List Mgmt. The 2024 Draft (Nov 20/21)

Keys · Saturday at 5:41 AM

Quick links

Player contract status
Draft prospect video highlights (thanks to noobermensch)
Provisional 2025 Draft order

Key Dates

• Oct 17 to Nov 8: Pick swap window
• Nov 1 to Nov 8: Delisted free agency period
• Nov 20-21: Telstra AFL Draft
• Nov 22: Telstra Pre-Season Draft and Rookie Draft

List Spots Available

• 5 Main list
• 1 Rookie list

Current Draft Picks

• Main Draft - 12,26,73,81,99
• Rookie Draft - 3

stallon · 2024-10-30T02:42:35+1100

Would anybody else rate Bo Allan as a more similar player to Yeo than Ginbey?

Ginbey lacks the agility that Yeo and Allan have/had, and Bo's traits seem to line up with Yeo quite nicely. Both Yeo and Allan are both far more aggressive and penetrating kicks than Ginbey too.

Seeing that Bo actually placed 4th in the combine in agility surprised me a bit, im coming around to him a lot lately.

stallon · 2024-10-30T02:47:32+1100

maverick001 said:
Thought I'd have a stab at a phantom

Assumes NM trade pick 2 to Tigers for 6 and 18-ish.

Reckon there's a decent chance of one of TT or Smillie getting to our pick.

Guiding principles:

Have gone with the Adam Jones belief that Allan doesn't get past 10 with Melb & Stk most keen

I think Stk go a genuine mid & a tall fwd with their 2 picks. Think someone else to partner with King is a bigger need for them than a HBF like TT

There's quite a few possibilities for Rich's 10 & 11. No doubt it could go many ways. But if they go genuine mids with 1&2, then you'd expect they're looking at wings, flanks & talls at 10/11. Having that many early picks you'd think there's a chance they take the risk on Hotton. And I think they'd want at least one tall in their first 4 picks. But Shanahan might be a reach for here, & who knows whether Trainor will slide further given concussion issues.

Rich - Lalor

Rich - FOS

Carl - Smith

Adel - draper

Melb - Langford

NM - Tauru

Stk - Reid

Stk - Armstrong

Melb - Allan

Rich - TT/Hotton/Berry/Trainor/Shanahan/Smillie

Rich - TT/Hotton/Berry/Trainor/Shanahan/Smillie

WCE - decent chance one of TT or Smillie lasts

Yeah this is where ive landed too, really depends what Richmond want. Id like to think that if they take 2 mids with 1+ 2/6 then theyre going to take at least 1 tall at 10/11, with the other player really being a toss up. Maybe they dont want 3 mids in the top 10 of the same draft, but I hope they take a punt on Hotton.

Keys · 2024-10-30T03:24:13+1100

maverick001 said:
Thought I'd have a stab at a phantom

Assumes NM trade pick 2 to Tigers for 6 and 18-ish.

Reckon there's a decent chance of one of TT or Smillie getting to our pick.

Guiding principles:

Have gone with the Adam Jones belief that Allan doesn't get past 10 with Melb & Stk most keen

I think Stk go a genuine mid & a tall fwd with their 2 picks. Think someone else to partner with King is a bigger need for them than a HBF like TT

There's quite a few possibilities for Rich's 10 & 11. No doubt it could go many ways. But if they go genuine mids with 1&2, then you'd expect they're looking at wings, flanks & talls at 10/11. Having that many early picks you'd think there's a chance they take the risk on Hotton. And I think they'd want at least one tall in their first 4 picks. But Shanahan might be a reach for here, & who knows whether Trainor will slide further given concussion issues.

Rich - Lalor

Rich - FOS

Carl - Smith

Adel - draper

Melb - Langford

NM - Tauru

Stk - Reid

Stk - Armstrong

Melb - Allan

Rich - TT/Hotton/Berry/Trainor/Shanahan/Smillie

Rich - TT/Hotton/Berry/Trainor/Shanahan/Smillie

WCE - decent chance one of TT or Smillie lasts

I think this is plausible

Ultimately, what we want is for one or more of Trainor, Hotton or Shanahan to to go before our pick.

For each one that does, one of Smillie, Travaglia or Allan becomes available at our selection. The first 8 names you’ve listed won’t last to our pick so it becomes a waiting game to see which of those three get through

If they’re all gone then Lindsay sounds like our best option

aussierulesrules · 2024-10-30T03:38:35+1100

maverick001 said:
Thought I'd have a stab at a phantom

Assumes NM trade pick 2 to Tigers for 6 and 18-ish.

