-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Preview Rd 8 Geelong v Melbourne Sat May 4th 730pm @ MCG
- Thread starter dazbroncos
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Vdubs
Hall of Famer
Long term lover of Hawkins and Stanley
-as I was of Mooney and Milburn
2011- CS ended up picking Hawkins over Mooney, and probably Duncan over Milburn
2024- It's evolving. Neale over Hawkins, Conway over Stanley. Not sure how often and when, but by next year, that transition should be complete.
Vdubs
Hall of Famer
Demons can score. Their new defender come forward was great last week.
We do have a great coach, but this is more of when we play them rather than who we play this week.
Fully rested, lot of pressure on Viney, Petracca and Oliver to perform, and they will.
The loss of Dangerfield seems underrated here, and this week in particular.
Not a shock to drop a game to Demons, and they should be slight favourites.
Finknottle
Club Legend
- Aug 2, 2020
- 2,441
- 4,353
- AFL Club
- Geelong
On the AFL App, Hawkins is ranked 156 for score involvements. Miers ranked 14, Cameron at 16. Where do you get your goal assists data from?
A great article (April 2024) for an overview of Tom's career irrespective of their source on stats:
"A statistical breakdown of his last five seasons demonstrates this. Hawkins has ranked in the top 10 in goal assists, total goals and overall score involvements every year since 2018, holding the top rank at the end of the season at different stages in each category."
‘Be the man’: Inside the ‘boozy’ Grand Final rev-up that launched an AFL legend
‘Be the man’: Inside the ‘boozy’ Grand Final rev-up that launched an AFL legend
www.foxsports.com.au
Okay this one is older 2022. Maybe if you give him the rest of the 2024 season he could maintain (build) his record?
"Albeit as a statistic best maintained since 2003, Hawkins is ranked 7th of all time for goal assists and the highest ranked key forward in the statistics, with 248 goal assists in his 303 games after the first round of 2022."
We Don't Talk Enough About The Greatness Of Tom Hawkins
Undoubtedly one of Geelong’s greatest ever forwards and indeed, one of the best in the entire league since the turn of the century, Hawkins’ continued elite-level output is a testament to the continued evolvement of his game.
Finknottle
Club Legend
- Aug 2, 2020
- 2,441
- 4,353
- AFL Club
- Geelong
I agree Hawkins has been a great player but you should put some context around your quotes. I'm concerned with Hawkins' recent form and recent to me is 2024. You don't get a guernsey based on how you used to play.A great article (April 2024) for an overview of Tom's career irrespective of their source on stats:
"A statistical breakdown of his last five seasons demonstrates this. Hawkins has ranked in the top 10 in goal assists, total goals and overall score involvements every year since 2018, holding the top rank at the end of the season at different stages in each category."
‘Be the man’: Inside the ‘boozy’ Grand Final rev-up that launched an AFL legend
‘Be the man’: Inside the ‘boozy’ Grand Final rev-up that launched an AFL legend
Okay this one is older 2022. Maybe if you give him the rest of the 2024 season he could maintain (build) his record?
"Albeit as a statistic best maintained since 2003, Hawkins is ranked 7th of all time for goal assists and the highest ranked key forward in the statistics, with 248 goal assists in his 303 games after the first round of 2022."
We Don't Talk Enough About The Greatness Of Tom Hawkins
Undoubtedly one of Geelong’s greatest ever forwards and indeed, one of the best in the entire league since the turn of the century, Hawkins’ continued elite-level output is a testament to the continued evolvement of his game.www.statsinsider.com.au
In reality though, Hawkins does and will continue to do so, despite (what appears to us) a slump in form/health.
Something he has recovered from before, I'm sure the Club will give him every chance if he wants it.
I think the BF pro agenda for Neale is driving the undertakers measuring tape somewhat on Hawk.
Context is clear, champion then, champion now in a winning team.
Last edited:
Melbourne's defence is leagues ahead of Carlton's but their forward line is basically non-existent.
Goodwin is a better coach than Voss, but ultimately I don't think it matters.
Geelong by 15
Goodwin is a better coach than Voss, but ultimately I don't think it matters.
Geelong by 15
It's pretty clear that Hawkins is "role playing" right now.
He still demands the opposition's best defender. A few years ago it was "Hawkins island" where the forward line worked to isolate him. Now it's the reverse, he works to get separation from Jezza, Ollie etc and give them the opportunity to kick the goals.
Hawkins Island meant that Geelong's approach was predictable. This new approach means there are at least 3 or 4 paths to goal, with Tommy dragging an A-grade opponent away from the 3 or 4 contests on offer to Miers, Duncan etc.
And sure, maybe Hawkins' opponent decides to sag off and affect the contest where Cameron is the target, but....would you? It's a massive risk leaving Hawkins on his own to try and affect another contest. Hell, it's a risk being left one out with the man-mountain. What happens if the kick is pulled last moment? What happens if you run off Tommy only to see the ball heading his way. It's a mind**** for defenders.
Geelong haven't always had the luxury of 4 dangerous forwards - but now they do.
The other forwards have the speed and agility to spread away from Tom and offer up leads and options.
IMHO - he's not kicking goals directly but he's still contributing in a massive way - nothing that will appear on the stats sheet.
In addition, it improves his longevity.
Last edited:
BlakeyNoFlakey
Brownlow Medallist
Not game related but I didn't know where to put this. Take a couple of minutes to admire the great man.
Lot of chat about how Rohan gets back in and comparisons to OHenry.
