Rate the Club Jumpers

[memberforever]

I'll leave my clubs jumper out of it but i do think its quite good.

1. Fitzroy
2. Footscray
3. Kangas
4. Geelong
5. Collingwood
6. Sydney
7. Richmond
8. Carlton
9. Brisbane
10. Western Bulldogs
11. Essendon
12. Adelaide
13. St Kilda
14. Eagles
15. Hawks
16. Freo
17. Port

I like the Melbourne jumper, its one of the best.

 

[memberforever]

[/URL]

I thought Ports heritage round jumper (this year) was a great way to put the black and white together. Much better than Collingwoods plain verticals.

 

[chickens_law]

Richmonds clash jumper is terrible. One of the worst.

But its home guernsey is one of the best.

 

[iRemember87]

Any jumper that has tried to keep with tradition is up there for me.

Clubs who keep needing to change there jumper has problems.

I love the Carlton jumper of course based on the fact they have always kept the logo on the front with blue the solid colour all over and haven't tinkered with it...tradition.

Colour combo the Tigers have it...

I wish the Dogs would go back to the jumper they had in the 80's

 

[iRemember87]

Richmonds clash jumper is terrible. One of the worst.

But its home guernsey is one of the best.

No worse than the Collingwood one...oh hang do Collingwood have one?? Nah thats right they just swapped the black stripes with white and the white stripes with black...so do they have one??

 

[El_Scorcho]

I thought Ports heritage round jumper (this year) was a great way to put the black and white together. Much better than Collingwoods plain verticals.

Best Guernsey ever.

I love our home guernsey, but i'm not a huge fan of any of our other guernseys up until now.

However, based on home guernseys...

1 Port. Bias
2 Carlton
3 Richmond
4 Collingwood
5 Essendon
6 Brisbane
7 Melbourne
8 Western Bulldogs
9 Kangaroos
10 Adelaide
11 West Coast
12 Sydney
13 Geelong
14 St Kilda
15 Freo (all white guernsey is okay though)
16 Hawthorn (sorry but the white number panel is awful)

 

[DEEZ_4_LIFE]

dont understand how collingwoods is rated so highly in this thread.. its not as bad as the hawks one but it has boring colours and the same pattern as half of the rest of the league.. i think brizzy has the best jumper, followed by melbourne or the tiges.

 

[doodlefeatures]

Another thread designed to have a crack at Hawthorn's jersey, ho hum.

Who really gives a rats which jersey looks the best, a sleeveless footy jumper is hardly the kind of thing you wear anywhere other than to the game regardless of what pattern it has on it.

 

[Kaiser Powser]

Whats with Fitzroy being in the list??????? Have we been having byes I am not aware of.

Because it was a very good jumper.

Brisbane should wear it for every Victorian game.

 

[Kaiser Powser]

Another thread designed to have a crack at Hawthorn's jersey, ho hum.

Who really gives a rats which jersey looks the best, a sleeveless footy jumper is hardly the kind of thing you wear anywhere other than to the game regardless of what pattern it has on it.

While base purely on colours, the Hawthorn jumper is bad, it is actually quite a practical jumper. It never clashes with another team, which is a good thing. Because it is traditional and I am used to it, I can handle it, but if a new team came into the comp with that jumper, fingers would be going down throats in unison.

 

[TOPBLUE_25]

1. Carlton*
2. Brisbane
3. Western Bulldogs
4. Sydney
5. St Kilda
6. Richmond
7. Essendon
8. Wests coast
9. Melbourne
10. Collingwood
11. North
12. Geelong
13. Hawthorn
14. Fremantle
15. Adelaide
16. Port

 

[The Final Word]

No worse than the Collingwood one...oh hang do Collingwood have one?? Nah thats right they just swapped the black stripes with white and the white stripes with black...so do they have one??

Why people keep making this call is beyond me. The two jumpers, especially when combined with the appropriate shorts are very distinguishable.

 

[The Final Word]

Top 10

1. Brisbane heritage (old FFC jumper)
2. Sydney heritage (old South jumper)
3. Port Adelaide heritage (prison bars)
4. Richmond home
5. Essendon home
6. Geelong home
7. Doggies away
8. Collingwood away
9. Carlton heritage
10. West Coast away

Honourable mention to WC's 2007 heritage (old WA guernsey). Love it and would make the list but don't anticipate seeing it again.

And worst jumper seeing in 2007 by a light year:

Port Adelaide away

 

[Truetiger]

1. Essendon-though this could be cause i'm an Essendon supporter but I do like it.2. Port Adelaide
3. Collingwood
4. Bulldogs
5. Brisbane
6. North Melbourne
7. Richmond
8. Saint Kilda
9. Sydney
10. Eagles
11. Fremantle
12. Melbourne
13. Geelong
14. Carlton
15. Adelaide
16. Hawthorn

BTW good thread

Anyone seens Universities jumper-alright it is. Kinda like a jockeys jumper.

Well if you have Essendons as no1 Surely Richmond would have to be the same if not 2nd as there the same besides the yellow and red part?

