Webster’s year massively underrated. I had him in the Newnes/Acres category at the start of the season but he was unbelievable this year. Still think he’s an overrated kick but even when we were getting flogged every week he rarely got beaten. Toss up between him and Sinclair for second spot.
- Thread starter
- #13
Totals at this point
30+: Sinclair (34), Steele (34), Wilkie (34), Crouch (32), Howard (30)
25+: Membrey (29), Webster (27)
20+: Higgins (23), King (23)
15+: Hill (15)
10+:
5+: Billings (9), Marshall (9), Ross (8), Dunstan (7), Jones (7)
1+: Highmore (2), McKenzie (2), Butler (1), Byrnes (1), Ryder (1)
0: Battle, Bytel, Clark, Coffield, Long
Top 10 clear on our votes.
30+: Sinclair (34), Steele (34), Wilkie (34), Crouch (32), Howard (30)
25+: Membrey (29), Webster (27)
20+: Higgins (23), King (23)
15+: Hill (15)
10+:
5+: Billings (9), Marshall (9), Ross (8), Dunstan (7), Jones (7)
1+: Highmore (2), McKenzie (2), Butler (1), Byrnes (1), Ryder (1)
0: Battle, Bytel, Clark, Coffield, Long
Top 10 clear on our votes.
Saint_Dos
Premiership Player
1. Steele
2. Sinclair
3. Howard
4. Marshall
5. Wilkie
6. Membrey
7. Higgins
8. Webster
9. Crouch
10. Hill
2. Sinclair
3. Howard
4. Marshall
5. Wilkie
6. Membrey
7. Higgins
8. Webster
9. Crouch
10. Hill
- Sep 18, 2013
- 4,849
- 12,900
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
- Other Teams
- NOLA
Good 10 could be close.
Wouldn’t be surprised tho if seb sneaks in. Gets on the fan’s nerves but does what he’s told I reckon.
St Plugger
Team Captain
- Feb 28, 2012
- 307
- 515
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
I think DMac actually has a chance to make it into the top 10. I don't think his efforts this season will go unrecognised!
gringo2011
Premium Platinum
- Nov 7, 2012
- 10,806
- 35,360
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
- Other Teams
- Bristol City FC, Urawa Red Diamonds FC
10 Leo Connolly
9 David Teague
8 Ned Guy
7 Duke Lustman
6 The D Mac
5 Jack Silkclair
4 Jack Steele's parents
3 Jack Steele
2 Cooper "The" Sharman
and the winner is
1 The Trainee Receptionist
9 David Teague
8 Ned Guy
7 Duke Lustman
6 The D Mac
5 Jack Silkclair
4 Jack Steele's parents
3 Jack Steele
2 Cooper "The" Sharman
and the winner is
1 The Trainee Receptionist
Steele
Sinclair
Crouch
Howard
Membrey
Wilkie
Hill
Ross
Billings
Higgins
Webster/Marshall/King/Dunstan
Sinclair
Crouch
Howard
Membrey
Wilkie
Hill
Ross
Billings
Higgins
Webster/Marshall/King/Dunstan
Last edited:
After every game this year I voted 5 for beat down to 1. This is the end result.
1-Steele
2-crouch
3-membrey
4-king
5-Sinclair
6-Jones
7-Marshall
8-dunstan
9-billings
10-Ross/hill
now this way of voting doesn’t take in consistency but merely the best 5 players for each game. So missing games doesn’t hurt a players chances as much. If I had to do my top 10 off they eye test and gut feel this would be it.
1-Steele
2-daylight
3-Sinclair
4-crouch
5-Wilkie
6-king
7-Webster
8-Howard
9-hill
10-membrey
11-dunstan
1-Steele
2-crouch
3-membrey
4-king
5-Sinclair
6-Jones
7-Marshall
8-dunstan
9-billings
10-Ross/hill
now this way of voting doesn’t take in consistency but merely the best 5 players for each game. So missing games doesn’t hurt a players chances as much. If I had to do my top 10 off they eye test and gut feel this would be it.
1-Steele
2-daylight
3-Sinclair
4-crouch
5-Wilkie
6-king
7-Webster
8-Howard
9-hill
10-membrey
11-dunstan
SaintByTrade
Debutant
- Oct 14, 2016
- 127
- 235
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
- Other Teams
- Derby County
This goes to show how truly average our list actually is.
Similar threads
