Rules S33 Rules & Tribunal Thread

[NaturalDisaster]

The word superfluent is used at one stage in the rules. It is a neat word that also could be applied to much of the preceding discussion.

It also can be misinterpreted, or misused in tortured puns. (I am showing my usual restraint.)

Fluency in English, or in this case it's absence, has emerged as a problem for the Committee and the Admin.

It seems a miscarriage of justice may have occurred because of literacy problems. This is not without irony, given one of the penalised individuals struggles with English as a First Language. Still it is to be hoped justice prevails.

The lessons are clear. "Grunt" is not a language. Clear and concise English should be used by the Admin and Committee.

The good news is Ned_Flanders Tigerturbulance and the fine folk at the Ophidians OB run basic literacy programs. A place has been reserved for NaturalDisaster

I actually just copied Ant Bear ‘s OP.

 

[Grand Uncle Horace]

I actually just copied Ant Bear ‘s OP.

You are the true master of copy/paste.

 

[Headless]

I actually just copied Ant Bear ‘s OP.

And here I was thinking you re-typed the whole thing.

I feel so foolish.

 

[NaturalDisaster]

And here I was thinking you re-typed the whole thing.

I feel so foolish.

I only re-worded anything that needed to be.

 

[Grand Uncle Horace]

And here I was thinking you re-typed the whole thing.

I feel so foolish.

Apparently Elton Johns Wig is to tutor ND. One method will be for ND to type the Rules out 30 times. This is a basic start. It is hoped his English improves along with his knowledge and understanding of the words and the totality of the Rules.

 

[TJASTA]

I actually just copied Ant Bear ‘s OP.

Mighty job Wacky Disaster

 

[NaturalDisaster]

Mighty job Wacky Disaster

I learned from the best, it is why my teamsheet record as captain was perfect.

 

[Grand Uncle Horace]

I learned from the best, it is why my teamsheet record as captain was perfect.

If nothing else!

 

[Ned_Flanders]

A few committee members misinterpreted my wording when I called for the vote. Out of fairness, I am calling it again.

... Yeah I think I might just leave this one alone...

 

[damicky]

... Yeah I think I might just leave this one alone...

Come on Ned

You know you want to

 

[NaturalDisaster]

Verdict of RE-Vote

All committee members have voted to either dismiss or uphold the High Impact Charge on the Bombers. If upheld, the HI charge would remain, if dismissed, the charge would be downgraded to a Medium Impact.

The Bombers challenge has been successful with 6 committee members voting to dismiss the High Impact charge. Thus, their charge for incorrect Squad Submission will be downgraded to Medium Impact. Captains BLUEALLTHRU and Metalcrusher will still miss a week, but the Bombers will no longer receive a -2 point penalty.

 

[Headless]

HI charge

And the charge says hello back to you, too.

 

[ClarkeM]

Verdict of RE-Vote

All committee members have voted to either dismiss or uphold the High Impact Charge on the Bombers. If upheld, the HI charge would remain, if dismissed, the charge would be downgraded to a Medium Impact.

The Bombers challenge has been successful with 6 committee members voting to dismiss the High Impact charge. Thus, their charge for incorrect Squad Submission will be downgraded to Medium Impact. Captains BLUEALLTHRU and Metalcrusher will still miss a week, but the Bombers will no longer receive a -2 point penalty.

A better result.

Now, one must ask the question as to whether the rules are amended to reflect whether incorrect Ins/Outs in the Squad Submission constitute either High or Medium Impact.

 

[Ned_Flanders]

Verdict of RE-Vote

All committee members have voted to either dismiss or uphold the High Impact Charge on the Bombers. If upheld, the HI charge would remain, if dismissed, the charge would be downgraded to a Medium Impact.

The Bombers challenge has been successful with 6 committee members voting to dismiss the High Impact charge. Thus, their charge for incorrect Squad Submission will be downgraded to Medium Impact. Captains BLUEALLTHRU and Metalcrusher will still miss a week, but the Bombers will no longer receive a -2 point penalty.

Did all the committee members understand what they were doing this time, or should I await the final feature in this trilogy?

 

[Metalcrusher]

Did all the committee members understand what they were doing this time, or should I await the final feature in this trilogy?

There will be a media piece to follow ...

 

[Supersuns]

Verdict of RE-Vote

All committee members have voted to either dismiss or uphold the High Impact Charge on the Bombers. If upheld, the HI charge would remain, if dismissed, the charge would be downgraded to a Medium Impact.

The Bombers challenge has been successful with 6 committee members voting to dismiss the High Impact charge. Thus, their charge for incorrect Squad Submission will be downgraded to Medium Impact. Captains BLUEALLTHRU and Metalcrusher will still miss a week, but the Bombers will no longer receive a -2 point penalty.

Cowardice

 

[Mobbs]

Verdict of RE-Vote

All committee members have voted to either dismiss or uphold the High Impact Charge on the Bombers. If upheld, the HI charge would remain, if dismissed, the charge would be downgraded to a Medium Impact.

The Bombers challenge has been successful with 6 committee members voting to dismiss the High Impact charge. Thus, their charge for incorrect Squad Submission will be downgraded to Medium Impact. Captains BLUEALLTHRU and Metalcrusher will still miss a week, but the Bombers will no longer receive a -2 point penalty.

I am ashamed. I honestly did not put this much credence in the Committee to bring about this change, and I was wrong. Well done all on a poor process, processed well, and followed to a conclusion that I truly believe is the correct one!

 

[ClarkeM]

processed well

But they didn't even understand what they were doing the first time

 

[Metalcrusher]

But they didn't even understand what they were doing the first time

Thats because NaturalDisaster can't type english properly and confused every campaigner.

 

[ClarkeM]

Thats because NaturalDisaster can't type english properly and confused every campaigner.

The fish rots...

 

[Mobbs]

Everybody should be happy, both the camp for justice and the camp for drama. We got both!

 

[Metalcrusher]

Everybody should be happy, both the camp for justice and the camp for drama. We got both!

COPYRIGHT campaigner!!!!

 

[Mobbs]

COPYRIGHT campaigner!!!!

ahaha i didnt even notice it was your avatar until you said this LOL. i literally just had that quote come to me thinking it was appropriate

 

[Metalcrusher]

ahaha i didnt even notice it was your avatar until you said this LOL. i literally just had that quote come to me thinking it was appropriate

I keep mine off centred because it triggers Tonga Bob

 

[Barrybran]

I am ashamed. I honestly did not put this much credence in the Committee to bring about this change, and I was wrong. Well done all on a poor process, processed well, and followed to a conclusion that I truly believe is the correct one!

If it makes you feel any better the committee has effectively tripped arse over head into the right outcome helped along the way by the admin