Teams SC 2016 - My Team (Post NAB)

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Looks good. What do you think Wingard will average? I'm currently having the Dusty v Wingard debate for my team.
Had the same issue but downgraded for the dosh! Im not super strong on Wingard but a) Port have quite a soft draw, especially early on! and b) he has had a solid preseason from all reports and is a game changer. I think with natural progression he can only go up, if he stays forward he kicks more goals and if he goes into the mids he will get more touches. I just think he is the type of player who will score well regardless of what happens. Doesnt have any real faults unless he gets shut out of the game up forward - but when will that ever happen? With Dusty he does have a ? on his kicking which makes him susceptible to poor games every now and again. That along with his daddy issues (poor excuse) and sometimes poor demeanour impacting frees against etc. means that I could see a poor game impact. I wouldnt bet on it though. As I said I sort of hate myself for taking him out but I dont think Wingard will average that much less. But he will score less.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Had the same issue but downgraded for the dosh! Im not super strong on Wingard but a) Port have quite a soft draw, especially early on! and b) he has had a solid preseason from all reports and is a game changer. I think with natural progression he can only go up, if he stays forward he kicks more goals and if he goes into the mids he will get more touches. I just think he is the type of player who will score well regardless of what happens. Doesnt have any real faults unless he gets shut out of the game up forward - but when will that ever happen? With Dusty he does have a ? on his kicking which makes him susceptible to poor games every now and again. That along with his daddy issues (poor excuse) and sometimes poor demeanour impacting frees against etc. means that I could see a poor game impact. I wouldnt bet on it though. As I said I sort of hate myself for taking him out but I dont think Wingard will average that much less. But he will score less.
Does Wingard ever go into the middle? High forward I thougth. but never seen him in the middle.
I'm having the Wingard wrestle in my mind too.
 
I know this isn't the right thread but there is a lot of traffic here and I can't find the original thread. Can anyone link me to the SC 2015 winner's team? Thanks in advance
 
Looks pretty standard. Hoskin Elliot pick is a bit odd. What's the reasoning behind that? Rookies might need some work, especially that midfield, Gore and Petracca will miss games, although to be fair not many rookies can be confidently picked until teams are out for rd 1.

Thanks. That was one of my worries that it might be a little bit stock standard, will have to do a bit more shuffling around.

Yeah i know the rookies are not the best, but was hoping to get myself a full bench (wait until rd1 teams are out) then trade around from there.

Just traded out Hoskin-Elliott (good point made by you! what was i thinking!!) for Menzel, then I have gone with Mumford over Blicavs now.
 
1st rough draft a lot of rookies to be culled. 333k left

def shaw,rance,laird,bartel,wetering,dea emg ruggles and tippa

mid fyfe,gazza,rockliff,crouch,mills,oliver,menadue,gresham emg keays,polkinghorne,davis

rucks goldy,martin emg grimley

fwd dusty,barlow,greene,wells,milera,kerridge emg brown and petracca

mids are really light on and thats where i will chop and change getting in who i want. any suggestions of who to cut
 
Critique away please! don't be shy only 3 days left and need all the help i can get!

Thanks in advance.

upload_2016-3-21_20-9-55.png
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Have 17 the same differing mainly on premo mids. Wonder if right picks there will separate wheat from chaff
They can as you can run into injuries etc that can't be planned for BUT SC is really won on your trading and timing with a bit of luck too.
 
Critique away please! don't be shy only 3 days left and need all the help i can get!

Thanks in advance.

View attachment 226919

Do you have a lot of money left over?

You're sort of 'one short' up front and don't have Goldstein, yet I don't really see where the money has been used?
Your backs are OK - maybe a bit much having both Dea and Weitering?
Then your mids are good, but with the money saved from your forward and rucks I'd have expected something more...

All the players you've selected are fine btw, just expected to see ground made up elsewhere...
 
Ok guys done a few changes not sure tho, tell me what u think?
2f030087599a05f933a344651639d326.jpg
5ced4a9bf5f89787abb89c6a73668695.jpg
 
Really happy with this, however I am sure it will require a rethink once teams come out..

B: Shaw, Laird, Bartel, Dea, Hartley, Lee (Brown, Ruggles)
M: Fyfe, Pendlebury, Ablett, Selwood, Rockliff, Liberatore, Mills, Kennedy (Menadue, Hewett, Davis)
R: Goldstein, Gawn (Grimley)
F: Wingard, Barlow, Hall, Wells, McCarthy, Kerridge (Adams, Tipungwuti-McDonald)

$24.3k left!
Will Lee play R1, and think he can hold down a KPD role?
 
Critique away please! don't be shy only 3 days left and need all the help i can get!

Thanks in advance.

View attachment 226919

I like it, structure is pretty similar to mine but do you need Trengove on the bench? I would've thought there'd be quite a few VFL games to get back into the swing of things first. Missed a fair chunk of footy. I'd be looking for a way to downgrade him so you can upgrade one of your rucks to Goldy or Sheridan to a premo.
 
Updated. Only changes I'll make are probably rookies. This bloody game is already doing my head in.

View attachment 226933
Your backs and forwards look a bit light? How much money do you have left? I'd look to re-allocate some of your MID funds to sure up those lines.

upload_2016-3-21_21-4-3.png

I'm pretty happy with mine. Rookies to change come team selection. Honest thoughts please? Be as brutal as possible
 

To be honest I thought the same thing until about a month ago. I now have him at F4 but I can see it turning to shit, but then I look at his numbers from the last 7-8 weeks last year, whatever it was, and I wonder why everyone doesn't have him? Then, I look at him in my team and I think why the **** do I have him? I don't trust him, he could be a huge bust but I feel like he needs to be picked. I'm so torn. I had Greene for a long time and thought he was easily the best pick, then you look at his entire season last year and he looks like a pile of innefective shit. Then you go back again and look at his last 7-8 weeks of 2014 and wonder why he can't be the top scoring fwd this year. ****.
 
To be honest I thought the same thing until about a month ago. I now have him at F4 but I can see it turning to shit, but then I look at his numbers from the last 7-8 weeks last year, whatever it was, and I wonder why everyone doesn't have him? Then, I look at him in my team and I think why the **** do I have him? I don't trust him, he could be a huge bust but I feel like he needs to be picked. I'm so torn. I had Greene for a long time and thought he was easily the best pick, then you look at his entire season last year and he looks like a pile of innefective shit. Then you go back again and look at his last 7-8 weeks of 2014 and wonder why he can't be the top scoring fwd this year. ****.
I have Greene, and I'm not sure how I feel about that. o_O
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top