Rate my team for 2010 (cont)

[Hawks92]

Unsure about Hille in the ruck, will track his progress. Liam Shiels is my little ripper

 

[Axel.]

I like your forward line but doubt Watts will play a lot of games.

Dal Santo is a massive no no. He'll get tagged and score 20 points maybe downgrade him and upgrade Ladson/Hunt.

 

[Hawks92]

I like your forward line but doubt Watts will play a lot of games.

Dal Santo is a massive no no. He'll get tagged and score 20 points maybe downgrade him and upgrade Ladson/Hunt.

Thanks mate, much appreciated. Thought Jack would get some game time and would eventually trade him out. Dal Santo I'm also unsure about, will be easy to find a replacement.

 

[Daitro]

Dal Santo is a massive no no. He'll get tagged and score 20 points maybe downgrade him and upgrade Ladson/Hunt.

Dal Santo sub 80 point games in 2009 = 3
Hayes = 3
J Selwood = 4
Goodes = 6
Pendlebury = 5
Didak = 5

he's in one of the most dominant mid-fields in the competition, which as a unit racks up points at will. he's not a massive no no. he's a 'probably doesn't have much upside'.

 

[Axel.]

Dal Santo sub 80 point games in 2009 = 3
Hayes = 3
J Selwood = 4
Goodes = 6
Pendlebury = 5
Didak = 5

he's in one of the most dominant mid-fields in the competition, which as a unit racks up points at will. he's not a massive no no. he's a 'probably doesn't have much upside'.

Yeah.

But this guy can't handle a simple tag. (Even stiller manged to shut him down to only 16 touches)

Other teams know this and i assume he'll get way more attention than he did last year.

 

[nicK_]

this is my DT for 2010, Please tell me ur thoughts of my team any help or hints would be great
thanks

have 46k left over

any1 able to rate my team give me some tips ta

 

[Axel.]

any1 able to rate my team give me some tips ta

Sure.

Love the rucks.

Mcveigh is a interesting choice see how he does in the NAB Cup and then decide to keep or not.

And Sheppard apparently won't play much in 2010.

 

[Jimi]

Strauss and Blease are placeholders as my bench spots are dependant on NAB cup. Only started working on my team yesterday so will likely change.

 

[Membling]

Jimi:
Backs: solid but not completely sold on goose or waters see how preseason goes, maybe a rookie for one of them?
Mids: Goodes is a strange choice as he is playing CHF, good choice for a forward but more pure midfielders to choose at his price. Have a look at Balastic and Shuey for ressies, more potential to play
Rucks: Not sold on tippett with kruezer being more solid and consistent in scores atm, feeling the Charman may not be best bet for second mid
Forwards: Maybe change Sylvia to ROK as he has more mid time also buchanan is not the best value at that range, maybe hurley or ben warren if he gets the nod

 

[yogibbear]

I'm happy if no one else is prepared to take the risk on Morton. For me he is the only lock in my midfield. I don't even like melbourne. Though i suck at DT so....... take my teams/advice with a grain of salt, throw it into the ocean and then get a glass, dip it in and chuck it through a filter.

Yeah i see he's expensive, and technically not that experience and in a crappy side where any talent will be targetted with tags... but whatever. Someone has to touch the ball. And in DT it doesn't matter if they touch it and kick it to the opposition. Preferrably someone that does lots of turn overs is even better cause then they'll have a chance of going in for the mark+kick+tackle+handball+receive+goal combo.

 

[Jimi]

Jimi:
Backs: solid but not completely sold on goose or waters see how preseason goes, maybe a rookie for one of them?
Mids: Goodes is a strange choice as he is playing CHF, good choice for a forward but more pure midfielders to choose at his price. Have a look at Balastic and Shuey for ressies, more potential to play
Rucks: Not sold on tippett with kruezer being more solid and consistent in scores atm, feeling the Charman may not be best bet for second mid
Forwards: Maybe change Sylvia to ROK as he has more mid time also buchanan is not the best value at that range, maybe hurley or ben warren if he gets the nod

Waiting on Nab cup re Waters and Goose.
Goodes was a toss up, liked him because I could sub him with dangerfield when its time for dangerfield to be upgraded. I traded him out for Selwood for now.
Kreuzer/charman I'll wait and see.
Sylvia can average 100+ is having a great pre season and Buchanan is likely to play in the midfield more - also like him as a unique pick.
Anyway thanks for the feedback. I'll keep working on it!

 

[yogibbear]

Backs:
R Shaw, Gilbee, Newman, Russell, Hurn, Buckley, Sheppard (Mcguire, Davis)

Centres:
Boyd, Prismall, Hodge, Ball, Trengrove, Martin (Morabito, Shuey)

Rucks:
Jolly, Kreuzer (Charman, Warnock)

Forwards:
Goodes, Pavlich, Lecras, Gray, Hahn, Tippett, Dangerfield (Moore, Gumbleton)

Any thoughts? Love to hear some advice

Prismall. Hot stuff. I'd never pick him though. Good on you for being different.

