It will be disappointing if we miss finals, but I disagree that we've meekly disappeared given the nightmarish run of injuries we've had THROUGHOUT the year. Every time we get someone back, someone else gets a long-term injury and there's only so much you can do with a bunch of guys lacking in cohesion, match fitness and form.
You look at what happened when West Coast were hit with injuries last year compared to their dream run this year. What's changed? They haven't gone out and completely changed their gameplan or gained any extra guns (although the contribution of Shuey, Darling at the start and Gaff recently has helped) but they've jumped an unprecedented 12 spots on the ladder.
I'm at the stage where I think we just don't have the cattle to beat some of the top sides. If we miss finals because we get beaten by the better team on the day (and that will happen with our run home) but the playing group shows they're applying themselves 100%, I can accept that. What else can you ask of them?
But if we miss finals and look like a bunch of pea hearts doing it, then that will be a black mark against the club.
Well, they have at the very least tweaked the game plan significantly. Whether that is due to players and player development is a moot point. We have also changed our game plan. In terms of their performance last year, the additions of Shuey, Darling and Gaff is a deliberate attempt to improve skills, which has happened. Their gameplan required improved skills, and they addressed it.
Nobody is saying that injuries don't impact, of course they do. But if we have any sense that a window may be even a little bit ajar for us, then we must leave nothing to chance, and there have been lots of things that have not been done.
Schammer is a good example; If he was never going to play again, why wasn't his contract paid out and Lower selected on the main list, and another rookie added? The Pitt/Darling question is also worth asking. Why did we draft Anthony? He doesn't seem to be cover for anybody, because we have needed a big forward, but apparently don't need him. The use of Palmer, Pavlich and MJ have been pretty interesting too. The way players have been brought in after injuries. The use of the Sub.
I think we can improve in many areas on what has happened this year, and we need to.