Sandilands bump on davis, 1-2 weeks?

[Upgrayedd]

Looked savage, Sandilands did nothing wrong but when someone runs into a 211cm and 110+ kilos Giant its going to be nasty

 

[Defacto]

Will sandilands get rubbed out for that bump? Shoulder connected with davis's head.

 

[The Spike]

Re: Phil Davis Cleaned up by Sandilands

did nothing wrong???

Under the new interpretation, he is gone for 4 weeks. Hard impact of his shoulder directly to the head.

 

[hendrie]

Re: Phil Davis Cleaned up by Sandilands

I don't know . If Sandilands' name was Lance Franklin it would be weeks!

 

[Bennett.]

Will sandilands get rubbed out for that bump? Shoulder connected with davis's head.

He shouldn't go, because there was no malice and just 2 people going for the ball - unfortunately shoulder height of a 7 foot tall man is head hight for lesser mortals.

Having said that, 3 weeks knowing the MRP

 

[Brasil2007]

Re: Phil Davis Cleaned up by Sandilands

Very courageous from the kid. He'd have known there were some big bodies coming at him and didn't flinch. Hope he can get back out today.

 

[Altum Volantes]

Nothing in that, quite obviously.

Did everything right I thought.

 

[crownie]

no different to the Habrow and Lewis collision really, Sandilands charged with all intension to mark.

shouldnt get rubbed out.

 

[maryjames]

Re: Phil Davis Cleaned up by Sandilands

Hille would get off...........

But it may be 3..

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Davis didn't have the ball, so no option to tackle. Did all he could do but got the head.

Deserves nothing, will get 3+

 

[BaliHawk]

Re: Phil Davis Cleaned up by Sandilands

geez I just saw that...ouch, now this will be a test for the MRP and all us whinging Hawk supporters when they come back with 'it was accidental, he had no option and was making a marking contest, that he hit Davis in the head was due to the difference in their height '

 

[Ron The Bear]

Will be fascinating to see the outcome. Sandilands turned side-on and collected Davis with the shoulder.

 

[WASaintsFan08]

isnt the rule that if you go to hip and shoulder when you have another choice and you make contact with the ops head that youre going to get done????

or is that just sometimes....

few years ago nothing in it... but under current rules atleast 2 weeks youd expect

due to the head contact when going for the bump

 

[mad_eagle]

Dirtiest player in the league, give him six weeks

Throw the book at him...




If he gets anything I give up on this game

 

[Brasil2007]

I have no idea. I've given up trying too read the MRP's minds. I would have thought a reprimand or at the outside a week because I thought he was trying to bump rather than mark. But then again when you look back at Hille on Bartel - one which most people thought was worth time off - Hille didn't get anything and clearly wasn't even thinking about anything but taking him out. Similarly in a slightly different situation I didn't think there was much in the Mumford one - legal tackle on a player with the ball but the MRP saw differently. So I have no idea where the lines are for a lot of these things any more.

 

[longsuffreosupp]

No head contact - maybe a bit of whiplash though.

 

[Byron_Clanger]

Both going for the ball, absolutely nothing in it and if he goes then it's a joke

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Re: Phil Davis Cleaned up by Sandilands

Compared to the Buddy ones....Buddy's hits all came when the bloke had the ball. Buddy could have tackled each guy but chose not to.

Should get off, hope he does

 

[JUBJUB]

Nothing in it.
Davis now knows what it's like to run into a brick wall

 

[crownie]

isnt the rule that if you go to hip and shoulder when you have another choice and you make contact with the ops head that youre going to get done????

its a tough one with all the rules and intepretations, he wasnt going for the hip and shoulder, he was going for the mark and hit him with a reflex action.

 

[walken79]

Will sandilands get rubbed out for that bump? Shoulder connected with davis's head.

Are you serious??

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Will sandilands get rubbed out for that bump? Shoulder connected with davis's head.

Depends if they use the Hille rule or the Franklin rule.

 

[Byron_Clanger]

Re: Phil Davis Cleaned up by Sandilands

Nothing in it, shouldn't go

 

[Clay Davis]

No contact to the head.

 

[Upgrayedd]

at 6'11" its hard not to clean someone up when your running towards a contest, im not even convinced Sandi touched Davis' head, it seemed more of a whiplash effect, Sandilands had another option rather then to go the man, and it was to pull out and let Davis collect the uncontested mark, Nothing else he could of done

0 Weeks.