So... what is the situation with Buddy? ***Warning*** Hollow Earth Proponents within

[dipper86]

Didn't Clarko say in the presser that it was the medicos that said he wasn't fit?

LOL, incompetence......is that hard for all of them to get there story right, it makes it all more believable then, Pfft, amateurs.

 

[The Big Woofer]

The fact that his Coleman Medal price has gone out to $8 with sportsbet ($4.50 tab) doesn't bode well for him playing this week as these guys tend to know more than the general public about this type of thing given the money involved.

 

[savagelunchbox]

The fact that his Coleman Medal price has gone out to $8 with sportsbet ($4.50 tab) doesn't bode well for him playing this week as these guys tend to know more than the general public about this type of thing given the money involved.

Or it could be that he is sitting 4th and has to go +6 over the final 3 games and has to come up against the likes of Richards and Glass in 2 of those games.

 

[Dinner Plate]

My simplistic understanding (feel free to set me straight) is that those betting markets are determined by weight of money and the bookmaker's willingness to take on risk i.e. how much of the wager they hedge.

However, I'd combine all of the above points (he seems doubtful to play this week, and even if he returns for Syd/WC he'll struggle to overcome the other goal kickers tallies.) My money's on Buddy not winning the Coleman. But I've been a naysayer about the handling of his injury since he left the field during the GWS game.

More importantly, where's the thread on Roughie's injury?

 

[NICE1]

Or it could be that he is sitting 4th and has to go +6 over the final 3 games and has to come up against the likes of Richards and Glass in 2 of those games.

lol yeah id say thats more the case...too much speculation ocuuring at the moment.

 

[Collins-Langford-Ayres]

I think he'll play this week.

 

[HAWKS HEROES]

Didn't Clarko say in the presser that it was the medicos that said he wasn't fit?

thats what i heard him say

 

[Gary Conan Ayres]

Buddy has just been arrested by the fashion police for wearing Brown and gold stripped speedos.

 

[Cyrilyouchampion]

Buddy has just been arrested by the fashion police for wearing Brown and gold stripped speedos.

just for wearing his buddie smugglers?

 

[Off The Couch]

Buddy has just been arrested by the fashion police for wearing Brown and gold stripped speedos.

And so he should of been

 

[KAMSTAR HFC]

Didn't Clarko say in the presser that it was the medicos that said he wasn't fit?

I would say that the medical staff copped a fair reeming after they passed him fit for GWS

 

[spudmaster]

Buddy has just been arrested by the fashion police for wearing Brown and gold stripped speedos.

Be thankful little Tony is donning them!

 

[Off The Couch]

And it's 1...2...3 strikes your out...at the old ball game..

This isn't a thread about a brownlow medalist

 

[gibba23]

This isn't a thread about a brownlow medalist

so witty

 

[cryptor]

Didn't Clarko say in the presser that it was the medicos that said he wasn't fit?

The way I took it from Clarko's and Lewis' press conferences was that Buddy told the Docs that he still wasn't 100% and that they've gone and passed that on to Clarko as logically it would be the club doctors job to pass on the medical reports to the coach and not up to the players to go pass the diagnosis on themselves.

 

[Linda Crescent]

Buddy has just been arrested by the fashion police for wearing Brown and gold stripped speedos.

Hooped not striped or "stripped".

 

[saaam]

Of particular concern our medicos passed him fit to play twice when he clearly wasn't. My biggest worry is that in the last 6 weeks he's had just a half of footy so will be rusty and out of match conditioning. This maybe a good thing though as we may not see him on the HBF or Wing.

 

[IdiotBox]

Question: is the Coleman based solely on the H&A games? (ie finals not included)

 

[Mighty P]

Question: is the Coleman based solely on the H&A games? (ie finals not included)

Finals not included, just H&A.

 

[crankybeep]

The way I took it from Clarko's and Lewis' press conferences was that Buddy told the Docs that he still wasn't 100% and that they've gone and passed that on to Clarko as logically it would be the club doctors job to pass on the medical reports to the coach and not up to the players to go pass the diagnosis on themselves.

Thanks, I was curious about that.

 

[Gilbert_Hodge]

Seems Aker has Tweeted a storm........

 

[Off The Couch]

Seems Aker has Tweeted a storm........

What sort of storm

 

[Stratton_Gun]

Seems Aker has Tweeted a storm........

Heard that rumour a couple of weeks ago but there is no way Hawthorn would say he is 1 week away etc etc if they knew he was on 3. Plus Buddy would know and his twitter pretty much says he'll be back this week if not soon

 

[Gilbert_Hodge]

What sort of storm

3 strikes. If it isn't true than Aker will cop it I would imagine.

 

[Stratton_Gun]

3 strikes. If it isn't true than Aker will cop it I would imagine.

He didn't cop it with the Dogs so why would he?