I also struggled to find a forward to drop for him, but the more I think about it, the more I think it won’t be too hard to fit him in. He played every game with OHenry last year. And the only addition to the forward mix has been Dempsey, but then Smith is out who played a bit of half forward last year. Plus miers, Cameron and dempsey are spending more time up the ground. When coupled with the ability we’ve shown for players to change their role from game to game (and sometimes within game), eg Atkins, bowes, Blicavs, tuohy, I don’t think it will take too much shuffling to rest/drop someone further up the field to fit him in.
That said everyone is playing well at the moment, but I think it’ll be easy enough to rotate out some players further up the ground to give him a stretch of games.
I also struggled to find a forward to drop for him, but the more I think about it, the more I think it won’t be too hard to fit him in. He played every game with OHenry last year. And the only addition to the forward mix has been Dempsey, but then Smith is out who played a bit of half forward last year. Plus miers, Cameron and dempsey are spending more time up the ground. When coupled with the ability we’ve shown for players to change their role from game to game (and sometimes within game), eg Atkins, bowes, Blicavs, tuohy, I don’t think it will take too much shuffling to rest/drop someone further up the field to fit him in.
That said everyone is playing well at the moment, but I think it’ll be easy enough to rotate out some players further up the ground to give him a stretch of games.
dazbroncos
Max Rooke Appreciation Society
- Oct 9, 2010
- 52,239
- 88,649
- AFL Club
- Geelong
- Other Teams
- Denver Broncos, Red Bull Racing
- Thread starter
- Moderator
- #262
truly pants off stuff.
Just no better and like the OP says... all in 20 days.
With no disrespect to Jamie Elliot who deserves all the kudos he gets for that one mark... the comparison just isnt fair lol
GO Catters
We were spoilt going to the footy in those days.
*off topic sorry, not sorry.
Champion Data's Daniel Hoyne joins Gerard Healy and Adam White to unpack all of the numbers behind Round 7, only on SEN!
A MUST LISTEN for any keen Cat follower -
SEN Sports - Geelong on a roll.............. go to
15.46 to 18.30
A MUST LISTEN for any keen Cat follower -
SEN Sports - Geelong on a roll.............. go to
15.46 to 18.30
Last edited:
Zouz Kitty
Miss Kitty
The Power of Pussy makes any grown man weep to his knees begging for a tap on the shoulder to indicate he has some relevance in life!........ GO PUSSY CATS
Started my Cats journey around the time of Abletts arrival. Couldn’t have timed it better, watched 95% of his games. Think Jezza up the ground, Hawkins out of the square with the pace of Holmes and the leap of Ollie Dempsey for reference if you’re too young to have seen it. Best ever by the length of the Flemington straight.
Finknottle
Club Legend
- Aug 2, 2020
- 2,441
- 4,353
- AFL Club
- Geelong
You forget how good he was. He would still dominate in today's game - balance, speed, explosive power and agility. You can see Gary Jnr in some of his moves. Both had that ability to keep their feet in contested situations guaranteeing quick access to any resulting ground ball. Multiple times last week Geelong or Carlton players went to ground in a contest or even in an attempt to get to the ball first. It usually didn't end well. There should be a 'keep your feet' coach at the football club.
You can't rest Hawkins this week, he and Cameron take the oppositions best defenders. If Hawkins is out, Cameron won't suffer, but the flow on hits the rest of the forwards.
Hawkins goals will return and I wouldn't be surprised if he kicked 3 or 4 this week.
Hawkins goals will return and I wouldn't be surprised if he kicked 3 or 4 this week.
Finknottle
Club Legend
- Aug 2, 2020
- 2,441
- 4,353
- AFL Club
- Geelong
Champion Data's Daniel Hoyne joins Gerard Healy and Adam White to unpack all of the numbers behind Round 7, only on SEN!
SEN Sports - Geelong on a roll.............. go to
Wow this is incredibly inciteful. Thanks so much for posting that.
- Sep 26, 2017
- 29,142
- 49,318
- AFL Club
- Geelong
I feel attacked!!!
- Mar 11, 2019
- 17,073
- 28,013
- AFL Club
- Geelong
Champion Data's Daniel Hoyne joins Gerard Healy and Adam White to unpack all of the numbers behind Round 7, only on SEN!
SEN Sports - Geelong on a roll.............. go to
Interesting listen as always
When Blighty first came to the Cats Finknottle: he told Gazza Snr the most important fundamental in football was to keep your feet, whether it was directly after a marking contest or going for a ground-ball in a contested situation, otherwise if you didn't keep your feet, not only were you out of the contest but your team was down a man in the field of play...... nothing TRUER !!!
The_Koulouriotis_Fan
All Australian
- Mar 21, 2021
- 963
- 3,866
- AFL Club
- Geelong
Is there anything more exciting at the footy than a forward dominating? When the ball goes forward, the crowd just goes nuts with anticipation. I was only a kid when Snr played but Hell it was exciting. We've been lucky in recent times, Hawkins has had a lot of those games, Cameron, Danger and Gas Jr, but every time it happens I am always reminded of Snr, what a legend on the football field
Hawkins has been a very good FF for Geel , but not as good as Doug Wade in my opinion
Wade was a big heavy bloke like Hawkins but it was amazing how high Wade could get off the ground re marking
There was a Geel FC publication one pre season i reckon either 1971 or 72 - and it previews Geelongs chances that year - with pictures of all the players and a bit of a write up on each of them - and on the front cover of that publication is Wade taking a screamer of a mark at KP in the goal square , Barwon River end , and he is standing on a Hawthorn blokes shoulders , i think it could be Don Scott
As good as Hawkins has been , i just think Wade gets the nod , being slightly better
- Status
Similar threads
