Round 16 Trades

[mattdb]

I was thinking Hannan > Darcy via DPP and Fisher to a premo mid. That would leave me with SSelwood and Greenwood on the mid bench with the plan of moving Greenwood to the fwd bench but having both Greenwood and SSelwood leaves a lot of cash on the bench and I'm not sure its the right idea. I have $257k and 7 trades left. Thoughts?

 

[GAsnr]

Why not Hannan --> Buzza ? At least he's playing (I think) and can easily make up that extra cash from downing to Bayok, if he does get the games. Plus, that'd be one less donut this week.

Had definitely considered, but I probably won't have enough trades to get rid of Buzza to get that extra cash anyway I reckon. Got enough blokes floating around to upgrade, who will make more than Buzza as well. West Coast have heaps of Sunday games so Bayok is a good loophole option in the fwd line and has DPP

 

[Whiskers]

Buzza's JS is not great.

 

[Waddatars]

Is it completely dumb if I don't pick up this Witherden fella? Have 3 trades after already making two this week. 99K in the bank. On the bench:
Def: Ryan and Shaz
Mid: SPP/Greenwood/Cousins
Forward: NRoo and Strndica
Cheers for thoughts!

 

[Huttabito]

Greenwood out? Is this likely to become a trend? Or is his JS otherwise acceptable? 'Cause this took me a little by surprise.

Oh, and hi friends! Long time lurker, newbie poster. And by long time, I mean, like, this season. First time doing SuperCoach, haven't a clue. So thanks to all for the advice you didn't know you were giving me. Appreciated.

Welcome. Love that you followed up your first post with another trying to help someone out, best way is to get involved and others will be more than welcome to help you out, no-one likes these blow ins just wanting help but offer nothing in return

I think Greenwood out caught everyone by surprise. He has been listed as rested, so I guess we are all hoping that given it's his first run of games (even though he had a bye a few weeks ago...) that they are just easing him in and that Adelaide have opted for some more experience (Thompson) against the Bulldogs mids. Bit more beef to try and help Sloane out a little bit.

Best of luck with your SC team, you'll learn a lot in your first year!

 

[Waddatars]

View attachment 389755 View attachment 389756 Is it completely dumb if I don't pick up this Witherden fella? Have 3 trades after already making two this week. 99K in the bank. On the bench:
Def: Ryan and Shaz
Mid: SPP/Greenwood/Cousins
Forward: NRoo and Strndica
Cheers for thoughts!

Sorry for the 200% zoom first time posting my team

 

[pincrusher]

Welcome. Love that you followed up your first post with another trying to help someone out, best way is to get involved and others will be more than welcome to help you out, no-one likes these blow ins just wanting help but offer nothing in return

I think Greenwood out caught everyone by surprise. He has been listed as rested, so I guess we are all hoping that given it's his first run of games (even though he had a bye a few weeks ago...) that they are just easing him in and that Adelaide have opted for some more experience (Thompson) against the Bulldogs mids. Bit more beef to try and help Sloane out a little bit.

Best of luck with your SC team, you'll learn a lot in your first year!

Rank weather in Adelaide tonight. Any chance Greenwood is a late in? Strange that he is listed as rested but still an emergency.

I'm in a quandary now. Was going to go WHE> Taylor via DPP. However, if I do that I have to play both Hannan and Parsons up forward and one of Witherden or Berry down back with no loop option. If I don't do it I have to play both Berry and Witherden down back, and either Parsons or Hannan up forward but no loop option there. 4 trades left. Thinking of just holding for this week now. $900 short of going Scooter> Adams.

 

[toxic]

View attachment 389755 View attachment 389756 Is it completely dumb if I don't pick up this Witherden fella? Have 3 trades after already making two this week. 99K in the bank. On the bench:
Def: Ryan and Shaz
Mid: SPP/Greenwood/Cousins
Forward: NRoo and Strndica
Cheers for thoughts!

U dont need Witherden

 

[BeanZzZzY]

Parker now or wait for Jelwood to bottom out in a couple of weeks?

Can not be both, will be a potential upgrade of Fyfe after just bringing in Martin for S selwood.

 

[PowerForGood]

AHHHHHH
I am going round and round in circles and reversed changes 100 times!!!!!

Which option you think guys???

1 - Sandi > Darcy & Hannan > Franklin

2. Move Ryder to Ruck & Sandi to Franklin / Yeo & Hannan/Miller > Witherden

3- Sandi > Darcy & Hannan/Miller to Zerret / Jelwood?

