Trades Round 5 Trades - Contenders for dual-position status

[Chaisa]

Decided on Ridley -> Dawson and Jones -> JVR. Hopefully no-one gets rested.

 

[Exambolor]

Sadly have to trade Nank as hes injured.

Second trade a bit up in the air

 

[kaiserchief13]

Why are so many people trading out Mackenzie? As far as I can see he hasn't maxed out yet?

 

[Chaisa]

Why are so many people trading out Mackenzie? As far as I can see he hasn't maxed out yet?

He's probably still closer to being maxed out than the other cash cows. Apart from Jones and if you don't have the DPP flexibility to trade him out (or have already done so....)

 

[PoopingHindi]

Why are so many people trading out Mackenzie? As far as I can see he hasn't maxed out yet?

because it gets me a better player with a lower B/E that could potentially be a keeper

 

[SELFCONFESDAFLNERD]

Goater > Rookie
B.Campbell > W.Powell

 

[blackshadow]

I’ve pressed the button on this and will let it sit for a while.

 

[Hawkboy62]

They have Stewart's BE at 69

I goofed up. The 19 is out of the cycle. So expected LT ave about 110 x 3 - (170 + 92) + 69 (new BE).

 

[Silky23]

Hollands > JVR
Baker > Kossy

Need to take some risks now.

 

[Jiska]

Why are so many people trading out Mackenzie? As far as I can see he hasn't maxed out yet?

Yep I don’t get it. I started a 180k rook to hold down a spot in my starting team. 80k profit? Plus his trend is good game, ordinary game, good game, ordinary game. Due for a 90 this weekend, and playing GWS

 

[Bjchan13]

Think ill hold the trigger on Ridley. A 90ave and shouldn't bleed cash. Targets Sic and Gullpig should lower in price next week.

Cumming and Doch to Dawson and Redman this weeks trades

Really need a mid upgrade soon as i have Hopper at F4 and Sheed with a broken throat on the bench.

Laird, Bont and Touk on the radar but dont have funds to upgrade Sheed to one of them yet. Could go Sheed to Warner but feels a little bit like a trap. Will investigate more during the week. All Rookies still generating cash so will leave them be

 

[Jiska]

Need to get rid of Young. No cash in the bank. Not even sure what to do. Might just have to hold. Can’t see any options cheaper than the spud will be.

**** it. My season is done anyway. Time to throw the rule book out the window. I laughed at others for bringing in Chandler late, so hypocritical, but I’ve got nothing to lose.

Michalanney the best option cheaper than Young, and still a cash cow with a BE of -45 with a 55k projected price rise. And he keeps Wilmot and Cowan on the bench.

Someone talk me in to it, or out of it if theres a better DEF option under 450k

 

[King_Steele]

* it. My season is done anyway. Time to throw the rule book out the window. I laughed at others for bringing in Chandler late, so hypocritical, but I’ve got nothing to lose.

Michalanney the best option cheaper than Young, and still a cash cow with a BE of -45 with a 55k projected price rise. And he keeps Wilmot and Cowan on the bench.

Someone talk me in to it, or out of it if theres a better DEF option under 450k

View attachment 1656043

Yeooo

 

[qarocks]

no injuries this week, weird feeling.
most rooks havent moo'd yet, but talk me out of:

Out
Philipoo
Doch
Ridley
In
Dawson
Lloyd
JVR

 

[Demon13304]

Is too early to get Stewart?

 

[BrutThough]

My trade assist is suggesting to rage trade Sicily. Proof that computers have similar emotions to us

View attachment 1655936

Still makes more sense than mine which suggested trading Daicos

 

[gutsroy]

Pickett doesn't look bad.
Not sure if I can find a good way to get to him that I like, but see the appeal.

 

[King_Steele]

Is too early to get Stewart?

BE of 69 I would say now is the time

Cats start playing at GMHBA after next round too

 

[Makeshift Park]

Yep I don’t get it. I started a 180k rook to hold down a spot in my starting team. 80k profit? Plus his trend is good game, ordinary game, good game, ordinary game. Due for a 90 this weekend, and playing GWS

In two of his four games he's eked out a whole 8 effective disposals.

His CBAs have slided from more than 50% to zilch in the space of four games.

He will moo a bit more, but I'm not very confident he'll deliver another spike game over 90+ points in the near future.

 

[kaiserchief13]

Anyone trading out Worpel? I'm thinking of trading him to L Edwards, then trading Davey to Pickett. Thoughts? Would mean I have to start one of L Edwards, Phillips, Baker or Phillipou on field.

 

[TheArchitect]

JVR feels like a trap IMO

Young key forward, only 50 against WC, with McDonald and Fritsch getting more F50 targets.

Just my thoughts

 

[SSwans2011]

Think ill hold the trigger on Ridley. A 90ave and shouldn't bleed cash. Targets Sic and Gullpig should lower in price next week.

Cumming and Doch to Dawson and Redman this weeks trades

Really need a mid upgrade soon as i have Hopper at F4 and Sheed with a broken throat on the bench.

Laird, Bont and Touk on the radar but dont have funds to upgrade Sheed to one of them yet. Could go Sheed to Warner but feels a little bit like a trap. Will investigate more during the week. All Rookies still generating cash so will leave them be

I've got Doch and Ridley. Difference between the two for mine is I still expect Docherty to eventually return to form. He would have tonned up in round 3 if he used the ball better. Could have gotten a very good score.

I think he's a keeper. I don't think Ridley is. Stewart is probably as cheap as he'll be, so it makes sense to get that done now.

However, dumping him to get Dawson does make perfect sense.

 

[stevebbb]

JVR feels like a trap IMO

Young key forward, only 50 against WC, with McDonald and Fritsch getting more F50 targets.

Just my thoughts

and Ben Brown is available

JVR is helping in the ruck though, so that might keep him in

 

[Obese Arachnid]

The way back to glory!

 

[Jiska]

In two of his four games he's eked out a whole 8 effective disposals.

His CBAs have slided from more than 50% to zilch in the space of four games.

He will moo a bit more, but I'm not very confident he'll deliver another spike game over 90+ points in the near future.

Sicily only had 12 effective today. Day had 13. Reckon there are others who could go first. But hey, I’ve made bad call after bad call this year, so maybe you’re right