team for round 1.

[Spikey]

Is ackinson on rookie list absolute gun IMO good size backs himself in reminds me of Harry O'Brian. Not to impressed with Welsh doesnt do enough for a so called leader, big courtney johns did nothing last night apart from his last quarter goal needs to drasically improve his 2nd and 3rd efforts. I like dempsey and nash running off half back.

Yeah,Atkinson is on the rookie list.

Thought Welsh went pretty well (But Don35 won't say that)

Neagle's game means Johns has slipped futher back in the ranks IMO

 

[GoDons]

B: Fletcher Michael Ramanauskas
HB: Nash Ryder Lovett-Murray
C: Lovett Watson Dyson
HF: McPhee Lucas Welsh
F: Davey Lloyd Jetta
Foll: Hille Stanton McVeigh
Inter(from): Laycock Houli Monfries Dempsey Hocking Slattery Peverill

 

[bomberstomake8]

imo we need to have either gumbelton/neagle playing every game possible..

if we are going to focus on developing our kids these are two kids who must be played.. if gumby is out for round 1 i would strongly consider having neagle in there. i realise with lloyd lucas mcphee hille/laycock it can get too tall on occasions but we need to make it work otherwise barring injuries gumby/neagle will get very limited game time this year which is not whats best for our long term future

 

[bloods01]

Welsh and Lovett-Murray in particular are certs for round 1.

Dempsey has alot of work to do and isnt in my round 1 side to be honest.[/quote]

Spot on. He coughts it up way to much and his decision making is a little suspect also. Yes he's quick and takes them on, but that doesn't necessarily ensure him a Round 1 start IMO.

Welsh on the other hand has played some great footy accross half back. Not sure why he's in the forward line now?

 

[TheDon35]

Monfries out, Welsh in. He has shown nothing in the Bank-sponsored Cup to suggest he should be named as a first choice on-baller.

Would dissagree that Monfries should be out of the side. Particularly if you want to replace him with Welsh.

McPhee, Lucas, Lloyd and one of Hille and Laycock are all in the forward line. Throw in a couple of smaller forwards and there is no room for him.

Up to Bendigo Welshy!

 

[Windas_Magic]

B: Fletcher Michael Lovett-Murray
HB: Nash Ryder Dempsey
C: Lovett Watson Monfries
HF: McPhee Lucas Davey
FF: jetta Lloyd Welsh

FOLL: Hille Stanton McVeigh

INT: Laycock, Hocking, Rama, Houli

EMG: Dyson, Slattery, Neagle​

 

[SM10]

B: Slattery - Michael - Fletcher
HB: Nash - Ryder - Dempsey
C: NLM - Stanton - Houli
HF: McVeigh - Lucas - McPhee
F: Laycock - Lloyd - Jetta
R: Hille - Watson - Davey
I/C: Welsh - Monfries - Dyson - Lovett

 

[Hislop200]

FB Rama Michael fletcher

HB Nash Ryder Lovettmurray

C Lovett Watson Stanton

HF Mcfee Lucas Davey

FF Laycock Lloyd Jetta

FOL Hille McVeigh Monfries

INT Houli Dempsey Dyson Pev

Emerg Welsh Reimers Hocking

 

[acebomer]

B: Fletcher Michael Lovett-Murray

HB: Nash Ryder Dempsey
C: Lovett Watson Monfries
HF: McPhee Lucas Davey
FF: jetta Lloyd Welsh​

FOLL: Hille Stanton McVeigh​

INT: Laycock, Hocking, Rama, Houli​

EMG: Dyson, Slattery, Neagle​

this line up looks right to me maybe slatts should be in the 22

 

[Colin D'Cops]

B : Rama - Michael - Ryder
HB : Nash - Fletcher - Dempsey
C : Winderlich - Stanton - McPhee
HF : Davey - Lucas - Lovett
F : Welsh - Lloyd - Laycock
FOLL : Hille - McVeigh - Watson
I/C : Jetta - Nathan LM - Monfries - Houli / Dyson

 

[bomberstomake8]

this line up looks right to me maybe slatts should be in the 22

i personally think dyson should be ahead of lovett to start in our 22, he has earnt it this pre season and i think we have to remember that lovett is hardly a proven midfeilder.. its either lovett who is unproven and hasnt played a game the whole pre season or dyson who is unproven who has been very good in pre season matches before.. i vote dyson

 

[monty1104]

I'd hope Rama would be in our best 22 after his performance last night. He was great IMO. Neagle to get some game time hopefully, but wont be too disappointed if he misses out. There are others that deserve a game ahead of him, but its just that with Gumby injured, he is our 3rd tall, so he might get a game.

