Predicted/desired trades for 2007

[Silvagnis]

Fisher.
Waite.

 

[davey_23]

Wouldnt mind Murphy from Freo or Laycock from Essendon.

 

[catzfan]

what would teams give for joel corey? or steven king?

 

[brown_2000au]

Waite for Hartigan and a third rounder(Early)

 

[Reg Hickey]

Depends on your definition of cheap but.......

Fact - Geelong wanted to trade him last year and nobody was prepared to give up a top 35 pick.

His currency has not gone up since then.

All I am saying is that I dont think he is worth a top 30 pick based on last year nobody taking him. Interested in what other people than just biased Cats fans think.

No, you also said he's not in the best 22.

No-one wanted him last year, true, but that was solely due to his ankles which are so bad that he struggles to play more than 15-odd games in a season. But when he is playing, he is without doubt in the best 22, and would be in 15 other sides as well.

Geelong will never get a top 30 pick for him due to his ankles.

 

[Embers]

Sampi or LeCras anyone?

 

[Silvagnis]

Wouldnt mind Murphy from Freo or Laycock from Essendon.

I like Murphy and he would be a good target since he's out of the team after they acquired Tarrant.

Buckley's of getting him across after he re-signed last year.

Laycock is a spud like Paul Johnson.

Is McQualter a battler or a player stuck behind more talented midfielders?

He's a bit small but he'd be a worth a shot if he can play.

 

[mcphee_is_a_gun]

Early second round pick for Lovett from a club who need pace, but you'd get jackshit from the WCE, Swans or Crows for him because he's soft.

A packet of chips and a rookie pick for Davey.

First round pick for Jetta.

Dear oh Dear......

 

[irish_setanta]

Are you serious. Thats a horrible deal for us. Id want a player like Lovett plus pick around 20.

As far as Hurn goes no way the club would trade him at this stage. Wouldnt really want Brad Fisher. Not really a type of player we need atm.

Hes a forward who can take a mark a kick a goal, something you havent got alot of.

 

[Silvagnis]

Dear oh Dear......

I wouldn't have picked Davey at pick 36 any more than you'd pick Eddie Betts there and Lovett is an outside player. Forward pocket/flankers like that are a dime dozen and they are normally selected in the second or third round. I doubt the Eagles, Cats and Swans would give you a first round pick for Lovett when they have Sampi, Varcoe/Johnson and Davis.

Jetta was a second round pick.

Why does an opinion like that warrant a comment such as Dear Oh Dear?

 

[Silvagnis]

What would the eagles want for Waters? Dont say Winderlich or Jetta..wont happen..Love Waters tho..

Stanton would be fair because that's his level if you take into account his hardness and ability to take a mark as the third man up. They would never ask for Winderlich or Jetta for Waters when they have Morton, Hurn, Rosa, Butler, etc. pushing for selection in their best 22.

 

[J.Hetfield]

Stanton would be fair because that's his level if you take into account his hardness and ability to take a mark as the third man up. They would never ask for Winderlich or Jetta for Waters when they have Morton, Hurn, Rosa, Butler, etc. pushing for selection in their best 22.

No deal.....Stants is too important..Maybe Johns (eagles need another marking forward and say our 15 - 30 pick..)

 

[crows_4_life]

In Like Flint,

what would carlton want for Jarrad Waite??
i rate him highly and if we didnt succeed in getting Pavlich, wouldn't mind him.

would you accept:

Meesen, 2nd round pick, 3rd round pick?????

 

[cAsEy_18]

yes probabaly a bit harsh there i'd take any of them before Eddie (betts)

Dear oh Dear......

 

[cAsEy_18]

just because davery was picked up at pick 36 doenst mean he is a pick 36 player. its just that all the clubs (including essendon) were stupid enough to let him slip through to that late. u cant say there only worth what draft pick you get them for. if that was the case we'd only get pick 36 for davery but we'd get pick 7 for bradley

I wouldn't have picked Davey at pick 36 any more than you'd pick Eddie Betts there and Lovett is an outside player. Forward pocket/flankers like that are a dime dozen and they are normally selected in the second or third round. I doubt the Eagles, Cats and Swans would give you a first round pick for Lovett when they have Sampi, Varcoe/Johnson and Davis.

Jetta was a second round pick.

Why does an opinion like that warrant a comment such as Dear Oh Dear?

 

[cAsEy_18]

brings up a good point with dal santo out of contract what does essendon need to give up for him?

 

[Gets!]

In Like Flint,

what would carlton want for Jarrad Waite??
i rate him highly and if we didnt succeed in getting Pavlich, wouldn't mind him.

would you accept:

Meesen, 2nd round pick, 3rd round pick?????[/QUOTE]

FAR too much.

 

[crosby123]

Now that is the dumbest post of the year. If you are going to come on here and talk about trades you actually have to watch other teams play and have a semblance of understanding about opposition players. Didak played HF all year last year.

HF, HB all rotate through the midfield, like Didak. Sure, he kicks a few goals, but so should any decent half-forward/midfielder (i.e. Gary Ablett Jr, Paul Chapman).

 

[sydney eagle]

Hes a forward who can take a mark a kick a goal, something you havent got alot of.

Tell that do Ash Hansen and David Wirripanda !

 

[Deledio2Conca]

In Like Flint,

what would carlton want for Jarrad Waite??
i rate him highly and if we didnt succeed in getting Pavlich, wouldn't mind him.

would you accept:

Meesen, 2nd round pick, 3rd round pick?????[/QUOTE]

FAR too much.

I think he means one of those things.

Would anyone here trade for Hartigan?

 

[davey_23]

It would be good to get someone like Jaymie Graham.

 

[crackerjack91]

Chris Judd to Richmond for Mark Coughlan, Andrew Krakour and 2nd round dradt pick

 

[Calcium Man]

I would like to see the tigers get Meeson. Not sure what for tho. Maybe 2nd rd pick.

 

[sexyhunk]

Chris Judd to Richmond for Mark Coughlan, Andrew Krakour and 2nd round dradt pick

oh i see, my turn now.

chris judd to geelong for steven king, shannon byrnes and 2nd pick.

how i go?

 

[Upgrayedd]

Sampi, but we would be giving up shit all for him, 3rd round pick if your lucky