NO TROLLS RW and KP's #offtopic Dumpsterfire

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

I'm not sure why but I always associate Grothe with Noel 'Crusher' Cleal, who came a bit later. Were they similar players? I don't really remember Grothe - possibly just before my time.
Cleal was a centre, very burly and direct, played for Easts and Manly. Grothe was a winger, strongly built but not like Cleal. Played for Parramatta. Both played Origin and for Australia 1979-1989.
 
Cleal was a centre, very burly and direct, played for Easts and Manly. Grothe was a winger, strongly built but not like Cleal. Played for Parramatta. Both played Origin and for Australia 1979-1989.

I know Crusher played for the Sea Eagles. I thought he was a forward (second rower) but used to make amazing runs up the wings carrying the balls and barging through opponents and then often unloading before being brought to ground. I don't actually remember Grothe even though he was playing at the same time as I was watching (from about the mid 80s to the very early 90s).
 
I know Crusher played for the Sea Eagles. I thought he was a forward (second rower) but used to make amazing runs up the wings carrying the balls and barging through opponents and then often unloading before being brought to ground. I don't actually remember Grothe even though he was playing at the same time as I was watching (from about the mid 80s to the very early 90s).
Cleal played both centre and second rower. Your memory doesn't fail you!
 
There's an NRL thread going along, feel free to join in NRL - NRL 2023 Season - Round 1

Trying to get some discussion going on for this season :)

I have absolutely zero interest in league these days (and for a long time). I was a Balmain fan and they killed my club. Then came SuperLeague and I left and never looked back. I don't watch Origin and couldn't tell you who the current premiers are but I remember Cronulla won a couple of years ago. I'm more than happy sticking to footy. For a second string sport I go to sumo.
 
Superleague killed it for me too.
I have absolutely zero interest in league these days (and for a long time). I was a Balmain fan and they killed my club. Then came SuperLeague and I left and never looked back. I don't watch Origin and couldn't tell you who the current premiers are but I remember Cronulla won a couple of years ago. I'm more than happy sticking to footy. For a second string sport I go to sumo.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Of course Bud plays. Not as critical as he was but still bloody useful.

Totally different to a jpk situation where he was too slow and a liability in transition footy.
No-one needs a drive-by on JPK. He's retired, get over it.
 
Beg your pardon. Forgot you're the Barrett of the joint
I have no idea what that means. You've just taken every opportunity to pot JPK in the past, everyone was over it then and we'll react when you continue to do it. Yes he suffered when played in defence, that's on the coaches. They shouldn't have played him there.
 
I have no idea what that means. You've just taken every opportunity to pot JPK in the past, everyone was over it then and we'll react when you continue to do it. Yes he suffered when played in defence, that's on the coaches. They shouldn't have played him there.

He should have retired in 2021. Your ignorance qualifies you to write for Fox Footy.

My point is Buds case is different as he is still is Best 22 imo.
 
He should have retired in 2021. Your ignorance qualifies you to write for Fox Footy.

My point is Buds case is different as he is still is Best 22 imo.
You can have that view, many disagreed. What followed was every opportunity taken by you to take shots, including personal ones.

That's why people will react when you take another crack (albeit not personal in this case) after he's retired.
 
You can have that view, many disagreed. What followed was every opportunity taken by you to take shots, including personal ones.

That's why people will react when you take another crack (albeit not personal in this case) after he's retired.

Never personal until I was repeatedly attacked by fan Bois like you..

I was completely vindicated as 2022 unfolded. Still waiting for your apology

Tragically the wonderful career of JPK ended in ignominy with completely out of character violence.
 
Never personal until I was repeatedly attacked by fan Bois like you..

I was completely vindicated as 2022 unfolded. Still waiting for your apology

Tragically the wonderful career of JPK ended in ignominy with completely out of character violence.
Personal against JPK. I don't get how that's ok, just because other footy fans disagree with you.

You won't be getting an apology.
 
Personal against JPK. I don't get how that's ok, just because other footy fans disagree with you.

You won't be getting an apology.
Rubbish.. thought he was wrong to play on and said it. sue me.
 
One passage of play on the weekend solidified my view that McLean faces an uncertain future:

The sight of Frost sprinting past him with absolute ease.

I’m just not sure modern AFL forwards can thrive without a reasonable burst of speed. Hawkins perhaps - but I can’t think of too many others.
Yeah recall watching that and thinking "ouch". I think if he was the one to stay close to home and contest when we just kick it in long, there's a spot. He can also use his body to create enough space for a mark. But you'd want the likes of Logan, Amartey to be leading, up around 50 etc.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

NO TROLLS RW and KP's #offtopic Dumpsterfire

Similar threads

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top