Boyd. Absolute stunner. Amazing. Will win you games in eliminator etc. etc. when the usual ABC fail.

Goodes. I hate him. (Eagles fan) Have never had him in my side. Once lost in a DT final with Judd vs. Goodes or something ridiculous like that. Yeah he's got brownlow's and so fourth but is he fit? Will he last 22 vs. other players his price? Is there enough upside?

Newman. Wanted him in my backline. Couldn't fit him in with all the mid pricers. I think he might just have gotten over being a captain and might do something crazy. Could be the next premium back to join Goddard/Enright/Hodge/Hargrave(?)... Especially if he grabs lots of rebounds as the richmond forward line fails and pumps lots of rebound attacks back at him.

 

[captn carlton]

my team so far ......
some help would be great !!! unsure of mackie and blake (backline)
also no big names in the midfield ? what ya's think .....
cheers

 

[Alpha Male]

What's the deal with Sheppard and Moore?

Everyone seemed to be all over these 2 in the backline as either a 7th back or an emg but now people are jumping ship? Any reason to this?

I have Sheppard on my bench but do people really think someone like Trengrove (Port) would be a better option to save some $$$ ???

My team:

BACKS: Goddard, Fisher, Hodge, McPhee, Suban, Kennelly, Hunt (Sheppard, Davis)
MIDS: Selwood, Goodes, Cooney, Swift, Wells, Trengrove (Morabito, Bastinac)
RUCKS: Ottens, Hille (Warnock, Lobbe)
FWDS:Riewoldt, Pavlich, Giansiracusa, Franklin, Waite, Ziebell, Dangerfield (Dennis-Lane, Walsh)

 

[Jars458]

Heaps of upside in that team but with it goes some risk

Blake and Betts would be my main concern. Can't see them improving much.

 

[captn carlton]

Heaps of upside in that team but with it goes some risk

Blake and Betts would be my main concern. Can't see them improving much.

yeah was thinking blake for hurn ?
and betts for ziebell ?
also what risks you thinking of ?
cheers !

 

[Jan Juc]

Backs:
Carrazzo, Hodge, Shaw, Ellis, Broadbent, Myers, Ladson (Maguire, Davis)
Mids:
Boyd, Goddard, Goodes, Cooney, Trengove, Martin (Cunnington, Shuey)
Rucks:
Jolly, Kreuzer (Warnock, Lobbe)
Forwards:
O'Keefe, Pavlich, Franklin, McPhee, Gray, Ziebell, Dangerfield (Gumbleton, Tapscott)

Colours indicate DP players.


Hodge and Shaw, given their new roles, can't really be passed up IMO - Shaw getting tagged / taken out of games will be a thing of the past. Ellis's pricing I liken to Cooney's this year. The trio of Broadbent, Myers and Ladson probably won't see R1 - can't really see anyone jagging 3/3 of these types of picks. Davis provides B/F flexibility, whilst Maguire has been chosen simply by being a big, mature body that has been recriuted to a new club - that said, a rookie will be $20k cheaper.

My first four mids I hope will average 100 each - not than unreasonable an expectation I would've thought. Boyd is the solid, low-StDev, week-in-week in 100ppg player that's played every game since R16, 2005. Cooney I feel is massively under-priced. Goddard and Goodes have purposely been selected as Mids as I believe they can justify their places there (104 & 99 averages in '09), yet provide increased flexibilty and insurance given their DP. Of the rookies, I've dodged Scully on purpose and will monitor NAB Cup, with Cunnington's spot possibly the shakiest.

I've been sold on Sandi & Kreuzer all Pre-Season, yet have warmed to Jolly of late. Lobbe could well be the most popular selection by serious DTers, and I'm strangely happy to spend the extra $$ on Warnock instead of the usual $77k wasted 4th ruck.

Gray, Ziebell and Dangerfield I liken to my 5/6/7 defenders, again, jagging three from three of these types is nigh on impossible. Of these, I'm keenest on Ziebell. Medhurst & Mayne have also been in and out. ROK and Pav are my consistent premiums, Buddy can't be passed up on (out for R1) and McPhee, whilst not 110% sold on - is my DP for Davis in the backline. Gumbleton has about as much chance as being in my R1 team as Matty Stokes, and Tapscott seems the best of the rookies.

Still have $50k in the bank.


Critique away guys - cheers.

 

[Hawks92]

Some valuable information there mate ^

Not even my team, but thanks for the info

 

[captn carlton]

i like your theory on matt maguire ! might swap him for Sheppard (WCE) and give 30k odd in the kitty ............

