Preview Round 20 - Essendon VS St Kilda - Marvel - Saturday 27/7/24 - 4:35pm AEST

[bombreys]

Saints tearing West Coast apart

We are in real trouble here

 

[Reximilian]

Apparently Guelfi will miss with a hamstring injury. Should bring in Hobbs, Hind, Davey Jnr and Roberts for Guelfi, Goldy, Perkins, and manage Stringer.

 

[MiguelM]

Apparently Guelfi will miss with a hamstring injury. Should bring in Hobbs, Hind, Davey Jnr and Roberts for Guelfi, Goldy, Perkins, and manage Stringer.

Might be a blessing, he was woeful last night

 

[MiguelM]

Apparently Guelfi will miss with a hamstring injury. Should bring in Hobbs, Hind, Davey Jnr and Roberts for Guelfi, Goldy, Perkins, and manage Stringer.

I would think 2MP gets a call up too.

 

[bombreys]

Apparently Guelfi will miss with a hamstring injury. Should bring in Hobbs, Hind, Davey Jnr and Roberts for Guelfi, Goldy, Perkins, and manage Stringer.

Heppell and Wright will be back, they weren’t actually dropped

 

[naraku]

I read somewhere that crows scored 68 points from their clearance work.

So, Setterfield and/or Hobbs need to come in to try to address that issue.


Perkins, Goldy, Menzie, Kelly all in the firing line.

 

[jdstorm]

If there’s any week to try out some of the young guys it’s this one.

Easiest game of the run home. Coming off a bad loss where you can justify dropping quite a few players. Throw a few young guys into the mix and see who stands up.

Out: kelly Goldy Guelfi Perkins
Managed: Stringer

In: Hayes Wright Hobbs Setters Davey

 

[div12ressie]

is parish a chance to return? would be the type of game to get back into form

 

[Wahooti Fandango]

Membrey to kick 10 and Wood to have 20 intercept marks.

 

[Duckworth]

Out: Perkins, Guelfi (inj), Caldwell (inj), Goldy
In: Setterfield, Roberts, Hind, 2MP.

 

[Howard Moon]

STK will make this a very hard game, it's what they do. And seeing we can't get out of our own way it reeks of the classic blunt instrument vs the immovable force game...Ive probably mixed my paradox metaphors there but I know what i mean, with 1 minute to go we will still be in danger of losing

 

[Bombers36]

OUT: Caldwell/Guelfi (injured), Perkins/Goldy (omit)
IN: Setterfield, Hobbs, Hind, 2MP

Ridley McKay Lav
Martin Redman McGrath
Cox Merrett Duursma
Gresham Jones Hind
Langford Caddy Stringer

2MP Durham Hobbs

Bench: Setterfield Shiel Kelly Draper
SUB: Menzie

 

[Yoda_]

STK will make this a very hard game, it's what they do. And seeing we can't get out of our own way it reeks of the classic blunt instrument vs the immovable force game...Ive probably mixed my paradox metaphors there but I know what i mean, with 1 minute to go we will still be in danger of losing

We make things hard on ourselves, that is, before the opposition even gets involved

 

[Bjchan13]

We make things hard on ourselves, that is, before the opposition even gets involved

You could set up 18 mannequins on the ground and we'd struggle to find a way around them to move the ball forward smoothly.

 

[Vindicater]

Okay. After having a few nights to think on it I am all for a huge axe job

OUT: Guelfi (injured), Perkins, (omit) Menzie (omit) Goldstein (omit) and Kelly (omit)
IN: Davey Jr, Hobbs, Hind, Setterfield and Roberts

Ridley McKay McGrath
Roberts Laverde Redman
Martin Merrett Duursma
Gresham Caddy Davey Jr
Langford Cox Hind

Draper Durham Caldwell

Bench: Setterfield Shiel Hobbs Jones
SUB: Stringer

Cox/Jones/Langford to second ruck

 

[mcgrath_truther]

expect me to melt if we lose.

 

[ant555]

expect me to melt if we lose.

again

 

[mcgrath_truther]

again

this one will be nuclear

 

[ant555]

this one will be nuclear

 

[Nifft]

this one will be nuclear

 

[TheGreatBarryB]

Hind omission is a massive head scratcher. He’s a better option than a few players.

And at Marvel Wright needs to come back in for one of the rucks

 

[BomberManU]

Out: my optimism
In: welcome back, pessimism.
Saints by 42, our late season descent will continue for another season.

 

[Darealrath]

I'm more confident about this game than the last couple.

 

[rioli brownlow]

McGrath weideman laverde
Redman Ridley hind
Duursma Durham Martin
Merrett Langford Gresham
A.davey wright caddy
Draper Caldwell Hobbs
Shiel Roberts Cox tsastas
Sub
Stringer

In
Weideman,hind,a.davey,wright,Roberts,Hobbs,tsastas.

Out. Guelfi(inj),Goldy,Perkins,Jones Kelly Menzie
McKay (mang)

 

[TheWeapon]

Out: Guelfi (inj), Menzie, Perkins, Goldstein
In: Davey Jnr, Hobbs, Parish, Hind

Laverde McKay McGrath
Redman Ridley Kelly
Duursma Parish Cox
Martin Langford Gresham
Hind Caddy Davey Jnr
Draper Durham Merrett

Bench: Caldwell Hobbs Jones Stringer
Sub: Shiel

Forward pressure is still a real Achilles heel so picked the two quickest players on our list as forward pockets. Defense just needs to clear the 50 if no safe options inside and rely on players forward of the ball creating a contest. Feel Caddy is worth persisting with purely based on his attack on the footy. Midfield needs to be more accountable