Rank your team

[Juddernaut08]

1. Bont
2. Naughton
3. Macrae
4. Smith
5. English
6. Dunkley
7. Hunter
8. Williams
9. JJ
10. Crozier
11. Daniel
12. Keath
13. Wallis
14. Libba
16. Mclean
17. Lipinski
18. Vandermeer
19. Wood
20. Bruce
21. Weightman
22. West
23. Dickson
24. Richards
25. Suckling
26 + the rest

English 5th??

 

[Sttew]

No Harry Taylor and Tom Atkins twice.

That’s why he said “That will do”.

 

[NonPhixion]

1. Dangerfield
2. T.Hawkins
3. Selwood
4. Duncan
5. Blicavs
6. T.Stewart
7. C.Guthrie
8. G.Ablett
9. G.Rohan
10. M.O’Connor
11. R.Stanley
12. J.Bews
13. L.Dahlhaus
14. G.Miers
15. S.Menegola
16. B.Parfitt
17. Z.Tuohy
18. J.Kolodjashnij
19. J.Henry
20. J.Steven
21. J.Clark
22. E.Ratagolea
23. L.Henderson
23. N.Cockatoo
24. Q.Narkle
25. L.Fogarty
26. S.DeKoning
27. J.Jenkins
28. B.Close
29. C.Constable
30. T.Atkins
31. Z.Guthrie
32. D.Fort
33. T.Atkins

That will do

What did Menegola do to you. Possible AA year surely goes higher

 

[year of the cat]

What did Menegola do to you. Possible AA year surely goes higher

One swallow doesn't make a summer. See how he goes in finals where he's been a perennial flop first.

 

[Chaisa]

1. Dane Rampe
2. Isaac Heeney
3. Tom Papley
4. Jake Lloyd
5. Luke Parker
6. Lance Franklin
7. Callum Mills
8. Jordan Dawson
9. Josh P. Kennedy
10. James Rowbottom
11. George Hewett
12. Ollie Florent
13. Tom McCartin
14. Harry Cunningham
15. Will Hayward
16. Robbie Fox
17. Nick Blakey
18. Aliir Aliir
19. Justin McInerney
20. Lewis Melican
21. Sam Reid
22. Callum Sinclair
23. Dylan Stephens
24. Ryan Clarke
25. Hayden McLean
26. Jackson Thurlow
27. Lewis Taylor
28. Colin O'Riordan
29. Sam Wicks
30. Kaiden Brand
31. Sam Naismith
32. James Bell
33. Sam Grey
34. Matt Ling
35. Ben Ronke
36. Elijah Taylor
37. Chad Warner
38. Ryley Stoddart
39. Zac Foot
40. Joel Amartey
41+. unplayed dudes

 

[Power Raid]

1. Boak
2. Butters
3. Dixon
4. Byrne-Jones
5. Jonas
6. Wines
7. Hartlett
8. Clurey
9. McKenzie
10. Powell-Pepper
11. Amon
12. Houston
13. Lycett
14. Rockliff
15. Ladhams
16. Marshall
17. Rozee
18. Duursma
19. Ebert
20. Burton
21. Westhoff
22. Bonner
23. Georgiades
24. Mayes
25. Lienert
26. Woodcock
27. Farrell
28. Sutcliffe
28.
29. Motlop

 

[Shaunbkk]

Based on who may be with us and where they may sit next season.
1. Doedee
2. O'Brien
3. Laird
4. Milera
5. M Crouch
6. Keays
7. Sloane
8. Schoenberg
9. Sholl
10. McPherson
11. Smith
12. McAdam
13. Talia
14. Himmelberg
15. Brown
16. Fogerty
17. Lynch
18. Hamill
19. Worrall
20. McAsey
21. Jones
22. Walker
23. Hartigan
24. Kelly

 

[HairyO]

Based on who may be with us and where they may sit next season.
1. Doedee
2. O'Brien
3. Laird
4. Milera
5. M Crouch
6. Keays
7. Sloane
8. Schoenberg
9. Sholl
10. McPherson
11. Smith
12. McAdam
13. Talia
14. Himmelberg
15. Brown
16. Fogerty
17. Lynch
18. Hamill
19. Worrall
20. McAsey
21. Jones
22. Walker
23. Hartigan
24. Kelly

Scholl McAdam and Himmelberg could well end next year higher.

 

[gungho]

Not a huge fan of rankings because we all see through different eyes, but what the hell time is slow at the moment.

1: M. Bontempelli
2: J. Macrae
3: B. Smith
4: A. Naughton
5: A. Keath
6: B. Williams
7: H. Crozier
8: T. English
9: C. Daniel
10: L. Hunter
11: J. Johannisen
12: T. Liberatore
13: M. Wallis
14: J. Dunkley
15: L. Vandermeer
16: T. McLean
17: T. Duryea
18: E. Wood
19: Z. Cordy
20: P. Lipinski
21: M. Suckling
22: S. Lloyd
23: J. Bruce
24: B. Dale
25: E. Richards
26: R. West
27: J. Schache
28: T. Dickson
29: W. Hayes
30: R. Smith
- Rest -

A couple of widgets and subtle game style adjustments short of greatness.

