PURE SPECULATION - IN: Davis. OUT: Goldsack

[carltonblue]

Heard a whisper Collingwood are going to do this matchday. Anybody else out there heard it as well?

 

[Drongo]

Re: IN: Davis. OUT: Goldsack

Heard a whisper Collingwood are going to do this matchday. Anybody else out there heard it as well?

Not going to happen Leon's gone walkabout 3 times in grand finals. Too risky.

 

[DaVe86]

Re: IN: Davis. OUT: Goldsack

He isn't even in our emergencies...so seems unlikely.

What's the rule about bringing someone in if they are not in the 25??

 

[Zahki]

Re: IN: Davis. OUT: Goldsack

He's not an emergency, so no, it's not going to happen.

 

[dart]

Re: IN: Davis. OUT: Goldsack

ooh more selection shenanigans from the wiley old malthouse. . .


should be good for a few column inches.

 

[Igloo]

Re: IN: Davis. OUT: Goldsack

$20k fine, I believe.

I believe you are correct.

 

[Peter Sidorkiewicz]

Re: IN: Davis. OUT: Goldsack

If it did happen, Goldsack won't be playing for Collingwood next season.

 

[carltonblue]

Re: IN: Davis. OUT: Goldsack

If it did happen, Goldsack won't be playing for Collingwood next season.

Goldsack and his family and friends are in on it. That is how the rumour reached me.

Yes $20K fine to the Pies but its a year for unusual circumstances and I am starting to believe this rumour.

More Later.

 

[jimmy35]

Re: IN: Davis. OUT: Goldsack

20k fine wouldn't worry them if they thought it might give them an edge but I can't see it upsetting the Saints too much.

Blair out for Leon would make more sense.

 

[weagles_fan]

Re: IN: Davis. OUT: Goldsack

Malthouse would never hear the end of it if Leon is pathetic (again) and the Pies go down in a thriller.

 

[duffman324]

Re: IN: Davis. OUT: Goldsack

Won't happen. Stupid call anyway, we would shut down Leon again, Goldsack is a far better option. Risking the fine would be just stupid.

 

[Byron_Clanger]

Re: IN: Davis. OUT: Goldsack

If that was the case then why didn't they at least have him as an emergency, they are just playing silly buggers

 

[Headless]

Re: IN: Davis. OUT: Goldsack

Just to really shock them, Collingwood should take out Dane Swan for Neon Leon.

 

[dan warna]

Re: IN: Davis. OUT: Goldsack

Every coach has a favourite, even the best coaches.

I've often wondered why Dempster gets selected game after game after game.

But Lyon has delivered one of the most effective st kilda teams in our history, and frankly our 3rd grand final in two years so he's doing hte right thing.

As for micky milkshakes, he's delivered collingwoods 4th grand final in 9 years and a fair few prelims so whatever his faults, he's a good coach.

 

[Nathan Q Brown]

Re: IN: Davis. OUT: Goldsack

Not going to happen Leon's gone walkabout 3 times in grand finals. Too risky.

i guess you wouldn't have made that shit joke if he was white. moron

 

[seanoff]

Re: IN: Davis. OUT: Goldsack

i guess you wouldn't have made that shit joke if he was white. moron

a little too hurt. it would hardly be a comment that would fit a whitefella.

I've heard it used in breaks here, no one takes offence.

 

[Peter Sidorkiewicz]

Re: IN: Davis. OUT: Goldsack

Goldsack and his family and friends are in on it. That is how the rumour reached me.

Yes $20K fine to the Pies but its a year for unusual circumstances and I am starting to believe this rumour.

More Later.

I heard that around 20 or so Goldsack's family and friends are heading to the MCG to watch Tyson play. Why would they come if he wasn't going to play.

Also Mick Malthouse doesn't seem the kind of coach to make a deliberate change to bluff the other coach. Ross Lyon I think would be more happy with Leon in the side than Goldsack as Davis is currently a shadow of his former self. Horribly out of form.

 

[Beamsmagic]

Re: IN: Davis. OUT: Goldsack

Heard a whisper Collingwood are going to do this matchday. Anybody else out there heard it as well?

Poor Troll from a Carlton fan - yeah wow i believed it

 

[Bozo]

Re: IN: Davis. OUT: Goldsack

However, the 29-year-old [Davis] was upbeat at training on Friday morning and Malthouse said Davis would take his bags to the MCG on Saturday, adding that "strange things happen.

"Right now we're very satisfied with the 25 we picked, but the lads that have been training for the four weeks, as far as I'm concerned they take their bags along just in case," Malthouse said from the Westpac Centre on Friday.

"Who knows? It probably won't happen, but strange things happen."

It is a possibility as I don't think a $20K fine would be a consideration when the winner is going to pocket double prizemoney which is what, $2 mill? Still very unlikely though.

 

[Rack Watts]

Re: IN: Davis. OUT: Goldsack

$20 on Goldsack to win Norm Smith >_>

 

[The Falcon Strike]

Re: IN: Davis. OUT: Goldsack

Bad move by Mick - we all know Leon disappears in September - but we've hit October - the curse has lifted me thinks!!

 

[Lockyer24]

Re: IN: Davis. OUT: Goldsack

Judds Brownlow is more credible than this thread

 

[yeee_haaaa!!!!!]

Re: IN: Davis. OUT: Goldsack

Goldsack and his family and friends are in on it. That is how the rumour reached me.

Yes $20K fine to the Pies but its a year for unusual circumstances and I am starting to believe this rumour.

More Later.

bullsh*t

 

[Altum Volantes]

Re: IN: Davis. OUT: Goldsack

I'm pretty sure the Saints would chip in for the 20k if it meant Leon was out on the park again.

 

[nineteen eighty]

Re: IN: Davis. OUT: Goldsack

Every coach has a favourite, even the best coaches.

I've often wondered why Dempster gets selected game after game after game.

But Lyon has delivered one of the most effective st kilda teams in our history, and frankly our 3rd grand final in two years so he's doing hte right thing.

As for micky milkshakes, he's delivered collingwoods 4th grand final in 9 years and a fair few prelims so whatever his faults, he's a good coach.

Dempster is one of those unsung tough nuts that every side needs. Take a look at his defensive efforts last week and that is why Lyon has him in the team.

And is it really Lyon's 3rd GF and Mick's 4th?? Or it is still his 2nd and 3rd respectively...and this is simply a replay. I tend to think there is a bit of double counting going on if this is counted as a seperate GF in its own rights.

Good luck to both teams. I still get goose bumps thinking of the 2nd half...both teams smashed each other for the entirety of it. What a game!