Reckon there's a decent chance of one of TT or Smillie getting to our pick.

Guiding principles:

Have gone with the Adam Jones belief that Allan doesn't get past 10 with Melb & Stk most keen

I think Stk go a genuine mid & a tall fwd with their 2 picks. Think someone else to partner with King is a bigger need for them than a HBF like TT

There's quite a few possibilities for Rich's 10 & 11. No doubt it could go many ways. But if they go genuine mids with 1&2, then you'd expect they're looking at wings, flanks & talls at 10/11. Having that many early picks you'd think there's a chance they take the risk on Hotton. And I think they'd want at least one tall in their first 4 picks. But Shanahan might be a reach for here, & who knows whether Trainor will slide further given concussion issues.

Rich - Lalor

Rich - FOS

Carl - Smith

Adel - draper

Melb - Langford

NM - Tauru

Stk - Reid

Stk - Armstrong

Melb - Allan

Rich - TT/Hotton/Berry/Trainor/Shanahan/Smillie

Rich - TT/Hotton/Berry/Trainor/Shanahan/Smillie

WCE - decent chance one of TT or Smillie lasts

FWIW, I think it was reported in The Age that Richmond are very reluctant to part with pick 6, and apparently they really like Smillie there, so if anyone is going to trade up to 2 it’s probably going to be St Kilda.

Talk on our board that it would be for our future first and one of 7 or 8.

eaglevision · 2024-10-30T08:52:23+1100

Top draft prospects ranked 1-50: AFL stars they all play like and the clubs keen on them

Draft prospects ranked 1-50: AFL stars they play like — and what clubs could pick them

www.foxsports.com.au

Happy Mastenator · 2024-10-30T08:55:04+1100

PremiershipNo4 said:
So you’re saying Ross Lyons Saints will bid on our player again?

Pick 28 isn't the middle of the third round

Obeanie1 · 2024-10-30T09:00:07+1100

BartBart said:
Yep - try snd get a 1-1 matchup that you like the looks of and the person kicking out keeps an eye on it. Play on from square & boot the ball to your team-mate's advantage.

Maybe have a sneaky second player ready to go defensive side in case things go wrong.

Just show a bit of inventiveness.

And stop being so predictable.

Wooshaaaa · 2024-10-30T09:22:39+1100

eaglevision said:
Top draft prospects ranked 1-50: AFL stars they all play like and the clubs keen on them

Draft prospects ranked 1-50: AFL stars they play like — and what clubs could pick them

www.foxsports.com.au

We have to get another pick or 2 in the 25-35 range.

The bombers 28 31 trade in/out scenario has to pushed.

Having 12 28 31 champion and a late slider with our pick in the 80s (comes in to the early 60s) - this is where we take a punt on Urquhart if he slides.

On Pixel 6 Pro using BigFooty.com mobile app

eaglevision · 2024-10-30T09:31:56+1100

Wooshaaaa said:
We have to get another pick or 2 in the 25-35 range.

The bombers 28 31 trade in/out scenario has to pushed.

Having 12 28 31 champion and a late slider with our pick in the 80s (comes in to the early 60s) - this is where we take a punt on Urquhart if he slides.

On Pixel 6 Pro using BigFooty.com mobile app

The Bombers trade is a no brainer if they agree to it. Had a bit of a look with the draft points calculator as a rough guide assuming same ladder positions:

OUT: 26, F2 (WCE), F2 (HAW), F3 (HAW)
IN: 28, 31, 46, F2 (ESS)

28 and 31 take best KPD and best mid left on the board.

EagleEgo · 2024-10-30T09:49:10+1100

random260 said:
You do realise those weakness at that arange is just a scratch right?

The weaknesses from pick 12 and above is gigantic. Its potentially bust territory.

