Trades Round 14 Trades (2nd week bye)

[Butterz]

Thinking of going Anthony Tippa > T.Phillips then C.Wingard > B.Deledio / L.Montagna. Peoples thoughts on Lids or Monty, lids looks like he will give greater reward this week up against the lions?

 

[banana&2kiwis]

Steven or Cotch?

I'm going with Cotch this week, really having a good vibe from him.

 

[SM]

Mills -> Laird
Ben Kennedy -> Steven

Easy trades this week, 135k in the bank for next week's upgrades.

 

[Carey84]

Trent Cotchin yay or nay

Steven or Cotch?

I picked up Cotchin a few weeks back when he was back from injury. Since then he's got me 120 every week. By far my most consistent player (OK maybe Dangerfield).

Mills -> Laird
Ben Kennedy -> Steven

Easy trades this week, 135k in the bank for next week's upgrades.

Do you have Ablett? I'm trading to similar players, don't have ablett though but thinking steven will be a lower risk option from here on out.

 

[RickSanchez]

Is it worth an extra 20k to get Cotchin in over Ablett?

 

[Scrotes2000]

Is it worth an extra 20k to get Cotchin in over Ablett?

Don't think so unless you're after a POD.

I'd love to get Dangerfield in but he's just too damn pricey now

Not really worrying about the byes as my cash league doesn't play. Hopefully Philips plays because he looks perfect.

 

[Chrissybabes]

Cox > Billy Frampton (Port)
Sam Frost > Gablett

Billy looks like getting a call up in the next few weeks with Lobbe still out for the long term (listed 5-7 weeks), Dougal howard out with an ACL, and next to no other options for 2nd ruck at Port (please correct me if i'm wrong).

 

[SM]

I picked up Cotchin a few weeks back when he was back from injury. Since then he's got me 120 every week. By far my most consistent player (OK maybe Dangerfield).



Do you have Ablett? I'm trading to similar players, don't have ablett though but thinking steven will be a lower risk option from here on out.

Don't have Ablett, but prefer Steven.

 

[Keystone agony]

Frost > L.Pierce
Tippa > Laird

Going to sit on T.Phillips for one more week to see how he goes wont be losing out heaps as Blakely is likely to be downgraded to him.

 

[Possum Vomit]

Playing the waiting game this arvo until I hear the MRP news regarding Bernie. Not holding much hope.

 

[Possum Vomit]

He survives! $1000 fine.

 

[LordHaart]

Bit unsure about what to do this week...

Trade #1: I'd like to get Ablett in to round out my midfield, but not sure who to trade out. I have 3 midfielders out this week - Gaff, Zaharakis and Hunter. Not sure if it's worth losing the $$ on the first two vs. keeping them as M7 & M8. Alternatively, I have 5 mids out next week (Rockliff, Blakely, Lewis, Scully, Shiel), so could trade one of those. Shiel might be worth trading out as he's still worth more than I paid for him but has a high BE.

Trade #2: Probably Adams out for someone. I would like to bring in a ruck so that I can get some flexibility in my forward line as I'll have potentially 4 playing rucks next week, though I'll have 5-6 forwards too so perhaps a defender would be more useful.

 

[Keystone agony]

Blakley will get to $400k if not close. Collins also hasn't hit peak. Walla would be a good choice as he has made a fair bit of money already

Yeh i just have too many R13 players need to trade one of Ruggles, Collins or Blakely this week

 

[doona]

He's not my worst player but he is the player I can justify of trading out, he's got a B/E of 118 and is projected to devalue by -17k. Before by trades this week I've got 12 players with the bye next week so I already need to be planning for next week now. If I'm already planning on trading him out next week why hold him if he's only going to go down in value. I've seen no indication that his midfield minutes will rise.

Fair call. God I wish I had never fallen for his string of decent games!!!!

 

[Citrus22]

He survives! $1000 fine.

Yess

 

[Citrus22]

Franklin > Montagna?

The big bud is consistent but low ceiling it seems, too sideways?

 

[Possum Vomit]

Franklin > Montagna?

The big bud is consistent but low ceiling it seems, too sideways?

Too sideways for me. I'd leave that to a luxury trade near the end of the season.

 

[UpsideDown]

Bit unsure about what to do this week...