 

[p3zd1sp3nx0r]

B : Rama - Michael - Ryder
HB : Nash - Fletcher - Dempsey
C : Winderlich - Stanton - McPhee
HF : Davey - Lucas - Lovett
F : Jetta - Lloyd - Laycock
FOLL : Hille - McVeigh - Watson
I/C : Peverill - Nathan LM - Reimers - Houli

 

[Margim]

Cannot believe how little so many people rate Welsh. One of our more consistent, reliable players over many years.

 

[Tyler16]

I think we really need winderlich in there, he was good last year. Cant have jj, pev, and watson in the same game. Monfries is hard done by, i think he will be ok.

 

[DaSawx]

Winderlich is struggling to make round 1 but would be in the best 22 easily

 

[jules101]

B: Pev Michael Nash
HB: Rama Fletcher Dempsey
C: Dyson Stanton Lovett
HF: NLM Lucas Davey
F: Monfries Lloyd Welsh
R: Hille McVeigh Watson
I: Laycock, McPhee, Houli, Ryder
E: Slattery, JJ, Hocking

Reimers, Jetta in the mix too. Winder for Dyson if he was fit.. Might come back thru the reserves tho...

 

[cAsEy_18]

B. Dempsey, michael,ryder
H.B. Hocking, Fletcher,nash
C. dyson,stanton Houli
HF. davey,lucas,mcphee
F. Lovett, lloyd,reimers
FOLL. hille,mcveigh,monfries
INTER. Watson, Slattery, Jetta,Welsh


With the way we are hopefully going to attempt to play this year, you cant have Michael, Fletcher, Ryder, Hille, Laycock, Lloyd, Lucas and Neagle in the same team. Gotta drop at least 2-3 of them, if we're going to be a running side. Can't play 10-12 runners and keep them on the ground the entire game and expect people like Davey to be sprinting still come to the final quarter.

 

[efcboy]

B : Slattery - Michael - Ryder
HB : Nash - Fletcher - Rama
C : Monfries - Watson - Dempsey
HF : McPhee - Lucas - Lovett
F : Davey - Lloyd - Welsh
FOLL : Hille - McVeigh - Stanton
I/C : Laycock - Nathan LM - Dyson - Houli
Emerg: Peverill - Hocking - Jetta
(winderlich out injured)

 

[fishguts]

Ryder--michael--ramanauskas

Nash---fletcher---lovett-murray

Houli--watson--mcphee

Jetta--lucas--monfries

Davey--lloyd--jetta

R:hille--stanton--peveril

I/c Laycock--dempsey--dyson--welsh

 

[Schmick]

B: Rama Michael Fletcher
HB: Dempsey Ryder Nash
C: Dyson Mcveigh Stanton
HF: Davey Lucas Mcphee
F: Jetta Lloyd Hille
FOLL: Laycock Monfries Houli
INTER: Watson Welsh Hocking Lovett

 

[GuzzLG]

The way I see it:

B:.....Slattery........Michael..........Lovett-Murray
HB:...Ryder.........''.Fletcher.........Nash
C:.....(*)..............Stanton.........(*)
HF:...Welsh...........Lucas............McPhee
F:.....Davey........'..Lloyd............Jetta
R:.....Hille..........'...McVeigh........(*)
I:....,'Laycock.....(*).......(*).......(*)

*6 positions to be comprised from the following:
Dyson, Watson, Monfries, Rama, Peverill, Lovett, Johnson, Dempsey, Reimers, Hocking, Houli.

Those selected will be on the basis of forming a midfield rotation that will work well together, rather than just selecting the 'best' 22.

 

[angus6]

Rama - Michael - Ryder
Nash - Fletcher - Dempsey
Dyson - Watson - Houli
McPhee - Lucas - Davey
L-Murry - Lloyd - McVeigh
Hille - Stanton - Monfries
Welsh - Laycock - Peverill - Reimors

 

[monty1104]

FB: Nash, Michael, Fletcher
HB: Dempsey, Ryder, Rama
C: Dyson, Watson, McPhee
HF: Welsh, Lucas, NLM
FF: Lovett, Lloyd, Davey
Rucks: Hille, McVeigh, Stanton
Interchange: Laycock, Houli, Jetta, Neagle
E: Monfries, Reimers, Peverill.

This is what I would like to see, not necessarily what will happen.

FWIW, I think Monfries and Peverill will play ahead of Jetta and Neagle, but i dont think they deserve it, especially Monfries. For someone who was meant to have a "breakout" year last season, he has delivered very little.

 

[d-mac3276]

B NLM Michael Ryder
HB Nash Fletcher Dempsey
C Dyson Watson Stanton
HF Jetta Lucas McPhee
F Davey Lloyd Neagle
R Hille McVeigh Monfries
I Houli Laycock Reimers Welsh

E Peverill Slattery Hocking