We are considering a dude that tore his acl as the pick of the crop (Taj hotten)

We wre considering a dude that tore his something as a pick of the crop (Lindsay)

We are considering a player who averages at best 15-20 possessions at junior level (Bo Allen)

That's ****ing horrific

You don't even know Bo Allan's name but pretend to be a footy expert!?

eaglevision · 2024-10-30T10:09:17+1100


Player	Consensus rank	Cavanagh	Batten
Levi Ashcroft	1	1	1
Finn O'Sullivan	2	2	4
Jagga Smith	3	4	2
Sam Lalor	4	3	6
Sid Draper	5	6	3
Harvey Langford	6	5	5
Josh Smillie	7	7	8
Murphy Reid	8	9	7
Harry Armstrong	9	8	12
Tobie Travaglia	10	10	11
Alix Tauru	11	11	10
Leo Lombard	12	12	9
Isaac Kako	13	13	13
Bo Allan	14	14	15
Taj Hotton	15	16	14
Luke Trainor	16	15	17
Jobe Shanahan	17	17	16
Xavier Lindsay	18	18	18
Joe Berry	19	19	20
Sam Marshall	20	20	21
Jack Whitlock	21	22	19
Cooper Hynes	22	23	22
Alex Dodson	23	21	26
Matt Whitlock	24	24	24
Jesse Dattoli	25	25	25
Jonty Faull	26	27	23
Tom Gross	27	28	29
Ollie Hannaford	28	26	-
Christian Moraes	29	30	27
Harrison Oliver	30	29

boondy · 2024-10-30T10:18:35+1100

Lindsay very proficient handball with his right hand . So legit can feign left and right .

Obeanie1 · 2024-10-30T10:18:45+1100

eaglevision said:
Player Consensus rank Cavanagh Batten
Levi Ashcroft 1 1 1
Finn O'Sullivan 2 2 4
Jagga Smith 3 4 2
Sam Lalor 4 3 6
Sid Draper 5 6 3
Harvey Langford 6 5 5
Josh Smillie 7 7 8
Murphy Reid 8 9 7
Harry Armstrong 9 8 12
Tobie Travaglia 10 10 11
Alix Tauru 11 11 10
Leo Lombard 12 12 9
Isaac Kako 13 13 13
Bo Allan 14 14 15
Taj Hotton 15 16 14
Luke Trainor 16 15 17
Jobe Shanahan 17 17 16
Xavier Lindsay 18 18 18
Joe Berry 19 19 20
Sam Marshall 20 20 21
Jack Whitlock 21 22 19
Cooper Hynes 22 23 22
Alex Dodson 23 21 26
Matt Whitlock 24 24 24
Jesse Dattoli 25 25 25
Jonty Faull 26 27 23
Tom Gross 27 28 29
Ollie Hannaford 28 26 -
Christian Moraes 29 30 27
Harrison Oliver 30 29

Moreas and Oliver at our current 2nd is promising. Would love either one.

Bleedblueandgold · 2024-10-30T10:54:48+1100

Elite Pete said:
Could’ve been door 2 open of our Draft Advent calendar to Sid was an Eagle day…. Fml

Sacrificed him for a 27 year old.

Still not a bad dream...

Doashuey · 2024-10-30T11:05:11+1100

EagleEgo said:
You don't even know Bo Allan's name but pretend to be a footy expert!?

Unhinged melting has more gravitas when correct spelling and details are not used.

EagleEgo · 2024-10-30T11:07:21+1100

Doashuey said:
Unhinged melting has more gravitas when correct spelling and details are not used.

Respect is the reason.

Doashuey · 2024-10-30T11:10:19+1100

eaglevision said:
His best trait is arguably his ball use, credit to a raking left-foot kick when is often used to penetrate the attacking 50.

If anyone wants to do a Masters in human anatomy, please undertake a study on the reason mollydookers are born with a garden implement on the end of one leg.
Every single left footer with a half decent kick is referred to as having a raking left foot kick, but I don't recall ever hearing or reading of a right footer ever being described as a raking r.f. kick.

Mid-morning hump day musings.

ToastieBoy18 · 2024-10-30T11:21:26+1100

Cal Twomey has us linked with Allen, Travaligia, Lindsay as most on here have predicted, but also Matt Whitlock and Jobe Shanahan with pick 12.

Would be pretty happy with any of the first 3, TT, Lindsay, Allen in that order. Would be confused if we went tall with first pick.

WBBL Season 10 - Oct '24 to Dec '25

List Mgmt. The 2024 Draft (Nov 20/21)

Looking for a cloud to yell at

Premiership Player

Premiership Player

Looking for a cloud to yell at

Hall of Famer

Premium Platinum

Chris Masten's Sock Puppet

Hall of Famer

Club Legend

Premium Platinum

Club Legend

Premium Platinum

I pity the fool

Hall of Famer

Brownlow Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

Club Legend

Norm Smith Medallist

Senior List

List Mgmt. The 2024 Draft (Nov 20/21)

Similar threads

Log In or Create New Account