Rate my team for 2010 (cont)

[ishka29]

BACKS:

Brendon Goddard
Jack Grimes
Sam Gilbert
Jarrod Harbrow
Andrejs Everitt
Tadhg Kennelly
Matthew Broadbent

Jackson Trengove
Phil Davis

MIDFIELDERS

Jimmy Bartel
Lenny Hayes
Joel Selwood
Brett Deledio
David Armitage
Jack Trengove


Dustin Martin
Ryan Bastinac

RUCKS

Kurt Tippet
Jesse White

Robbie Warnock
Matthew Lobbe

FORWARDS

Nick Riewoldt
Matthew Pavlich
Chris Knights
Robbie Gray
Patrick Dangerfield
Scott Gumbleton
Ben Reid

Luke Tapscott
Trent Dennis-Lane

Thoughts??

 

[Dimitri_Mishkin]

I love it when there's 4 consecutive posts where no one rates anyone elses teams and just posts their own. Good luck getting rated guys.

 

[foley_falcon]

i have the greatest team ever but im not telling anyone what it is!

 

[snomeD]

feedback? Have i picked up any injured players?

 

[snomeD]

Hey Guys, I've tried something a little different this year (for the time being). What are your thoughts???

BACKS:



Brad Sheppard



MIDFIELDERS


Jack Trengove
Dustin Martin
Anthony Morabito


THOUGHTS PLEASE

These players will definitly play but they are young bodies, they will not all play 22 games this year. This is going to cost you trades or 0 scores. You need to downgrade 2-3 of your premiums and smartly pick more mid priced players

 

[snomeD]

Here is my go:

Def: B.Goddard, J.Kelly, M.Firrito, R.Hayden, N.Malceski, T.Kennelly, B.Waters, (M.Magiuer, A.Silvagni)

Mid: G.Ablett, L.Montagna, C.Masten, J.Ziebell, T.Scully, D.Martin (J.Trengrove, L.Shuey)

Ruck: A.Sandilands, M.Kreuzer (S.Grimley, S.Mcnamara)

Forward: A.Goodes, J.Brown, M.Pavlich, L.Franklin, C.Rioli, J.Kennedy, P.Dangerfield (L.Tapscott, N. Fyfe)

I think you can pick better players for Kelly's price such as Cornes, Shaw, Mackie, or even C.Johnson if Carlton stop playing him as a KPP.

Sydney are historically poor Dream Team scorers, and you have Malceski who has been poor since his knee injury and Kennelly was never a great DT scorer. Waters is also coming back from injury and may take a while to post some decent scores.

T.Scully, D.Martin and J.Trengrove will play games and score well but i wouldn't expect Scully and Trengove to play more than 15 games each this year.

I like your forward line, but Kennedy is currently recovering from injury and Dangerfield is a bit of an unknown. If he can find some more space and take more marks his scores will increase dramatically.

 

[snomeD]

Backs:
Duffield, Gilbee, Hurn, O Brien, Polo, Suban, Kenelly (Sheppard, Davis)

Midfield:
Cross, Ray, Hodge, Ball, Trengrove, Martin (Morabito, Shuey)

Ruck:
Jolly, Kreuzer (Charman, Warnock)

Forwards:
Goodes, Pavlich, Lecras, Tippett, Hahn, Williams, Dangerfield (Moore, Gumbleton)


Thoughts?

Decent effort but you're backline is too weak. O'Brien, Polo, Suban Kennelly... not good enough. History tells us you need a strong and reliable backline to post consistent scores.
You've done well picking Hahn. He is a good DTer for his price and if Lecras plays as well in the midfield as he did in the forward line last year then you'll be laughing

 

[blast]

Hey guys, just wondering if anybody feels like rating my team.

Be as critical as possible, thanks

$2,800 left over.

 

[Axel.]

[B]B:[/B] Heath Shaw      - Jarrad Waite    - Lindsay Gilbee
[B]HB:[/B] Luke Hodge     - Brendon Goddard - Tadhg Kennelly
[B]C:[/B] Adam Goodes     - Shaun Higgins   - Bradd Dalziell
[B]HF:[/B] Jarrad McVeigh - Nick Riewoldt   - Jason Porplyzia
[B]F:[/B] Mark LeCras     - Matthew Pavlich - Cyril Rioli
[B]Foll:[/B] Brad Ottens,   Daniel Kerr,      Jack Ziebell
[B]INT:[/B] David Hille, Pat Dangerfield, Dan Hannebery, Beau Waters

[B]EMG:[/B] Rob Warnock, Dustin Martin, Brad Sheppard
[B]Others:[/B] Phil Davis, Luke Shuey, Matt Lobbe, 
        Trent Dennis-Lane, James Podsiadly

With 27,400 left over. Thoughts? Improvements that could be made?

That's really confusing.

feedback? Have i picked up any injured players?

Martin, Ladson and Warnock are injured.

Hey guys, just wondering if anybody feels like rating my team.

Be as critical as possible, thanks

$2,800 left over.

IMO downgrade Duffield for someone like Suban then upgrade Greenwood or Hunt.

 

[ppops1984]

Hey guys, some help needed.

Just read that Ladson is injured.....how bad is it and who should I replace him with?

Any other thoughts at all?

 

[Axel.]

Hey guys, some help needed.

Just read that Ladson is injured.....how bad is it and who should I replace him with?

Any other thoughts at all?

That's a good team.

Only thing is Franklin won't play round 1 and keep an eye out for Hurley.

 

[WeninRome]

Hey guys, some help needed.

Just read that Ladson is injured.....how bad is it and who should I replace him with?

