Rate my team for 2010 (cont)

[Trav 20]

Anyone?

: Goddard, Enright, Kelly, Hodge, H. Shaw, Ladson, Hunt (Sheppard, Davis)
M: Bartel, Goodes, Watson, Cooney, Martin, Trengove (Shuey, Bastinac)
R: Sandilands, Tippet (Warnock, Trengove)
F: Sylvia, Pavlich, Giansiracusa, Franklin, Dangerfield, Burton, Dennis-Lane (Rockcliff, Tapscott)

I wouldn't have Kelly as his durability is questionable and his role undefined.

Ladson and Hunt have the antenae up as they're coming off injuries. Hunt has never been a high scorer, but I suppose there is some cash to be made if all goes well.

Those in the know say Cooney is a poor Dteamer. Others say that he's primed for his best year. It worries me that he won a Brownlow scoring in the 80's. He may have a great year, but will he average 100 ?

Sylvia is probably a decent choice. I've waxed and waned with him. I doubt he'll improve because 95 was a great score last year and we should have better players around him taking some of the pie. I just don't know. He's a risk I probably won't take, but he's had a great preseason.

Burton has just injured himself and the durability factor is a concern.

All in all a very strong team with some 'ifs', but everyone will have those. No doubt your team changes every day like mine.

 

[Blue Red and Gold]

any hints or advice would be much appreciated

Backs: Goddard Gram Carrazzo Hodge Urchuart Suban Kennelly Ladson Waters

Centres: Ablett Gibbs Kerr Schuey Trengrove Martin Sloane Morrabito

Rucks: Sandilands Natanui Lobbe Warnock

Forwards: Riewoldt Franklin Didak Ziebell Dangerfield Veszpremi Hitchcock Dennis-Lane Gumbleton

Cheers guys

 

[Cosmo Kramer]

any hints or advice would be much appreciated

Backs: Goddard Gram Carrazzo Hodge Urchuart Suban Kennelly Ladson Waters

Centres: Ablett Gibbs Kerr Schuey Trengrove Martin Sloane Morrabito

Rucks: Sandilands Natanui Lobbe Warnock

Forwards: Riewoldt Franklin Didak Ziebell Dangerfield Veszpremi Hitchcock Dennis-Lane Gumbleton

Cheers guys

Downgrade your backline bench, way too much cash used on it at the moment. I would use the extra cash to upgrade 1 or 2 of your mids.

 

[joelselwood#14]

is anyone thinking of starting warnock??
cause if he plays he will be carltons number 1 ruck and wanting kruzer to play CHF

 

[Deport Pedro]

thanks everyone for suggestions and tips: but here is my third team:
Hopefully better, im still worried about my rucks and not 100% on polkinghorne.



and i have 6k Left in the DT bank

 

[Dugong]

thanks everyone for suggestions and tips: but here is my third team:
Hopefully better, im still worried about my rucks and not 100% on polkinghorne.



and i have 6k Left in the DT bank

Get Pav out of the mids......Brown WILL drop in price......Having Polkinghorne and Rockliff starting is extremely risky..........

 

[Atavistic]

is anyone thinking of starting warnock??
cause if he plays he will be carltons number 1 ruck and wanting kruzer to play CHF

No, it would probably be too risky due to concerns regarding durability, but by all means have him on your bench.

 

[Hurley300]

Thanks for the advice. Team is now as follows:

Defenders: Goddard, Hargrave, Gram, Firrito, Greenwood, Hawksley, Ladson, Polak, Maguire (Bris)

Midfield: Ablett, Montagna, Boak, Scully, Trengove (Mel), Martin (Rich), Bastinac, Cunnington

Ruck: Brogan, Tippett, Warnock, Trengove (Port).

Forward: Chapman, Didak, Goodes, Sylvia, Williams (Ess), Henderson, Hitchcock, Shepheard, Dennis-Lane.

Any further changes, or do you reckon I'll be all sweet from here?

I had Firrito last yr. Thought his midfield role would boost his scores, was i wrong! extremely frustrating can go missing for weeks.

 

[saints07]

Hey guys what do you think of this team?

Backs: Goddard, Duffield, Carrazzo, Fisher, Hodge, Kennelly, Ladson (Emerg: Davis & Trengove)

Mids: Bartel, Selwood, Kornes, Armitage, Martin, Trengove (Emerg: Bastinac & Shuey)

Rucks: Kreuzer, Tippett (Emerg: Lobbe & Warnock)

Fwds: Riewoldt, ROK, Pavlich, Le Cras, Ziebell, Dangerfield, TDL (Emerg: Podsiadly & Tapscott)

Only $20K left.

I am think of downgrading one of my backs to a suban and upgrading ziebell to buddy?

Any thoughts on who else I should change in my team.

Cheers.

 

[SM]

is anyone thinking of starting warnock??
cause if he plays he will be carltons number 1 ruck and wanting kruzer to play CHF

At 100k he's a good cash cow on the bench.