 

[Kaiser Powser]

Well if you have Essendons as no1 Surely Richmond would have to be the same if not 2nd as there the same besides the yellow and red part?

Unless you really hate yellow.

But i suggest this may be due to Bias, but at least he admitted that much.

Nothing wrong with that, it is only natural to appreciate your clubs jumper more than the next bloke.

 

[Shane_Mag]

1. Port
2. Collingwood
3. Essendon
4. West Coast
5. Melbourne
6. Kangaroos
7. Geelong
8. St Kilda
9. Carlton
10. Bulldogs
11. Sydney
12. Richmond
13. Brisbane
14. Adelaide
15. Fremantle
16. Hawthorn

 

[walhawk]

I love the Hawthorn jumper.

And Fitzroy's was the best.

but all bias aside...

Carlton
Richmond
Essendon
North
Hawthorn
Collingwood
Geelong
Melbourne
Adelaide
Brisbane
St Kilda
Bulldogs
Sydney
West Coast
Freo
Port

 

[Beckers]

Best:

1. Brisbane - Love the design and colours
2. Carlton - simple yet does the job
3. Geelong - see above
4. Sydney - Good design and colors.

Daylight
All good but no standouts

5. Collingwood
6. Kangaroos
7. Fremantle - don't mind it and it is different!
8. West Coast
9. Hawthorn
10. Bulldogs
11. Essendon
12. Richmond
13. Port Adelaide
14. Melbourne

Daylight......

Shockers:

15. Adelaide - horrible, horrible, horrible design - Urrrgghhhh!!!!
16. St Kilda - That candy striped number is shocking!!! The traditional 3 colors/stripes are not as bad but still very bad. Go back to the jumper with the shield on the front FFS!!!!!

 

[thebigboy]

Worst-

Freo Away Jumper
St.Kilda Away
Bulldogs Away
Simply not a fan of the all white jumpers, looks too much like basketball.

Best

Essendon with Black Shorts
Richmond with Black Shorts
North Melbournes with the White V and the Emblem on the front. Best one they've had.

Honourable Mention to the Harliquin Jumper of Hawthorns, absolutly terrible and the Old Fitzroy jumper with the Blue shorts. Almost the best design ever.

 

[BlueRoos]

I thought Ports heritage round jumper (this year) was a great way to put the black and white together. Much better than Collingwoods plain verticals.

yeah, have a l of time for the prison bar traditional Port Jumper.

Makes me wonder why Port don't incorporate that style in an away jumper at least using their current colours. Not sure Port fans would go for a teal and black prison bar style uniform, but i think it could look the goods.

 

[murph#3]

1-carlton (i dont know if its 'cos im biased but i just love our jumper)
2-richmond (i like the colours)
3-st kilda (like the design and colours aren't too bad)
4-collingwood ( i hate to say it but it does look good)
5-essendon (dont really like the colours but design is nice)
6-brisbane (liked the fitzroy one much much more)
7-melbourne (red and blue don't go but design is really nice)
8-geelong (nothing spectacular nice and simple)
9-kangaroos (the traditional stripes are pretty good)
10-hawthorn (i don't know why everyone bags their colours i quite like them)
11-west coast (the jumper with the eagle head on it and wings on the sides)
12-adelaide (the plain hoops aren't too bad)
13-doggies (design isnt too bad but as i said blue and red doesn't go)
14-port adelaide (didnt mind the heritage jumper but the teal one is an eye-sore)
15-fremantle (shocking jumper(s) to go with song, name and amount of premierships)
16-sydney (nice colours but horrible design they really could have done better given their colours and emblem)

 

[GFCats07]

Geelong
Brisbane
West Coast
St Kilda
Essendon
Crows
Fremantle
W.Bulldogs
Collingwood
Richmond
Carlton
Kangas
Sydney
Melbourne
Port
Hawthorn

 

[Bollox]

Of the other clubs

Acceptable..only their old traditional jumpers and colours tho.

Collingwood
Richmond
StKilda
Carlton
Melbourne
Brisbane
Essendon
Geelong

Dont think looks much chop...

Doggies
North
Hawthorn

Bloody awful...

Weagles
Port
Adelaide
Freo

Those weagle theatre jackets just look ****y
Port's jumper is a disgrace
Adelaide's is chronic and vomitworthy
Freo's looks like a box of smarties


Brisbane would do well to use the Fitzroy jumper for all home games...so similar to the existing one but just looks great.

 

[Hollow Knight]

Brisbane would do well to use the Fitzroy jumper for all home games...so similar to the existing one but just looks great.

You would do well to just speak for your own team and not another.

In case you haven't heard, we're a merged club of two separate entities.

We're not the Fitzroy Lions, and we aren't the Brisbane Bears.

We are the Brisbane Lions, and we already have our own jumper, a bloody great jumper in fact. If I recall correctly, we may have won a few premierships in it a few years back.

 

[-CG-]

It seems like a lot of people don't like Adelaide's guernsey. Why?