I'm an outsider but surely Daniel is better than Crozier?

 

[flipper83]

1. Bont
2. Naughton
3. Macrae
4. Smith
5. English
6. Dunkley
7. Hunter
8. Williams
9. JJ
10. Crozier
11. Daniel
12. Keath
13. Wallis
14. Libba
16. Mclean
17. Lipinski
18. Vandermeer
19. Wood
20. Bruce
21. Weightman
22. West
23. Dickson
24. Richards
25. Suckling
26 + the rest

Libba hugely underrated

 

[flipper83]

I'm an outsider but surely Daniel is better than Crozier?

Crozier has been huge for us, unlucky not to be all Australian last year.
He defends, intercepts and rebounds.
Daniel only really has one weapon and it is an amazing weapon but I'd also have him behind Crozier

 

[Arctic fox]

Rank my team? OK. My team is rank.

 

[eaglespremiers]

I presume that you mean in general and not specifically for this season. I have left out Rioli and Venables.
1. Nic Naitanui
2. Josh Kennedy
3. Luke Shuey
4. Elliot Yeo
5. Jeremy McGovern
6. Jack Darling
7. Liam Ryan
8. Tim Kelly
9. Brad Sheppard
10. Dom Sheed
11. Tom Barrass
12. Andrew Gaff
13. Shannon Hurn
14. Oscar Allen
15. Jack Redden
16. Liam Duggan
17. Jake Waterman
18. Tom Cole
19. Jamie Cripps
20. Will Schofield
21. Jackson Nelson
22. Lewis Jetta
23. Bailey Williams
24. Brendon Ah Chee
25. Tom Hickey
26. Josh Rotham
27. Jarrod Brander
28. Jack Petruccelle
29. Nathan Vardy
30. Mark Hutchings
31. Xavier O'Neill
32. Francis Watson
33. Jarrod Cameron
34. Harry Edwards
35. Jamaine Jones
36. Callum Jamieson
37. Brayden Ainsworth
38. Anthony Treacy
39. Nic Ried
40. Hamish Brayshaw
41. Mitch O'Neill
42. Ben Johnson

Specifically for the 2020 season:
1. Nic Naitanui
2. Liam Ryan
3. Brad Sheppard
4. Tim Kelly
5. Josh Kennedy
6. Tom Barrass
7. Andrew Gaff

 

[gungho]

Crozier has been huge for us, unlucky not to be all Australian last year.
He defends, intercepts and rebounds.
Daniel only really has one weapon and it is an amazing weapon but I'd also have him behind Crozier

Fair enough, he must have improved a lot from his time at the dockes

 

[gungho]

Top 30 if all fit on current form.
Fyfe
Walters
Ryan
Pearce
Taberner
Mundy
Brayshaw
Cerra
Hogan
Logue
Hamling
Serong
Wilson
Cox
Tucker
Darcy
Conca
Aish
Sturt
Young
Schultz
Duman
Acres
Frederick
Lobb
Hill
Swttoski
Bewely
Blakely
Henry

 

[Yojimbo]

I'm an outsider but surely Daniel is better than Crozier?

I have unique views on my team and football in general and yes you are right Caleb Daniel is ranked higher than Hayden Crozier, but is he more easily replaced in terms of general structure and overall game performance that is what i look at. The ball is either in the air or on the ground and Caleb has a Harry Styles tattoo on his right butt cheek.

 

[Virgin Dog]

1. Bont
2. Libba
3. Macrae
4. Naughton
5. Hunter
6. Dunkley
7. Daniel
8. Crozier
9. Wallis
10. Smith
11. Keath
12. Williams
13. English
14. McLean
15. JJ
16. Lipinski
17. Bruce
18. Vandermeer
19. Cordy
20. Wood
21. Jong
22. Dale

 

[Jcpdragonx]

1. Laird
2. Doedee
3. ROB
4. MCrouch
5. Talia
6. BCrouch
7. Keays
8. Himmelberg
9. McAdam
10. B. Smith (regressed)
11. Brown
12. Sloane (regressed)
13. Milera
14. Seedsman
15. Hartigan
16. MacKay
17. Lynch (regressed)
18. McPherson
19. Sholl
20. Stengle
21. Shoenberg
22. Hamil

Not graded: Fogarty, Walker, Jones, McHenry, McAsey, Murphy

 

[flipper83]

Bont

Dunkley
Libba
Hunter
B Smith
Macrae

Naughton
Crozier
Williams
Daniel
English
Wallis
Keath

Maclean
JJ
Durea
Cordy

Vandermeer
Lipinski
Richards
Bruce
Dale

West
R Smith
Lachie young
Wood
Jong
Suckling
Schache
Butler
Lewis young
Trengrove
Lloyd

Gardner
Hayes
Weightman
Green
Cavarra
Gowers
Lynch
Dickson
Porter

Yet to play
Garcia
Khamis
Sweet

Was actually a difficult task.