Trade #1: I'd like to get Ablett in to round out my midfield, but not sure who to trade out. I have 3 midfielders out this week - Gaff, Zaharakis and Hunter. Not sure if it's worth losing the $$ on the first two vs. keeping them as M7 & M8. Alternatively, I have 5 mids out next week (Rockliff, Blakely, Lewis, Scully, Shiel), so could trade one of those. Shiel might be worth trading out as he's still worth more than I paid for him but has a high BE.

Trade #2: Probably Adams out for someone. I would like to bring in a ruck so that I can get some flexibility in my forward line as I'll have potentially 4 playing rucks next week, though I'll have 5-6 forwards too so perhaps a defender would be more useful.

i would start getting the backline fixed as that is where you'd have the biggest PODs as most peoples mid and forwards are close to completion. Ablett in for one of those three is too sideways and can be done later in the season. Go Adams to someone as he is losing value now. Lastly, Scully will probably average the least so you could be looking at getting him out (Blakely has money to be made).

My trades: Adams to Joyce, Mills to Laird

Side after trades:

Shaw Doch Laird Dea Wagner Ruggles (Collins, Joyce)
Danger Hanners Steven Rockliff Titch Hunter Duncan Blakely (Jansen, Davis)
Martin Gawn (Currie, Cox)
Merret Voldt Dusty Montagna Wells Kerridge (Reid, Mccarthy)

Thoughts?

 

[banana&2kiwis]

I've done my trades like a 100 times.

As of now their:

Bailey Williams > Reid

Dunkley > GAZ

 

[Torz]

Petracca -> Phillips
Wagner -> K Simpson

Then:

Ruggles -> Rookie
C Ellis -> Z Merrett

 

[Yellow Feathers]

So the plan remains:

Wagner - Simpson
Harwood - Docherty

$243k in the bank.

Next week:

1. Blakely - Parker

2. Duncan - Steven
or
2. Downgrade a rookie.

I know Simpson and Docherty are guns but I wish there were some more options around the 400-450k mark. Already have Laird and Suckling.

 

[Yellow Feathers]

i would start getting the backline fixed as that is where you'd have the biggest PODs as most peoples mid and forwards are close to completion. Ablett in for one of those three is too sideways and can be done later in the season. Go Adams to someone as he is losing value now. Lastly, Scully will probably average the least so you could be looking at getting him out (Blakely has money to be made).

My trades: Adams to Joyce, Mills to Laird

Side after trades:

Shaw Doch Laird Dea Wagner Ruggles (Collins, Joyce)
Danger Hanners Steven Rockliff Titch Hunter Duncan Blakely (Jansen, Davis)
Martin Gawn (Currie, Cox)
Merret Voldt Dusty Montagna Wells Kerridge (Reid, Mccarthy)

Thoughts?

How much cash remaining for next week?

I like the trades -it's a shame there aren't better options than Joyce around ATM.

 

[RickSanchez]

How do you do the loophole?
To make it easier - I might give Laird a go (Boyd/Vince on bench and not playing due to bye)
If Laird fails, I want Rocky to have the C - Mitchell and Zaharakis on the bench not playing.

 

[Fyfetheknife]

My trades atm are
Wagner > Laird
Tipa > Pierce, Cox into fwds

Next week
Collins > Boyd
Ruggles > any rookie

Defence will be pretty much complete with Gibson at D6.

How do you do the loophole?
To make it easier - I might give Laird a go (Boyd/Vince on bench and not playing due to bye)
If Laird fails, I want Rocky to have the C - Mitchell and Zaharakis on the bench not playing.

V on Laird, C on Rockliff. If Laird goes well, move the C from Rockliff to a non playing player before full lockout on friday night.

 

[Possum Vomit]

How do you do the loophole?
To make it easier - I might give Laird a go (Boyd/Vince on bench and not playing due to bye)
If Laird fails, I want Rocky to have the C - Mitchell and Zaharakis on the bench not playing.

VC on Thursday night player you want to loophole. If they score well, put the C on a non-playing player on your field, if not obviously choose another captain. Easy to do it bye rounds. Outside of byes the easiest is to pick one of your non-playing ruck bench, put them on the field and captain them, and then make your playing ruckman that you benched your emergency.