 

[Mastenbation]

Hey guys, what do you think, some changes still to come I'm sure:

Backs: Enright, Carrazzo, Hodge, H. Shaw, Suban, Ladson, Sheppard (Davis, Trengove)

Mids: Pendlebury, J Selwood, Mitchell, Kerr, Trengove, Martin (Morabito, Bastinac)

Rucks: Kreuzer, Tippet (Warnock, Lobbe)

Forwards: Riewoldt, Didak, Pavlich, Giansiracusa, Medhurst, Ziebell, Dangerfield (Gumbleton, Dennis-Lane).

Any feedback appreciated

 

[JurahcaneKatrina]

hey guys this is my second year of dream team and my second draft. would love any and all feedback

B: B Goddard, L Hodge, C Enright, H Shaw, T Kennelly, N Suban, R Ladson

C: L Hayes, P Chapman, J Selwood, S Mitchell, D Martin, J Trengrove

R: K Tippett, M Kruezer

F: M Pavlich, L Franklin, C Sylvia, D Giansiracusa, P Dangerfield, C Mayne, T Rockliff

Reserves:
C Schmidt
J Lisle
A Morabito
R Bastinac
J Trengove
J Roughead
L Tapscott
T Dennis-Lane

 

[GrandBlue]

hey guys this is my second year of dream team and my second draft. would love any and all feedback

B: B Goddard, L Hodge, C Enright, H Shaw, T Kennelly, N Suban, R Ladson

C: L Hayes, P Chapman, J Selwood, S Mitchell, D Martin, J Trengrove

R: K Tippett, M Kruezer

F: M Pavlich, L Franklin, C Sylvia, D Giansiracusa, P Dangerfield, C Mayne, T Rockliff

Reserves:
C Schmidt
J Lisle
A Morabito
R Bastinac
J Trengove
J Roughead
L Tapscott
T Dennis-Lane

Personally, I'd upgrade at least one of those ruckmen to something with more scoring potential, but that's just me. Also, don't expect Jordan Roughead to play much this year. Hudson and Minson are both ahead of him and I can only see him playing if one of them gets injured. I'd also be careful with both Hayes and Chapman in your midfield, very big risk there. Still a good looking team though.

I think I'm happy with this team for now. I really want to fit Goddard in somewhere though, getting the cash for it will be a tricky task though:

 

[Narkee]

Personally, I'd upgrade at least one of those ruckmen to something with more scoring potential, but that's just me. Also, don't expect Jordan Roughead to play much this year. Hudson and Minson are both ahead of him and I can only see him playing if one of them gets injured. I'd also be careful with both Hayes and Chapman in your midfield, very big risk there. Still a good looking team though.

I think I'm happy with this team for now. I really want to fit Goddard in somewhere though, getting the cash for it will be a tricky task though:

That's quality mate. You fixed up your backs. Waters still holds some risk until such time as we see him play a preseason match. Keep Hunt in mind.

Keep your eyes on Vez too. Has attracted DT preseason hype for two years now but injury has prevented us from seeing much of him.

Nice team!

 

[GrandBlue]

That's quality mate. You fixed up your backs. Waters still holds some risk until such time as we see him play a preseason match. Keep Hunt in mind.

Keep your eyes on Vez too. Has attracted DT preseason hype for two years now but injury has prevented us from seeing much of him.

Nice team!

Appreciate the feedback. I prefer Waters to Hunt simply due to Waters' scoring potential. Looking at Hunt's history, it doesn't seem like he's ever been a good scorer and coming off a knee reco, I don't think he'll improve.

Also I gotta stick with Vez. Third year player and while he's been a bit disappointing the last 2 years, I reckon now's his time to shine... at least until I've seen him in the NAB Cup. He was the best available in my price-range anyway.

 

[yogibbear]

My final team at the moment has 480k left in the bank... am i weird?

 

[Kenzie101]

Team A
BACKS
Goddard , Adcock , Hodge , Mackie , Mcdonald , Kennelly , Ladson. EMG - Sheppard , Maguire.

MIDS
Bartel , Pendlebury , Selwood , Masten , Trengrove , Martin. EMG - Shuey , Bastanac.

RUCK
Kreuzer , Hille. EMG - Warnock , Lobbe.

FORWARDS
Riewoldt , O'Keefe , Higgins , Franklin , Polkinghorne , Dangerfield , Henderson. EMG - Gumbleton , Dennis-Lane.

$23900 left in the bank.

Or
Team B

BACKS
Goddard , Adcock , Hodge , Mackie , Krakouer , kennelly , Ladson. EMG - Maguire , Davis

MIDS
Bartel , Gibbs , Selwood , Masten , Trengrove , Martin. EMG - shuey , Bastinac.

RUCK
Kruezer , Hille. EMG - Warnock , lobbe.

FORWARD
Riewoldt , O'Keefe , Giansiracusa , Franklin , Ziebell , Dangerfield , Polikinghorne. EMG - Gumbleton , Dennis-Lane

$0 left in the bank.

whch team do you recon is better? Go to town on it boys anything said will be appreciated.

 

[The Hunting Coach]

i have 22k left in the bank and think my rucks are a bit weak...but any feedback is appreciated.

BACKS:
Goddard, Hargrave, Carazzo, Hodge, S Selwood, L Greenwood, R Ladson, J Hunt, P Davis

MIDS:
Montagna, J Selwood, B Vince, T Cotchin, R Palmer, M McVeigh, D Martin, B Cunnington

RUCKS:
Sandilands, M Pike, Warnock , Lobbe

FWDS:
B Harvey, M Bate, R Grey, Medhurst, J Westoff, Dangerfield, T Rockliff, Gumbleton, J Posadilly

 

[Dr Awkward]

i have 22k left in the bank and think my rucks are a bit weak...but any feedback is appreciated.

BACKS:
Goddard, Hargrave, Carazzo, Hodge, S Selwood, L Greenwood, R Ladson, J Hunt, P Davis

MIDS:
Montagna, J Selwood, B Vince, T Cotchin, R Palmer, M McVeigh, D Martin, B Cunnington

RUCKS:
Sandilands, M Pike, Warnock , Lobbe

FWDS:
B Harvey, M Bate, R Grey, Medhurst, J Westoff, Dangerfield, T Rockliff, Gumbleton, J Posadilly

Some good individual selections but to me it doesnt seem like you have enough high end keepers. I've always found that it's good to ask yourself at the start of the season what you want your team to look like at the end of the season.

You seem to have a fair bit of cash on the bench (J. Hunt, D. Martin).. One of those three ruckman will have to be upgraded early in the season. Also just personally I don't think Scott Selwood or Justin Westhoff are good selections.

 

[Dr Awkward]

Personally, I'd upgrade at least one of those ruckmen to something with more scoring potential, but that's just me. Also, don't expect Jordan Roughead to play much this year. Hudson and Minson are both ahead of him and I can only see him playing if one of them gets injured. I'd also be careful with both Hayes and Chapman in your midfield, very big risk there. Still a good looking team though.

I think I'm happy with this team for now. I really want to fit Goddard in somewhere though, getting the cash for it will be a tricky task though:

The team has an excellent structure, it clealy looks like you know what you are doing, so the only thing to criticise is some individual selections. Personally I dont see any value in Mc Pahrlin or Taylor Walker. Veszpremi is a risk. He will probably go up in value but to be honest he isnt that cheap and has only played a handful of AFL games.

You must be confident of Morabito getting a round 1 game, I was under the impression he was only a borderline chance?

 

[The Hunting Coach]

Some good individual selections but to me it doesnt seem like you have enough high end keepers. I've always found that it's good to ask yourself at the start of the season what you want your team to look like at the end of the season.

You seem to have a fair bit of cash on the bench (J. Hunt, D. Martin).. One of those three ruckman will have to be upgraded early in the season. Also just personally I don't think Scott Selwood or Justin Westhoff are good selections.

Thansk for the evaluation. Any tips on if I loose S Selwood and move J Hunt off the bench what and low priced defenders that i could slot in that I don thave?

I think D Martin will be a gun, but as a young player he isnt gonna play all 22 games.....hence why i have him on the bench.

I do like th eidea of getting rid of westoff (2 port players in the fwd line isnt a good move). I am toying with the idea of loosing him and freeing up some cash to upgrade my rucks

 

[BACCS]

You must be confident of Morabito getting a round 1 game, I was under the impression he was only a borderline chance?

He will play 22 games this year barring injury, no doubt whatsoever.

 

[Dime]

He will play 22 games this year barring injury, no doubt whatsoever.

Absolutely incorrect.
Whilst there is a chance he'll play a lot of games, Harvey has said that he would prefer to not have a repeat of having to play rookies so early and in such large numbers as 09.
Maybe Mora will be the one who does play, but I would in no way be guaranteeing it.

 

[Dr Awkward]

Thansk for the evaluation. Any tips on if I loose S Selwood and move J Hunt off the bench what and low priced defenders that i could slot in that I don thave?

Actually well this is a bit of a problem so far there arnt any obvious backline rookies, at the moment I have Davis and Trengove and there is some talk about Sheppard. Even Mc Guire could bee a good pickup at only 100k, but maybe something will unfold in the next couple of weeks.

I think D Martin will be a gun, but as a young player he isnt gonna play all 22 games.....hence why i have him on the bench.

Well he doesnt have to play all 22 games, he only has to play 5 or 6 until he has gone up a fair bit and then you have made some money. But to be honest, looking at Richmond's list and from what I have seen so far I think he might go close to playing every week. Richmond will be losing all year and Hardwick will have to satisfy supporters by playing youth.

 

[Dr Awkward]

He will play 22 games this year barring injury, no doubt whatsoever.

Do you have a source, or just opinion?