9 Trades left

Given you have trades left, i think 2.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Huttabito]

Rank weather in Adelaide tonight. Any chance Greenwood is a late in? Strange that he is listed as rested but still an emergency.

I'm in a quandary now. Was going to go WHE> Taylor via DPP. However, if I do that I have to play both Hannan and Parsons up forward and one of Witherden or Berry down back with no loop option. If I don't do it I have to play both Berry and Witherden down back, and either Parsons or Hannan up forward but no loop option there. 4 trades left. Thinking of just holding for this week now. $900 short of going Scooter> Adams.

Hope so, I would have thought Adelaide were too top heavy. Especially with the forecast weather. End of the day you need emergencies listed and I guess you'd rather have someone who is game ready.

Yeh bit of a pickle, so much money on the bench I'd probably hold too. You will be able to go Scooter to Adams next week, he will drop the $900 and Scooter aint going no-where. With 4 trades left you have to use them sparingly too.

 

[AssassinAndy]

Parsons >>> Buddy
Tuohy >>> Rocky

Rocky will probably burn me but I'm in no man's land in the rankings and not overly fussed about leagues so think he's worth the punt.

 

[pincrusher]

Hope so, I would have thought Adelaide were too top heavy. Especially with the forecast weather. End of the day you need emergencies listed and I guess you'd rather have someone who is game ready.

Yeh bit of a pickle, so much money on the bench I'd probably hold too. You will be able to go Scooter to Adams next week, he will drop the $900 and Scooter aint going no-where. With 4 trades left you have to use them sparingly too.

Tell me about it... If all my first choice players were playing this week and I did do that trade my projected is over 2500.

 

[Red Syrah]

And carnage for me..

Was going to downgrade Stewart and then hold the upgrade, but with GAJ out and Scotty still out..... too many non players and not enough trades.

option 1: 2nd trade - scooter to Gawn (and bolton to mids, ryder to fwd)
option 2: cop a donut

only 5 trades left (so need to think to finals) and $8K in bank

View attachment 389451

second guessing myself now ....

Had decided to go:
Stewart > Witherden
Scooter > Gawn

to get cash and cover donut in the forwards.

But with only 5 trades before trading, wondering about:
Gaz > Gawn

will save a trade (have 4 left instead of 3) and end up with 20K more in bank (90K).
It means this week I'll have berry as m8 and only have playing bench of ryan -def, instead of this:



Is it worth it??

 

[AssassinAndy]

Is it worth it??

I would do the first two trades and keep Gaz.

 

[Red Syrah]

Which means you will


I would do the first two trades and keep Gaz.

Cheers - this last minute panic with not enough trades does my head in!

 

[AssassinAndy]

Cheers - this last minute panic with not enough trades does my head in!

With so few trades left, sideways trading a premium probably not the answer. Scooter and Stewart out are a no brainer.

 

[toxic]

second guessing myself now ....

Had decided to go:
Stewart > Witherden
Scooter > Gawn

to get cash and cover donut in the forwards.

But with only 5 trades before trading, wondering about:
Gaz > Gawn

will save a trade (have 4 left instead of 3) and end up with 20K more in bank (90K).
It means this week I'll have berry as m8 and only have playing bench of ryan -def, instead of this:
View attachment 389775


Is it worth it??

Do the Wither Gawn trades

 

[BeanZzZzY]

Is getting them Darcy and Gawn next week crazy?

Hannan for Darcy...Gave me Cash Generation to get S Selwood to Martin with $217K in the bank with 4 Trades left.

Nank potentially to Gawn next week depending on how Nank goes?

 

[AssassinAndy]

Is getting them Darcy and Gawn next week crazy?

Hannan for Darcy...Gave me Cash Generation to get S Selwood to Martin with $217K in the bank with 4 Trades left.

Nank potentially to Gawn next week depending on how Nank goes?

Sounds ok to me. Gawn won't go up much in value this week. Defo wont hurt to see him for another week to make sure he's back.

 

[Red Syrah]

Do the Wither Gawn trades

Done

 

[raymagoo]

bump

How about stop being that lazy campaigner

 

[raymagoo]

Any thoughts on josh Thomas?

 

[Moustachio]

Any thoughts on josh Thomas?

Looked pretty good last week, fell off a bit late but prolly to be expected after so long out. Should be best 22 and doesn't have injuries in history.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Any thoughts on josh Thomas?

Shithouse funny man thats not funny .