 

[BACCS]

Backs:
Carrazzo, Hodge, Shaw, Ellis, Broadbent, Myers, Ladson (Maguire, Davis)
Mids:
Boyd, Goddard, Goodes, Cooney, Trengove, Martin (Cunnington, Shuey)
Rucks:
Jolly, Kreuzer (Warnock, Lobbe)
Forwards:
O'Keefe, Pavlich, Franklin, McPhee, Gray, Ziebell, Dangerfield (Gumbleton, Tapscott)

Colours indicate DP players.


Hodge and Shaw, given their new roles, can't really be passed up IMO - Shaw getting tagged / taken out of games will be a thing of the past. Ellis's pricing I liken to Cooney's this year. The trio of Broadbent, Myers and Ladson probably won't see R1 - can't really see anyone jagging 3/3 of these types of picks. Davis provides B/F flexibility, whilst Maguire has been chosen simply by being a big, mature body that has been recriuted to a new club - that said, a rookie will be $20k cheaper.

My first four mids I hope will average 100 each - not than unreasonable an expectation I would've thought. Boyd is the solid, low-StDev, week-in-week in 100ppg player that's played every game since R16, 2005. Cooney I feel is massively under-priced. Goddard and Goodes have purposely been selected as Mids as I believe they can justify their places there (104 & 99 averages in '09), yet provide increased flexibilty and insurance given their DP. Of the rookies, I've dodged Scully on purpose and will monitor NAB Cup, with Cunnington's spot possibly the shakiest.

I've been sold on Sandi & Kreuzer all Pre-Season, yet have warmed to Jolly of late. Lobbe could well be the most popular selection by serious DTers, and I'm strangely happy to spend the extra $$ on Warnock instead of the usual $77k wasted 4th ruck.

Gray, Ziebell and Dangerfield I liken to my 5/6/7 defenders, again, jagging three from three of these types is nigh on impossible. Of these, I'm keenest on Ziebell. Medhurst & Mayne have also been in and out. ROK and Pav are my consistent premiums, Buddy can't be passed up on (out for R1) and McPhee, whilst not 110% sold on - is my DP for Davis in the backline. Gumbleton has about as much chance as being in my R1 team as Matty Stokes, and Tapscott seems the best of the rookies.

Still have $50k in the bank.


Critique away guys - cheers.

I am having the same dilemmas mate! Although some advice for the foward rookies, Dennis-Lane is expected to play plenty on senior footy at the Swans this year. And I would try moving Goddard into the backs so you can have another premium midfielder, and drop Carrazzo.

 

[Bluetiger]

Hi folks

Wondering which backline is best (Different players are highlighted):

(1) Enright, Gilbee, Hodge, McPhee, Hurn, Greenwood, Sheppard

or

(2) Enright, Gilbee, Hodge, McPhee, Toovey, Greenwood, Kennelly
or

(3) Enright, Gilbee, Hodge, McPhee, S Selwood, Greenwood, Kenelly


Subs for all three are: Davis/Trengrove (pa)

Appreciate thoughts on Toovey also, as haven't seen him in any sides and he very similar in price to S Selwood.

 

[Dimitri_Mishkin]

Prismall. Hot stuff. I'd never pick him though. Good on you for being different.

Boyd. Absolute stunner. Amazing. Will win you games in eliminator etc. etc. when the usual ABC fail.

Goodes. I hate him. (Eagles fan) Have never had him in my side. Once lost in a DT final with Judd vs. Goodes or something ridiculous like that.
Yeah he's got brownlow's and so fourth but is he fit? Will he last 22 vs. other players his price? Is there enough upside?
Newman. Wanted him in my backline. Couldn't fit him in with all the mid pricers. I think he might just have gotten over being a captain and might do something crazy. Could be the next premium back to join Goddard/Enright/Hodge/Hargrave(?)... Especially if he grabs lots of rebounds as the richmond forward line fails and pumps lots of rebound attacks back at him.

I had a quick look on FanFooty and he's missed something like 6 games in 10 years (finals excluded)

 

[happy_eagle]

I reckon we should impose a new rule on this thread, to make it more helpfull, and to stop all this crap cluttering up



You can only post your team, once the previous team has been given feedback
Would definantly free up alot of shit posts on this thread (and this board in general)

 

[Jan Juc]

I reckon we should impose a new rule on this thread, to make it more helpfull, and to stop all this crap cluttering up



You can only post your team, once the previous team has been given feedback
Would definantly free up alot of shit posts on this thread (and this board in general)

My humblest apologies.

In my attempt to not be shit, I added 300+ words of explanation/justification to my team to give an idea of where my head was at, especially as, from what I can see, my plan of holding two DP players (1 x BC, 1 x CF) in my mids is somewhat unique as opposed to general convention of having these players play in their non-mids positions.

I will try not to be shit in the future.

 

[yogibbear]

I had a quick look on FanFooty and he's missed something like 6 games in 10 years (finals excluded)

Yeah i know he's good..... just my WCE goggles on.