Traded Shai Bolton, pick 14 & F3 (Rich) traded to Fremantle for picks 10, 11 & 18
- Thread starter fargothegreat
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Snuffaluphagus
Brownlow Medallist
- Sep 10, 2015
- 25,408
- 88,045
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Because I find it hilarious that so many Richmond fans seem to think it's "highly unlikely" to find someone as good as Bolton in a top 5 pick, I present my evaluation of the last 10 drafts. Green for players I think are definitively going to be or are better than Bolton. Orangey for debateable (and I tried to give like 10% either way) and red for definitively worse players than Bolton (even if due to injury).
By my count, I think 18 of 50 are currently clearly worse, 6 are better and currently, about 26 are relatively equal. The top end of the draft is a pretty safe space for very good to elite talent provided you dont have a global pandemic or career ruined by injury
By my count, I think 18 of 50 are currently clearly worse, 6 are better and currently, about 26 are relatively equal. The top end of the draft is a pretty safe space for very good to elite talent provided you dont have a global pandemic or career ruined by injury
Last edited:
Snuffaluphagus
Brownlow Medallist
- Sep 10, 2015
- 25,408
- 88,045
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Pass
Nice try Snuff but Shai is clearly at Franklin and Gary Ablett Jr levels. Untouchable with a top 5 pick
Tassie won't massively effect us, we get some time now before they come in, plus we literally built a dynasty team where some of those pre years were the introduction of 2 expansion teams. Teams effected more will be the ones bottoming out in 2-4 years, I think by that stage we should be starting to climb the ladder if this next period is done correctly. Plus these days with FA/RFA and trading of future picks that we didnt have acess to in the AFL before, rebuilding is accelerated, again the caveat being the club does that process well in that time.
Bolton's potentially not around for the next one I agree but speculating 7 years in advance is just throwing darts in this league. In 2010 I wouldn't have picked Richmond to win our first of the three in 7 years time....
Wasn't it just one Tigers poster that said that?
You're better than this Snuff.
tigs2010
Pick 1...
Just like GC and GWS set us back. Imagine how many we could have won without the massive setbacks.
They're premiership cups for those that haven't seen one before
WC aren't in the habit of talking about media speculation
.
TB did come out and pretty much say a few weeks ago he was an Eagle for life unless the club pushed him out.
WC don't really push contracted players out.
Having said that, he's now being linked to Hawthorn.
I'd like the club to come out and hose it down TBH.
Snuffaluphagus
Brownlow Medallist
- Sep 10, 2015
- 25,408
- 88,045
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Nah, the "disagrees" triggered me, and I was interested to see how what the top5 historical was anyway tbh. Actually better than I thought
I'm also not above being petty
thistimeforsure
Team Captain
- Mar 12, 2024
- 403
- 567
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Funny if you go back to when Freo fell off the cliff and we had Fyfe out of contract and a lot of speculation he might go to the Tigers
A lot of people were making excuses about injuries and so forth and expecting us to bounce back but I didn’t like the look of our list at all and thought we should cash in on Fyfes value because what’s the point of a great player in a shit team anyway , if your bad just be bad and restock kind of thing
Fyfe won a Brownlow after that but then his body started breaking down and the last five years or so he’s been up and down and pretty low value compared to his prime
Similar kind of situation for Richmond with Bolton and Rioli at the moment bar the contracted side of things
On iPad using BigFooty.com mobile app
A lot of people were making excuses about injuries and so forth and expecting us to bounce back but I didn’t like the look of our list at all and thought we should cash in on Fyfes value because what’s the point of a great player in a shit team anyway , if your bad just be bad and restock kind of thing
Fyfe won a Brownlow after that but then his body started breaking down and the last five years or so he’s been up and down and pretty low value compared to his prime
Similar kind of situation for Richmond with Bolton and Rioli at the moment bar the contracted side of things
On iPad using BigFooty.com mobile app
Remind us what Fremantle traded the 'clearly worse' Cerra for?
Also lol at some of those you have as 'relatively equal' to Bolton.
There are plenty of players on that list anyone would pick ahead of a 26 year old Bolton to lead a rebuild.
Bolton at 26 is a cherry on top gun player. Not a 18 yr old Sam Walsh who can lead a midfield for 10 years. You may argue about one or two but top 5 picks is where the cream is selected.
Lol indeed
Ok champ,how bout you give us your thoughts on some of those players you think are inferior?
Not really interested on Bolton tbh…we are getting our attacking together anyway. Could it be better? Yes…
I’m not coughing up the picks we have for anyone except Warner, and that looks like next year.
Would rather draft
I’m not coughing up the picks we have for anyone except Warner, and that looks like next year.
Would rather draft
Last edited:
Snuffaluphagus
Brownlow Medallist
- Sep 10, 2015
- 25,408
- 88,045
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
That's a reasonable call but Cerra was traded when younger and was like pick 6 and a 3rd rounder. I'm also not suggesting a top 5 pick would be enough purely by itself but just showing how remarkably safe those picks actually are these days. Remarkably few duds outside a Covid year.
I expect a lot of the names I said "were relatively" equal to raise eyebrows but I tried to give a decent amount of leeway either side. I think everyone either has been, is or will be a top 5 player at their club for decent amount of time (I'd probably change Parish now on second look though).
What?
Freo are trading for a gun cherry on top. To win now.
Richmond don't need a 26 year old Bolton to rebuild they need the next Sam Walsh to lead their midfield for 10 years.
Simple concept isn't it?
What a stupid post.
Really?
What is stupid about trading in a top 5 pick that gets a Sam Walsh quality inside mid to lead a rebuild?
Plus a 2nd or a player.
Are you saying if you were a list manager and had a decision to make on how to rebuild. Your option was a 26 yr old Bolton or a top 5 player the ilk of Sam Walsh or Pertracca plus a 2nd.
You would choose a lightly built 26 yr old half forward mid? Who will be over 30 when you next contend.
Seriously?
Klink
All Australian
Hope he stays. Tigers will be desperate to move on a hot and cold (gun at his best in a good side) player to fast track their rebuild given some significant list management errors.
Gun player in a good side, but as others have said, cherry on top and icing on the cake type of player. Tigers have no cake and won't for quite a while.
Harwick loaded up with Tarranto and Hopper and bailed when he realised he'd put Tigers behind for many years..
They can continue to gain high picks via their onfield performances. I hope the WA clubs leave him. Freo and WC should be putting all their eggs into the Warner basket..
Gun player in a good side, but as others have said, cherry on top and icing on the cake type of player. Tigers have no cake and won't for quite a while.
Harwick loaded up with Tarranto and Hopper and bailed when he realised he'd put Tigers behind for many years..
They can continue to gain high picks via their onfield performances. I hope the WA clubs leave him. Freo and WC should be putting all their eggs into the Warner basket..
Morro
Brownlow Medallist
LOL, the club has literally said the opposite and Shai doesnt want to leave.
Ctl
Premiership Player
- Oct 20, 2021
- 3,466
- 9,339
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Bolton is Richmonds best player and is contracted for multiple years, Richmond won't be entertaining any 'fair' offers. If Freo really do want Bolton because they have set themselves up to trade for WA guns this trade period but at the moment don't have anyone on the hook, the offer will have to be something that is too good to refuse for Richmond. It doesn't really matter how people view Bolton, what matters is what it will take for Richmond to trade Bolton which is more than anyone will be willing to give up
Freo would be crazy not to try get Bolton. He'd take the piss in that side. I can't believe so many freo fans are hesitant, it's like they dont want to win their first flag.