Any other thoughts at all?

not a bad effort..my thoughts are as follows

backs - gilbee and hurley - think there are better options available..both are more suited to super coach.

replace ladson with maybe drum or broadbent

mids are good but i think ablett is over priced at the minute...gibbs will struggle in the first three games, cotchin is yet to prove he is durable in the slightest and rich is expenesive for not much more upside in scoring...love the choice of prismal though.

Rucks are solid but i am not sold on mumford...wait on nab cup for that

forwards are strong but maybe replace medhurst and upgrade gumby as i just don't trust him to play enough gaems to earn you cash.

Richard douglas is the same price as medhurst adn i think he has way more upside.

 

[_RT_]

BACKS:

Brendon Goddard
Jack Grimes
Sam Gilbert
Jarrod Harbrow
Andrejs Everitt
Tadhg Kennelly
Matthew Broadbent

Jackson Trengove
Phil Davis

MIDFIELDERS

Jimmy Bartel
Lenny Hayes
Joel Selwood
Brett Deledio
David Armitage
Jack Trengove


Dustin Martin
Ryan Bastinac

RUCKS

Kurt Tippet
Jesse White

Robbie Warnock
Matthew Lobbe

FORWARDS

Nick Riewoldt
Matthew Pavlich
Chris Knights
Robbie Gray
Patrick Dangerfield
Scott Gumbleton
Ben Reid

Luke Tapscott
Trent Dennis-Lane

Thoughts??

Everitt is a unique pick and someone I'm sure wont be in many teams, same thing applies to Reid. Make sure both are locked into their sides best 22 during the NAB Cup.

Also find your midfield interesting, if Armitage comes off you could get away with just one more upgrade to finalise your midfield.

Apart from this looks to be a very even line up.

 

[_RT_]

BACKS:

Brendon Goddard
Jack Grimes
Sam Gilbert
Jarrod Harbrow
Andrejs Everitt
Tadhg Kennelly
Matthew Broadbent

Jackson Trengove
Phil Davis

MIDFIELDERS

Jimmy Bartel
Lenny Hayes
Joel Selwood
Brett Deledio
David Armitage
Jack Trengove


Dustin Martin
Ryan Bastinac

RUCKS

Kurt Tippet
Jesse White

Robbie Warnock
Matthew Lobbe

FORWARDS

Nick Riewoldt
Matthew Pavlich
Chris Knights
Robbie Gray
Patrick Dangerfield
Scott Gumbleton
Ben Reid

Luke Tapscott
Trent Dennis-Lane

Thoughts??

My only advice would be to make sure that Everitt White Gumbleton & Reid are locked into their sides best 22's during the NAB Cup if they are then as unique picks they could pay off well for you.

 

[_RT_]

Latest Lineup:

Backs - Goddard Hodge H.Shaw S.Selwood Suban Greenwood Broadbent Davis Webberley
Mids - Ablett Pendlebury J.Selwood Deledio Trengove Martin Shuey Bastinac
Rucks - Kreuzer Mumford Lobbe Trengove
Forwards - Riewoldt ROK Sylvia LeCras Ziebell Polkinghorne Dangerfield Tapscott TDL

Leftover: $10,900.

 

[WeninRome]

thoughts on my team please?

Changes to be made - may bring in waite depending on fitness
may drop hille depending on fitness
may drop armatige dependent on team selection.
$63k in the bank

 

[Axel.]

Latest Lineup:

Backs - Goddard Hodge H.Shaw S.Selwood Suban Greenwood Broadbent Davis Webberley
Mids - Ablett Pendlebury J.Selwood Deledio Trengove Martin Shuey Bastinac
Rucks - Kreuzer Mumford Lobbe Trengove
Forwards - Riewoldt ROK Sylvia LeCras Ziebell Polkinghorne Dangerfield Tapscott TDL

Leftover: $10,900.

I like this team but not sure about Broadbent and if he'll play 22 games.

But the rest is good.

 

[OneEyedPie7]

I like this team but not sure about Broadbent and if he'll play 22 games.

But the rest is good.

It won't matter that Broadbent plays 22 games unless you are looking to turn him into a low-end keeper, which I very much doubt he is.

 

[cryptor]

Any thoughts on my team? I have $22.5K left to play with. I'm pretty happy with what I've got, the only thing that is really bugging me is if I should be replacing some of these players with others that are within $10K give or take.

 

[Axel.]

Hey guys.

What do you think about this? Got 75k left.

 

[nicK_]

this is my DT for 2010, Please tell me ur thoughts of my team any help or hints would be great
thanks

have 46k left over

 

[xsmilekid]

Backs:
R Shaw, Gilbee, Hurn, Newman, Grima, Suban, Kenelly (Sheppard, Davis)

Midfield:
Cross, Ray, Hodge, Ball, Trengrove, Martin (Morabito, Shuey)

Ruck:
Jolly, Kreuzer (Charman, Warnock)

Forwards:
Goodes, Pavlich, Lecras, Tippett, Hahn, Williams, Dangerfield (Moore, Gumbleton)


I've replaced Duffield with R Shaw, Polo with Grima, PoloO Brien with Newman

4.9k left in the bank.
Still not happy with my backline/midfield though, any advice or suggestions?
love lecras btw (yes im a girl)

 

[_RT_]

Hey guys.

What do you think about this? Got 75k left.

Not bad just think that you've got too many rookies starting on the ground. Martin is the only one who I would say is a good chance of debuting in round 1. Also with White I'd be careful as he wont be rucking and with Bradshaw the likely FF White might not get as much of a look in as he was towards the end of last season.

 

[Axel.]

Not bad just think that you've got too many rookies starting on the ground. Martin is the only one who I would say is a good chance of debuting in round 1. Also with White I'd be careful as he wont be rucking and with Bradshaw the likely FF White might not get as much of a look in as he was towards the end of last season.

Thanks for that Tiger.

 

[Frozenwaste]

Rip it apart,