Injury SACK DOCTORS 1 - CTE

[Del165198]

You must love supporting a club where David Koch is chairman, Matthew Richardson is CEO, Ken Hinkley is coach and Tom Jonas is captain.

why do you think i've been a TOP 3 POSTER in the last 57 sack hinkley threads?

 

[rabidcrow]

I know the one about Boak in 2016. If Saturday night was incident two, what is number 3?

Didn’t know about the Boak one. The other incidents that have stood out

$20k fine for an issue with handling Hartlett concussion a few years back - not following protocol

The other one was Butters and Jonas head clash last year. Both players bleeding heavily after head clash, close game in the balance and both back on within a few minutes with a mountain of tape around there heads to try and stop bleeding (no concussion check then either)

The articles are floating around throughout the threads


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[PA88]

Yeah I've seen replays of the clash but couldn't piece the details.

Strangely I am thinking about Granger and the preliminary final.

 

[Del165198]

Yeah I've seen replays of the clash but couldn't piece the details.

Strangely I am thinking about Granger and the preliminary final.

in years gone by it was seen as brave as courageous. and yeah, there's a degree of that, but the player who is concussed might not even know they're concussed. but they know it 20 years down the track. and hopefully as a society we've moved on and can understand that, and can recognise that players deserve a decent quality of life afterward. not gonna comment on granger's mental health which has been a matter of ridicule by adelaide media..

 

[PA88]

in years gone by it was seen as brave as courageous. and yeah, there's a degree of that, but the player who is concussed might not even know they're concussed. but they know it 20 years down the track. and hopefully as a society we've moved on and can understand that, and can recognise that players deserve a decent quality of life afterward. not gonna comment on granger's mental health which has been a matter of ridicule by adelaide media..

No wasn't meaning his mental health.
Difficult to believe that the doctor isn't questioned at the time, given previous happenings.

 

[edgie]

Shoutout to the Crows fans that suddenly care about the safety and well-being of our players

Same ones that boo'd Jay Schulz when he was nearly blinded against them

Sent from my Nokia 7.2 using Tapatalk

 

[Lagooner]

Did Dr Fisher stuff up your circumcision or something?

Bloody hell is any head safe from this quack?!

 

[edgie]

Didn’t know about the Boak one. The other incidents that have stood out

$20k fine for an issue with handling Hartlett concussion a few years back - not following protocol

The other one was Butters and Jonas head clash last year. Both players bleeding heavily after head clash, close game in the balance and both back on within a few minutes with a mountain of tape around there heads to try and stop bleeding (no concussion check then either)

The articles are floating around throughout the threads


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Blood has nothing to do with it, as I've been replied mentioning the many head knocks Selwood has copped that some are ok with. Based on that, then there was nothing wrong with the Butters and Jonas calls. Why are people still bringing it up that there were bleeding?

Sent from my Nokia 7.2 using Tapatalk

 

[edgie]

Third last time I was concussed, they cancelled the game because I was completely unconscious for 15 - 20 minutes in the last quarter. This greatly annoyed me as when I came to I was denied the opportunity to tough it out and return to play.

Sent from my Nokia 7.2 using Tapatalk

 

[rogerjames]

4 players in 1 practice game. None come off the field after the hits, none get subbed out. Don't buy into the narrative that we are doing anything diff to other clubs.

Crows players head slammed into the ground by Marshall, not looked at.

No club will sub 2 players out of a game 5 minutes in unless they are basically dead.

So those 2 clashes get minimised, so typical

 

[Schulzenfest]

Well this is certainly the most popular Port board thread with opposition posters since ... the 2007 GF, probably?

Good way of gauging what a serious ****up this was.

 

[JimmyBC]

Bickley wants us to lose the ANZAC fixture.. no agenda there lol

 

[theouthouse]

AFL should really be having an independant doctor check off our list and assess who can be passed fit to play or not each game for the remainder of the year at minimum.

Sure Dr Teo saved some lives and bought happiness to families but he also destroyed some lives and brought misery to families watching their loved ones being vegetables for their remaining days.

Too much risk taking involved with this Port doctor.

 

[John the Butcher]

Bickley wants us to lose the ANZAC fixture.. no agenda there lol

What the hell may as well take our 11 home games off us too, and no crowds also. This guy is a clown.

 

[JimmyBC]

What the hell may as well take our 11 home games off us too, and no crowds also. This guy is a clown.

His reasoning was a 100k fine out of the cap etc. only hurts the position of a lower rung employee, so take their season requests away lose the ANZAC fixture blah blah.. yes no self interest there of course.

 

[bomberclifford]

The outrage pile on for this is an interesting phenomenon to watch. That main board thread is quite something.

 

[morell]

If it was his first **** up ... Written warning

But it's not. Its like his third or fourth. Most disciplinary procedures in HR world have guidance on this when the performance has the same theme or type eg start with verbal, then written, then final, then termination.

If we are in any way a football club that has accountability as part of our culture, he needs to be fired.

 

[morell]

The outrage pile on for this is an interesting phenomenon to watch. That main board thread is quite something.

That's because it's really bad mate.

 

[Schulzenfest]

Bickley wants us to lose the ANZAC fixture.. no agenda there lol

I would have thought sending young men into danger under false pretences perfectly embodies what ANZAC Day is all about.

 

[Ford Fairlane]

The outrage pile on for this is an interesting phenomenon to watch. That main board thread is quite something.

We live in a society that wants to be outraged so they can express an opinion. The blessing of social media.

 

[Papa G]

The outrage pile on for this is an interesting phenomenon to watch. That main board thread is quite something.

Lead by our Chief dweeb Cuck no less.

 

[Papa G]

That's because it's really bad mate.

Jesus. No it isn't. Nothing actually happened. Our supporter base has now become reflective of how weak the club is as a whole. Pant Shitters.

 

[bomberclifford]

If it was his first * up ... Written warning

But it's not. Its like his third or fourth. Most disciplinary procedures in HR world have guidance on this when the performance has the same theme or type eg start with verbal, then written, then final, then termination.

If we are in any way a football club that has accountability as part of our culture, he needs to be fired.

What were the first ‘three or four’ incidents? Be specific.

 

[JimmyBC]

Jesus. No it isn't. Nothing actually happened. Our supporter base has now become reflective of how weak the club is as a whole. Pant Shitters.

It's not 1985 mate sending Aliir back out there was a joke, cop what's coming and do better. Pretty simple.

 

[bomberclifford]

We live in a society that wants to be outraged so they can express an opinion. The blessing of social media.

It feels very disproportionate to what actually occurred and makes having a genuine discussion about it virtually impossible.