SFNL Division 3 2018

[Frank and Beans]

What’s all this about? What did Carroll do?

 

[YaMule]

What’s all this about? What did Carroll do?

D.Carroll got 5 weeks at the tribunal which took him over the threshold.

Black Rock sooks complained to the league along with THEIR OWN footage to which the league handed down the suspension.
Wasn’t even a free kick paid in the contest let along a card or a on field report.....go figure?!?!

Not the first time Black Rock have done this!

I wonder if Black Rock will be letting the league look at their tape of the game to investigate the Ashwood player that was felled behind play

My mail is next year at Ashwood they’ll get about 30 secs of footage and that’s it!

 

[Tigersman]

D.Carroll got 5 weeks at the tribunal which took him over the threshold.

Black Rock sooks complained to the league along with THEIR OWN footage to which the league handed down the suspension.
Wasn’t even a free kick paid in the contest let along a card or a on field report.....go figure?!?!

Not the first time Black Rock have done this!

I wonder if Black Rock will be letting the league look at their tape of the game to investigate the Ashwood player that was felled behind play

My mail is next year at Ashwood they’ll get about 30 secs of footage and that’s it!

Good work by Black Rock. Plenty of clubs filming every game for exactly this reason.

 

[Sratsky]

The sort of imbacilic reply excepted.

Knows nothing about football.....he’s won multiple senior flags at a better level than SFL DIV 1, you wouldn’t even carry his bag!

Going in hard to hurt intentionally you say, there wasn’t even a free kick paid!
Wether it was him or any other player how does “play on” then to a 5 week suspension add up??

I haven't seen the incident but I have heard that there were pretty severe injuries from it. it makes no difference if there was a free kick paid or not. that just means the ump didn't see anything in it. 5 weeks is a huge suspension so regardless of what you think, the act must have been pretty severe

 

[YaMule]

I haven't seen the incident but I have heard that there were pretty severe injuries from it. it makes no difference if there was a free kick paid or not. that just means the ump didn't see anything in it. 5 weeks is a huge suspension so regardless of what you think, the act must have been pretty severe

I’ve aware from several people who have viewed the footage, and there’s conjecture that the football was between the Black Rock player and the spoil attemp.
In the tribunal it was said they “heard skin on skin contact”, it reeks of a bit of guess work and the injuries determining the suspension.

As you said the umps didn’t see anything in it apart from a spoil maybe?? It’s football a lot of injuries occur from legimate contact etc.
Does it mean as soon as there’s and injury let’s try and report/suspend someone!

 

[Bounceback]

I’ve aware from several people who have viewed the footage, and there’s conjecture that the football was between the Black Rock player and the spoil attemp.
In the tribunal it was said they “heard skin on skin contact”, it reeks of a bit of guess work and the injuries determining the suspension.

As you said the umps didn’t see anything in it apart from a spoil maybe?? It’s football a lot of injuries occur from legimate contact etc.
Does it mean as soon as there’s and injury let’s try and report/suspend someone!

“It reeks of a bit of guess work.....”. So the independent tribunal gave him 5, not 1,2,3 or 4..but 5 Weeks based on a guess. As someone stated earlier, You Are A Moron!

 

[Frank and Beans]

Wow, sounds like a controversial call. What happened to the guy who got hit? I haven’t seen the footage so can’t comment

 

[WheelieP]

Let’s see if their footage will be used on/against their own player?

There’s never anything to report.

 

[WheelieP]

Wow, sounds like a controversial call. What happened to the guy who got hit? I haven’t seen the footage so can’t comment

Concussion and let’s just say his face exploded

 

[YaMule]

The boys are onto my replaced spelling , spell check F#*K wit , get an idea yamule ( ideal name) for a peanut , again 13 weeks up his sleeve bed made , no one else to blame but himself , the boys on the panel saw the footage and they know wat their doing in there , dunno bout you but if I was on 13 weeks and at the end of a "prestigious" career ( hahaha sarcasm on prestigious) I'd maybe tone it down abit , your clearly as thick as a sunday morning grogan

Glad you mentioned user names...yours.....
13 weeks over a 15 + year career.
Tone it down, surely you know the old saying.....pot and kettle.....
They know what they’re doing, well that debatable on a number of things?

 

[YaMule]

Concussion and let’s just say his face exploded

Was reported “6 stitches and a concussion” ??

 

[YaMule]

There’s never anything to report.

Of course there isn’t, what’s good for one is good for the other

 

[Frank and Beans]

Of course there isn’t, what’s good for one is good for the other

Maybe it might be time for ashwood to start filming their games

 

[YaMule]

It seems as though that’s the way it’s heading

 

[WheelieP]

It seems as though that’s the way it’s heading

They’ll just have to make sure they don’t film anything behind play. We all know half of the club loves to run past the ball and follow through

 

[Collo77]

crawl back into the dumpster at the top of the hill on huntingdale rd jerk off

That would still be better facilities than your abysmal rooms!

 

[local hack]

Nothing like a bit of victim blaming. Tribunal gave him 5 weeks!
Will Ashwood appeal??

 

[Jesslc]

I’ve aware from several people who have viewed the footage, and there’s conjecture that the football was between the Black Rock player and the spoil attemp.
In the tribunal it was said they “heard skin on skin contact”, it reeks of a bit of guess work and the injuries determining the suspension.

As you said the umps didn’t see anything in it apart from a spoil maybe?? It’s football a lot of injuries occur from legimate contact etc.
Does it mean as soon as there’s and injury let’s try and report/suspend someone!

What are you sooking about mate? They handed over footage cause a player got punched behind play. They saw exactly what happened and handed him the suspension. What else do you need? Do you want D. Carroll to coward punch you too so you get the whole experience?

Give it a rest. Video replays weed out dirty players. Simple as that.

 

[Concrete Jungle]

What are you sooking about mate? They handed over footage cause a player got punched behind play. They saw exactly what happened and handed him the suspension. What else do you need? Do you want D. Carroll to coward punch you too so you get the whole experience?

Give it a rest. Video replays weed out dirty players. Simple as that.

Would be better if you had half an idea of what actually happened before commenting.

Behind play???
Coward punch???

It was in a marking contest!

The only “behind play” incident on the day was a Black Rock player felling and Ashwood player.

 

[Tigersman]

Would be better if you had half an idea of what actually happened before commenting.

Behind play???
Coward punch???

It was in a marking contest!

The only “behind play” incident on the day was a Black Rock player felling and Ashwood player.

Surely to get that many weeks the video wasn’t pretty.

If Ashwood have appealed then the investigation is able to look into the entire game, not just the one incident.
Mention the other incident if it happened.

 

[Jesslc]

Would be better if you had half an idea of what actually happened before commenting.

Behind play???
Coward punch???

It was in a marking contest!

The only “behind play” incident on the day was a Black Rock player felling and Ashwood player.

Prove it, let's see the footage. lol!

 

[Tigersman]

South Yarra deemed unsafe for football this week and all games moved to HP

 

[Sratsky]

South Yarra deemed unsafe for football this week and all games moved to HP

is that fair dinkum?

 

[LSRU]

is that fair dinkum?

Online fixture is updated so yep fair dinkum.
Looks like the 3rds will be a four team battle Royale

 

[Apolo creed]

Hampton park allowed to rort points system now run to league and get sth yarras ground audited so they dont have to play their