Round 11 trades

[Pedro]

Is Gray worth the extra 90K over Wingard?

Yep. Even if its for the peace of mind of consistency. Over the years I've heard many many people moaning about Wingard and his yo-yo performances. Not so much with Robbie.

 

[Krujan]

Is Tippa > Brodie Smith too sideways?

 

[leng jai]

Is Tippa > Brodie Smith too sideways?

I'd rather have big Anthony to be honest.

 

[Pedro]

Is Tippa > Brodie Smith too sideways?

Probably imo. 5 point difference in their average. Smith has the potential to score well, but does he ever do it consistently? I'd only consider him if he spikes once Laird comes back.

 

[TheOz]

Is Tippa > Brodie Smith too sideways?

Brodie Smith is a bag of dicks, keep Tippa, he's awesome.

 

[GRUFFY]

Is Tippa > Brodie Smith too sideways?

Confucious say..
"Man who enter airport door sideways, is going to Bangkok."

 

[Red Syrah]

yes

Bringing in Gray and can do it through Brown with no spare $ or Wines (set to lose $30K and doing nothing) or SMItchell (set to lose $24K and doing nothing).

Wines will give me extra $185K to upgrade Gresham in a couple of weeks.

 

[Krujan]

I'd rather have big Anthony to be honest.

I concur, hence why I'm even asking. Normally I expect rookies to tail off, especially ones that play for crap teams but he's physically strong and is pretty consistent for a def. A Black Diamond in a shop full of Cubic Zirconia's.

 

[toxic]

Bringing in Gray and can do it through Brown with no spare $ or Wines (set to lose $30K and doing nothing) or SMItchell (set to lose $24K and doing nothing).

Wines will give me extra $185K to upgrade Gresham in a couple of weeks.

Bye Brown imo

 

[OhhhhhCyril]

Is Tippa > Brodie Smith too sideways?

Tippa is a

Don't trade him yet

 

[toxic]

Is Tippa > Brodie Smith too sideways?

Downgrade

 

[TheOz]

Tippa is a keeper, will be riding my bench once I get a full compliment of premo defenders (which is when that horse scrotum Laird gets back).

 

[LFC2010]

Brodie Smith is a bag of dicks, keep Tippa, he's awesome.

Yeah I wouldn't trade B Smith for Tippa. Tippa will be solid coverage on people bench's for quite a while I reckon.

 

[TheOz]

Yeah I wouldn't trade B Smith for Tippa. Tippa will be solid coverage on people bench's for quite a while I reckon.

He's also a lot of fun to watch, love his run and carry, he's a keeper!

 

[The Lemon]

He's also a lot of fun to watch, love his run and carry, he's a keeper!

He will be a beast next year

 

[Krujan]

Tippa is a keeper, will be riding my bench once I get a full compliment of premo defenders (which is when that horse scrotum Laird gets back).

I have Laird as well. When he comes back, Tippa will be fighting to the death with Bitchall for a loopholed spot @ D6. Competition for starting spots can be a good thing. My D8 Byrne goes alright as well. Guess I'll go "complete" some other line instead.

 

[TheOz]

I have Laird as well. When he comes back, Tippa will be fighting to the death with Bitchall for a loopholed spot @ D6. Competition for starting spots can be a good thing. My D8 Byrne goes alright as well. Guess I'll go "complete" some other line instead.

I've got the sexy trio of Shaw, Doc and Simmo with Jimmy, Boyd and Laird, I would prefer to play Tippa at this point over Laird, his 4 weeks for a toe has pissed me off enough that I hope he chokes on a bloated chode.

 

[LFC2010]

He's also a lot of fun to watch, love his run and carry, he's a keeper!

I'd would've stopped at keeper material, but agree with the rest of it.

I can see myself upgrading him, but will probably be the 2nd last > last upgrade I make.

 

[Krujan]

Am I missing something with the Kerridge talk?

Probably one of the only decent rookies who has the ability to go large. I'll be keeping him to use through the bye rounds, hopefully he pops out some half decent scores and I can catch further up the rankings.

For me,

Kennedy > Mathieson
Hartley > McVeigh

Means I have to play Hopper and Smith on field but think my premos will make up for it.

B: Shaw, Simpson, Bartel, McVeigh, Rich, Adams (Tippa, Brown)
M: Dangerfield, Ablett, Parker, Gray, Priddis, Liberatore, Hopper, Smith (Mathieson, Davis, Macpherson)
R: Goldstein, Gawn (Grimley)
F: Montagna, Zorko, Martin, Wingard, Wells, Hall (Kerridge, Petracca)

$139k remaining, 15 trades left.

Would love to get Kerridge on the ground somehow but don't think its possible ($1k short of going Macpherson > Mathieson, Kennedy > McVeigh!)

DMac > Uber (opens up your B/F link) Kerridge to M8 opening up your M/F link
BurnKen> McVeigh

 

[Gerald Preston]

Any advice on trades be appreciated? Struggling to decide this week...

 

[GAsnr]

View attachment 252584

Any advice on trades be appreciated? Struggling to decide this week...

Hartley -> playing def rookie (GL with that)
Ben Ken -> Buddy or similar

Ben Ken -> Paine or Howard
Hartley -> Gibson/Rance/Simmo/Doc

 

[King_Steele]

Is Tippa > Brodie Smith too sideways?

Keep big Anferny.

 

[OhhhhhCyril]

God dammit S.mitchell is really testing me now. I love the guy but I don't know how much longer I can handle his shit scores. Could really use a guy like Pendles or Gray, heck even Ward.. at the same time cant be affording to piss away trades..

 

[Sir Skid]

Oh FFS!

I have Krujan this week after toxic ragdolled him by the whole 9 points!

 

[alfyyy3]

God dammit S.mitchell is really testing me now. I love the guy but I don't know how much longer I can handle his shit scores. Could really use a guy like Pendles or Gray, heck even Ward.. at the same time cant be affording to piss away trades..

Atleast Sammy is a proven performer who you know will bounce back, try have clanger king ollie Wines in your side.

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk