Preview Richmond vs West Coast - 1:45pm Saturday the 6th of May @ The MCG - Desperate times call for desperate measures... or do they?

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Just seen the dusty incident with the suns player deliberately punching the ball over the goal line now that right there and then proves we get umpired differently than any other team if that was any other team especially the bullfrogs that would have been paid 100 percent guaranteed this is what is pissing me off about afl I am losing interest very quickly
 
We simply can’t lose this at the MCG. It would be Hardwick’s worst loss ever in his Richmond tenure and our second worst lost this millennium (Only behind the 222-65 loss against Geelong in 2007). It’d be even worse that the Karmichael Hunt game, our first Gold Coast game, the Port Adelaide 2011 loss, and the Tom Hafey tribute game loss.

Seriously, West Coast are sitting 18th for a very good reason. They have 26 fit players at the moment on their entire list and are limiting training because of injuries. They’re also getting smashed every week in the AFL and WAFL because of it.

But I’m confident we won’t lose because our organisation knows how unacceptable that would be. Also, we usually smash a team that plays us in such a bad form. Richmond by 40+ points. If we’re serious about getting our season on track though, then we need to win by 90+ points like we did against them last year. I’m not very confident of a smashing given our forward woes, but I am confident of a win regardless of what our changes are this week.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

I'm thinking it might be time to give Banks a go on the wing. There are still question marks on his game, but he's been pretty consistent on the VFL. Probably should have done it last week instead of playing Sonsie out of position in that role.

Wouldn't mind seeing Pickett trialled up forward again, purely out of desperation because we have no small forwards.
 
B: Young Balta Grimes
HB: Rioli Broad Baker
C: Banks Hopper Pickett
HF: Sonsie Ryan Short
F: Martin Riewoldt Cumberland
R: Soldo Taranto Bolton
INT: Vlastuin Prestia Ross Cotchin
SUB: Clarke

IN: Prestia Banks
OUT: McIntosh Miller Clarke(Sub)
 
B: Young Balta Grimes
HB: Rioli Broad Baker
C: Banks Hopper Pickett
HF: Sonsie Ryan Short
F: Martin Riewoldt Cumberland
R: Soldo Taranto Bolton
INT: Vlastuin Prestia Ross Cotchin
SUB: Clarke

IN: Prestia Banks
OUT: McIntosh Miller Clarke(Sub)
Sonise and Clarke out, both need to go and play 120 minutes of hard football to get their game up and running.

Cotchin for sub, or MacIntosh could have a week as a sub.

Dow deserves a go far more than a few others as he has gone back and did what was asked of him and is in good form. And he has something we need at the moment, a bit of spark around the ball.
 
In all seriousness if we cant beat West Coast on the weekend then Dimma needs to announce his resignation effective immediately and I'll jump on board the Mr Magic train and say we trade anyone we can to get as many picks as possible. LOL
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

I love seeing this. Almost everything Kane Cornes predicts turns out wrong. His predictions as a footy ‘expert’ over the years are bordering on embarrassing.

I mean even at 1-1-5 and with a 23k crowd against GC, Richmond (59k) has the second highest average attendance this season behind the Pies (64k)… just a lazy 39k per game ahead of GWS (20k).

Some Tiger ‘tales’ from Kane over the years:

Before the 2019 GF : “Jack Riewoldt is sadly out of form and needs to be under more scrutiny” (kicks 5 in the GF and gets NS votes).

In 2017 and 2018 : “Rance needs to stop diving or it will ruin his legacy” …(anyone ever hear Rance’s diving mentioned when he is discussed? Never)

August 2016: called on Richmond to sack Cotchin as captain and appoint Alex Rance.

End of 2016: “To target Prestia now is the wrong call, they are not in the Premiership window” (he was right .. there were 3 x windows)

After R5 2020 he nominated 6 x teams who could win the flag …. Richmond wasn’t one of them.

So don’t despair… the more negative stuff Karen writes, the better we will be …. and much quicker too. He gets almost everything wrong, so the only time to panic would be if he predicted good things for us.

He also said in 2020 Geelong should start a soft rebuild and trade out Cam Guthrie …. he ended up winning their B&F in a Premiership year in 2022.

The list of his diabolical predictions is endless…..



Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Kane's job isn't to be right though. It's to just say whatever so everyone provides his employer with attention.
 
B: Young Balta Grimes
HB: Rioli Broad Baker
C: Banks Hopper Pickett
HF: Sonsie Ryan Short
F: Martin Riewoldt Cumberland
R: Soldo Taranto Bolton
INT: Vlastuin Prestia Ross Cotchin
SUB: Clarke

IN: Prestia Banks
OUT: McIntosh Miller Clarke(Sub)

sauce
 
I don't want to see Miller play another game for Richmond.

He's a ballerina pretending to be a football player. Scratch that, a ballerina would probably be more classy with their performance than Miller. He just doesn't do anything well.

Up forward he doesn't kick goals.
In the ruck he is monstered and given a spanking by other ruckman. He doesn't do the dirty follow up work that Nank does once the ball gets to ground.
He doesn't have enough footy IQ to be a backman and read the play or generate offence.

He's like RCD, he teased us with a few nice plays but when put up against it in the Brisbane final he crapped his pants. Granted, a couple others crapped their pants in the final he is just not a football player.

We have Bauer who contests everything in the air.
We have Braedtke who looks way more imposing as a forward.
The Twig Samson Ryan at least kicks it between the big sticks instead of out on the full.
Time to move Miller on, we've given him enough time to prove himself in the 1s.
 
Just seen the dusty incident with the suns player deliberately punching the ball over the goal line now that right there and then proves we get umpired differently than any other team if that was any other team especially the bullfrogs that would have been paid 100 percent guaranteed this is what is pissing me off about afl I am losing interest very quickly
Worse than that was the amount of HTB non call prior opportunity decisions we didn't get in the 2nd half. 23,500 of us Richmond fans could see them at the ground except for the 4 field umpires. Our fans were going off their dial at the non calls.
 
or it could give the players some confidence and build off that to reset our season.
We’re a confidence team, so a good win (by a big margin) will usually be enough to get us on track and playing well again.

Only year I recall that not working since 2013 was in 2021 when we beat St Kilda by 86 points and did not build upon it. But we had Premiership fatigue that year.
 
Move d Rioli to forward. Allow short and baker to be the half backs.
‘just do somethin, Dimma, anything
Agree with this. Need to try it. Short and Baker’s best position is half back. Rioli obviously best there too but he is actually a chance kick goals if he plays forward. . Sick of playing forwards who are unlikely to actually kick any - MRJ, Pickett, balta, Mansell, Cotchin, Baker and Short.
 
In: Prestia, Graham, Dow
Out: Miller, Cotchin, Sonsie

B: Young Balta Grimes
HB: Rioli Broad Vlastuin
C: Short Hopper Baker
HF: Pickett Ryan Bolton
F: Martin Riewoldt Cumberland
R: Soldo Taranto, Prestia
INT: KMac, Clarke, Ross, Graham
SUB: Dow
 
Just seen the dusty incident with the suns player deliberately punching the ball over the goal line now that right there and then proves we get umpired differently than any other team if that was any other team especially the bullfrogs that would have been paid 100 percent guaranteed this is what is pissing me off about afl I am losing interest very quickly
The umpiring is turning me towards the NRL and I'm sure the diehards in that league hate the way the refs go on but I don't care. I'm enjoying that cooky sport atm because I don't know enough about the rules to know when someone's being ripped off.

Wests Tigers and Melbourne Storm baby, let's ride the sunset 😎
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top