Opinion Rank these players in order from 1-6: Gary Ablett Jnr, Nathan Buckley,James Hird, Chris Judd, Dustin Martin, Michael Voss

[Shane Heard]

Ablett
Judd
Goodes
Selwood
Pendlebury
Mitchell
Fyfe
Danger
Dusty

Sorry don’t remember much about the others but I imagine all of them are better than Dusty and you probably left out better names such as Ricciuto, Cousins and Robert Harvey

And Jason Johnson. Don’t forget him.

 

[dmt]

And Jason Johnson. Don’t forget him.

nah courtney johns

 

[eaglespremiers]

Everyone forgets Kerr too.

In my mind he (along with Voss) is the most aggressive hardnut gun who could turn a game on its head with his relentless attack on the ball. A beautiful kick too.

Probably in Simon Black and Joel Selwood range on my list IMO (60-85).
The height of 2005-2007 was very impressive (still behind Judd) but he tapered away quickly after this with the team.

 

[citizen-erased]

1- junior. Best footballer of this AFL era
2- judd. Esp WCE judd
3- vossy
4- hird
5- bucks
6 - dusty.

 

[TheUnicorn]

I find it really hard to choose between Hird, Voss and Buckley personally couldn't argue with them in any order from 3-5. I think Ablett and Judd clearly 1-2 and Dusty last.

1. Ablett
2. Judd
3. Hird
4. Voss
5. Buckley
6. Martin

 

[STPer18]

1. Ablett
2. Judd
3. Hird
4. Voss
5. Buckley
6. Martin

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

Might be too young but Gablett, Franklin and Judd are in their own tier to the others. Throw a blanket over a lot of other names (including Fyfe who is absent from most secondary lists mentioned here)

 

[citizen-erased]

I find it really hard to choose between Hird, Voss and Buckley personally couldn't argue with them in any order from 3-5. I think Ablett and Judd clearly 1-2 and Dusty last.

1. Ablett
2. Judd
3. Hird
4. Voss
5. Buckley
6. Martin

Tight between those 3
Awesome leaders, they turned games at will, each has a brownlow, they were the original top 3

Id have all 3 as eq. 3rd

 

[UnitedWarrior93]

1. Gary Ablett
2. Chris Judd
3. Michael Voss
4. Dustin Martin
5. Nathan Buckley
6. James Hird

 

[Hoops]

Who's arguing? I've presented a case that is yet to be refuted. In any thread in which the case has been presented.

There are plenty who rate Pendlebury ahead of Martin.

For their body of work I certainly do

 

[joy division]

Jnr
Judd
Hird
Dusty
Voss
Bucks


Dusty over Voss simply because he won more in those 3 flags. Bucks last because no premiership

 

[Here we go dogs]

1- Ablett
2- Martin
3- Judd
4- Voss
5- Buckley
6- Hird

 

[peetoo]

Are any of them the best ever player at their own clubs? Maybe jnr at Gold Coast lol

 

[STRONGandBALD]

Are any of them the best ever player at their own clubs? Maybe jnr at Gold Coast lol

I personally think Dusty, Voss, Judd and GAJ are.

 

[theasian]

Are any of them the best ever player at their own clubs? Maybe jnr at Gold Coast lol

Buckley probably at Collingwood, in competition with Bob Rose, Pendles, Swan, G Coventry Tuddenham

Voss if we take Brisbane Lions only.

If we include Fitzroy as well it's between him and Bunton snr, Kevin Murray, Gary Wilson, Quinlan etc

Martin in cotention with Bartlett, Dyer and Hart for Richmond.

Judd in contention for WCE with Matera, Cousins, Cox etc.

Hird was 3rd at the Champions of Essendon selction in 2002.

 

[JackFlash]

Ablett Jr
Hird
Martin
Voss
Judd
Buckley

Pendlebury*
Selwood*
Goodes*
Black*

 

[Walshawk]

Judd
Ablett
Voss
Buckley
Martin
Hird

 

[FairKouta]

Wc Judd was the best there ever was I’m sorry but no one comes close

 

[Shooter#17]

Martin is so far below the other 5 it's ridiculous.

 

[gungho]

GAJ.
JUDD
BUDDY
...................
MARTIN
VOSS
GOODES
FYFE
HIRD
DANGER
BUCKLEY

 

[Shooter#17]

1. Chris Judd (7-15)
2. Gary Ablett Jnr (7-15)
-------------------
3. Michael Voss (15-20)
4. Nathan Buckley (20-30)
5. James Hird (20-30)
6. Ben Cousins (20-30)
7. Robert Harvey (25-35)
8. Mark Riccuito (30-40)
9. Adam Goodes (30-40)
10. Dustin Martin (40-50)
11. Scott Pendlebury (40-50)
12. Simon Black (45-60)
13. Sam Mitchell (50-70)
14. Joel Selwood (60-80)

Cousins way too high

 

[Shooter#17]

They aren’t as good. I’ve been telling you this for a while now. But you’re still in denial.

All are far superior players to martin

 

[darcytiger]

Gary Ablett Jnr, Nathan Buckley, James Hird. Chris Judd, Dustin Martin, Michael Voss.

Voss
GAJ
Martin
Judd
Buckley
Hird

Very happy to flip Martin and Judd, happy with the rest of them.

 

[darcytiger]

Also, Hird - lol

 

[theasian]

Also, Hird - lol

Dont' rate him?