Rate a nice Pies player: Alan Didak.
Rate or Unrate?
Rate or Unrate?
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Rate a Scum: Alan Didak.
- Thread starter Ricketts
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
- Banned
- #4
AVA-182 said:Alan Didak, V's Geelong 2005.
Kicks: 12
HBalls: 4
Disposals: 16
Goals: 5
Yup. Ive always rated him. Wouldnt be the classiest bloke 3am on a saturday night but I would take him
- Banned
- #6
Nick Stevens>Alan Didak.
- Banned
- #9
Soft player who is a great opportunist but not as good as Nick Stevens.
- Jun 23, 2004
- 13,506
- 38
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Great skills on either side, cheeky player, loves to do the unpredictable, kicks some of the more 'clever' goals. Should go into the midfield in 2006, as he was a star in that position for the Port Magpies at a young age.
Expecting big things in 2006.
Expecting big things in 2006.
AVA-182 said:Alan Didak, V's Geelong 2005.
Kicks: 12
HBalls: 4
Disposals: 16
Goals: 5
That game got you into the finals race did'nt it?
Where did you guys finish on the ladder?
This guy is a scum bag. Totally agree with the title of the thread. He is a little germ in the football world, with saying that he does have good skills and can clearly turn a game. I would still not have him in a Geelong Jumper.
He is one of the few remaining dirty players.
One of my most hater players. He is just behind Jeff Farmer.
Only Collingwood fans rate him.
- Banned
- #13
Ah, ya gotta love those players that generally underperform all year but put in a blinder against your team. Another one for the Cats is that Leigh Harding of the Kangaroos. Seems to bob up every time we play them with a good game.
DOH
DOH
slow, unaccountable outside player without an engine but with good kicking skills...pass
His body will never be able to withstand the rigours of playing in the midfield.
A poor mans Stuart Dew
His body will never be able to withstand the rigours of playing in the midfield.
A poor mans Stuart Dew
cypher said:
I will admit I had exactly the same opinion after the 2003 Gf and could not believe we gave up the chance to get stevens ahead of him I was as mad as hell with his Soft efforts that day . But my opinion is starting to change. He has learnt to put his body on the line (see broken jaw against geelong in 2004 when backed into player)
He has had some really unlucky setbacks but whenever he came into the side this year showed he had improved in leaps and bounds and made a real difference .
I think Stevens is definately a better player at the moment but will never be a game breaker which is something Didak was on more than one occassion this year. Mark Williams was right on the money when he said Stevens gets lots of easy kicks accross half back.
Time will tell but I think he may prove quite a few people wrong in the next few years.
And god help him if he dosn't have a better career then Stuart(1 good game every 5 weeks)Dew
- Nov 27, 2005
- 47
- 0
- Other Teams
- Neutral
- Banned
- #16
I didnt see you guys in the Grand Final. I heard you cracked in the PFthehoff said:
Ricketts you're just jealous he shat all over Geelong. Too good for you
- Aug 9, 2005
- 5,624
- 12
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
blaisee said:
LOL, you rate Stuart Dew.
- Aug 9, 2005
- 5,624
- 12
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
topdon said:
I think it is only ignorant Collingwood haters that dont rate him mate.
Absolute gun of footballer, i wish we could get him at North so we could dispose of Thurley and Harding.
Pie 4 Life
Hall of Famer
Alan Didak > Carltoncypher said:Nick Stevens>Alan Didak.
HeLMie said:
Exactly, people are pathetic, if a player is good i will rate him, don't let your hatorade get in the way. One of the classiest players in the league (skills wise) and will do some serious damage to the brownlow count if he can a) get over his chronic knee soreness b) get a serious pre season in c) play all year.
When Didak was fit last year Collingwood won games. When he was out they didn’t. This year will be decisive for him. A good pre season and no excuses. I think he will shut a few up but he has it all to do yet, like a few of his team mates.
As for Stevens, well I know who won more games for their club last year and that was from limited opportunities. I was never interested in the Stevens deal and have not wished we made the trade since. I doubt we’d have won a single extra game with Stevens in our midfield. I know we have won games due to Didak on one leg in the forward line.
As for Stevens, well I know who won more games for their club last year and that was from limited opportunities. I was never interested in the Stevens deal and have not wished we made the trade since. I doubt we’d have won a single extra game with Stevens in our midfield. I know we have won games due to Didak on one leg in the forward line.
Re: Rate a nice Pies player: Alan Didak.
now common just because he had a thing with your mum and sister, oh yeah and the day in 05 when he tore gfc a new one, is no reason for a thread like this
RATERicketts said:
now common just because he had a thing with your mum and sister, oh yeah and the day in 05 when he tore gfc a new one, is no reason for a thread like this
- Status
Similar threads
- Poll