Feel like Macrae is probably too low but you could throw a blanket over 2-6 and I feel like you just don't notice Macraes possessions as much as the ones ahead of him.

Expect Naughton to be higher next year but too inconsistent at the moment.

The bottom of the list is interesting with a mix of players who have shown a lot of promise but dropped away, players who are fairly limited but get games as role players and players who I think are decent players but can't get a game in our system.

 

[EB&W Pieman]

Interesting exercise

Our top eleven - down to Crisp - are terrific; the next eight - down to Noble - are fine AFL standard players, but after that it does drop off.


Grundy
Moore
De Goey
Pendlebury
Howe
Adams
Meynard
Sidebottom
Treloar
Crisp
Elliott
Daicos
Cox
Stephenson
Quaynor
Roughead
Mihocek
Noble
Sier
Madgen
T Brown
Phillips
Hoskin-Elliott
Greenwood
Wills
Varcoe
Reid
C Brown
Scharenberg. (Regretfully)
Thomas
Cameron
Lynch
Appleby
Broomhead

The reminder are either Dayne Beams, or well past their prime or too new to rate, or Irish.

 

[Philth]

1. Martin
2. Grimes
3. Lynch
4. Cotchin
5. Riewoldt
6. Vlastuin
7. Edwards
8. Prestia
9. Houli
10. Balta
11. Bolton
12. Lambert
13. Baker
14. Short
15. Graham
16. Castagna
17. Soldo
18. Rioli
19. Caddy
20. Nankveris
21. Astbury
22. McIntosh
23. Chol
24. Broad
25. Ross
26. Higgins
27. Aarts
28. Markov
29. Pickett
30. Stack


There is our top 30

Pretty good list.
But I'd have Edwards at #3.

 

[Shaunbkk]

Scholl McAdam and Himmelberg could well end next year higher.

Totally agree. I guess I gave minimum expectations.

 

[austinnn]

Clark
Steele
Marshall
Gresham
Butler
Battle
Ryder
Jones
King
Membrey
Sinclair
Billings
Carlisle
Howard
Coffield
Long
Wilkie
Lonie
Paton
Hill
Hanneberry
Bytel
Kent
Hind
Marsh
Ross
Dunstan
Parker
Geary
Phillips
Roberton
Webster
Brown
Mackenzie
Langlands
Savage
Austin
Abbott
Joyce

IMO obviously. 2020 form prioritised but not exclusive. Leaving out players with an AFL career of less than 3 senior games.

 

[AndysAngels]

1 Naitanui
2 Yeo
3 Gov
4 Sheppard
5 Shuey
6 Gaff
7 Kennedy
8 Darling
9 Ryan
10 Kelly

11 Redden
12 Sheed
13 Cripps
14 Duggan
15 Hurn
16 Barrass

17 Allen
18 Waterman
19 Cole
20 Nelson
21 Schofield
22 Jetta
23 Hutchings
24 Rotham
25 Ah Chee

26 Brander
27 Hickey
28 Vardy
29 Cameron
30 Jones
31 Williams
32 XON
33 Petruccelle
34 Ainsworth
35 Watson
36 Edwards
37 Brayshaw
38 Foley
39 Reid

Pretty clear top 10 for me. Feels harsh to have player of the finals in 2018 Redden at 11, but i think our top 10 is very strong. I've picked on a set of pretty arbitrary criteria, but I guess these ranks mostly reflects my thoughts on their importance to the team.

Rioli and Venables not included; Rioli slots in at #9, Venables #20

Patron thoughts? Ryan at 9 feels harsh; will go top 4 or 5 in our B&F, but tough to put him any higher

 

[eaglespremiers]

1 Naitanui
2 Yeo
3 Gov
4 Sheppard
5 Shuey
6 Gaff
7 Kennedy
8 Darling
9 Ryan
10 Kelly

11 Redden
12 Sheed
13 Cripps
14 Duggan
15 Hurn
16 Barrass

17 Allen
18 Waterman
19 Cole
20 Nelson
21 Schofield
22 Jetta
23 Hutchings
24 Rotham
25 Ah Chee

26 Brander
27 Hickey
28 Vardy
29 Cameron
30 Jones
31 Williams
32 XON
33 Petruccelle
34 Ainsworth
35 Watson
36 Edwards
37 Brayshaw
38 Foley
39 Reid

Pretty clear top 10 for me. Feels harsh to have player of the finals in 2018 Redden at 11, but i think our top 10 is very strong. I've picked on a set of pretty arbitrary criteria, but I guess these ranks mostly reflects my thoughts on their importance to the team.

Rioli and Venables not included; Rioli slots in at #9, Venables #20

Patron thoughts? Ryan at 9 feels harsh; will go top 4 or 5 in our B&F, but tough to put him any higher

Gee Barrass at 16 is tough.