- Banned
- #201
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
The official Judd Trade With Carlton thread
- Thread starter WaDsY
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Message for all Coasters Fans
You must go to richmond and secure a wild card or carlton will load Judds contract up and walk him into the PSD. Juddy is now a blue and has been bought with Pratts money. Pratt is a billionair, self made genius, who in the end knows business and will get Judd PSD, Pratt will advise and make this happen, it will enable the blues to be a power house in 2 years. You cannot keep a giant like the blue baggers down for long, especially now Uncle Pratt and Swann are involved.
They will offer you 3,20 and kennedy. 3 is a nothing pick because they cheated and tanked for pick 1, 20 is a gamble and kennedy has not been developed right and is a walking DUD.
You must go to richmond and secure a wild card or carlton will load Judds contract up and walk him into the PSD. Juddy is now a blue and has been bought with Pratts money. Pratt is a billionair, self made genius, who in the end knows business and will get Judd PSD, Pratt will advise and make this happen, it will enable the blues to be a power house in 2 years. You cannot keep a giant like the blue baggers down for long, especially now Uncle Pratt and Swann are involved.
They will offer you 3,20 and kennedy. 3 is a nothing pick because they cheated and tanked for pick 1, 20 is a gamble and kennedy has not been developed right and is a walking DUD.
Re: Message for all Coasters Fans
I think you will find Carlton will make it a win - win for both clubs. I doubt they would try and burn West Coast as from all reports they have a good relationship going. It helps to try and keep good relationships as what goes around, come around.
Josh Kennedy will be a very diificult player to hold down in the future. Big lad who can play and can take a hard hit.
I think you will find Carlton will make it a win - win for both clubs. I doubt they would try and burn West Coast as from all reports they have a good relationship going. It helps to try and keep good relationships as what goes around, come around.
Josh Kennedy will be a very diificult player to hold down in the future. Big lad who can play and can take a hard hit.
Re: Message for all Coasters Fans
What a w**ker.....the main reason why the WCE won't deal with the Filth is for the very thinking you mentioned above. Both teams will walk away with a compromised deal that is adequate for both......KNOB
Stevens now Judd - this must be hurting.....just like all those failures at the last hurdle......
What a w**ker.....the main reason why the WCE won't deal with the Filth is for the very thinking you mentioned above. Both teams will walk away with a compromised deal that is adequate for both......KNOB
Stevens now Judd - this must be hurting.....just like all those failures at the last hurdle......
- Mar 20, 2007
- 29,811
- 27,914
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Re: Likelihood of us getting pick 1 for Judas?
the carlton board on bigfooty has no impact on the trade whatsoever
the carlton board on bigfooty has no impact on the trade whatsoever
- Sep 21, 2004
- 39,623
- 29,719
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Norwood & Liverpool.
Re: Carlton being forced to cave in?
If you get pick 1, you get pick 1. I'd certainly like to keep it but I'm mindful of the player we're getting too. Might cost us Kreuzer but I'm sure they'll be a gun with pick 3 if it comes to that for us. Important that 1) we get him, 2) the Eagles get some sort of decent compenstation.Nothing is untouchable...
Look forward to grabbing #1 from you lot
Re: Likelihood of us getting pick 1 for Judas?
Luckily for Judd, I am sure he is not as keen on becoming a Tiger.
Luckily for Judd, I am sure he is not as keen on becoming a Tiger.
Re: Likelihood of us getting pick 1 for Judas?
But why not pick 3 instead of 1?
Are you actually gonna use it on Kreuzer, or are you after a West Australian?
But why not pick 3 instead of 1?
Are you actually gonna use it on Kreuzer, or are you after a West Australian?
Re: Likelihood of us getting pick 1 for Judas?
I'm tending to agree with that... Though I'd love it it was 1, 3 and kennedy.
- Banned
- #216
Re: Likelihood of us getting pick 1 for Judas?
Who knows. If we are wanting to take a West Aussie then pick 3 is effectively pick 1. Pick 3 and Fev would be my choice numero uno.
Who knows. If we are wanting to take a West Aussie then pick 3 is effectively pick 1. Pick 3 and Fev would be my choice numero uno.
- Banned
- #217
Re: Likelihood of us getting pick 1 for Judas?
We want Trent Cotchin. He wont be available at Pick 3. We also dont want Josh Kennedy.
We want Trent Cotchin. He wont be available at Pick 3. We also dont want Josh Kennedy.
Re: Message for all Coasters Fans
I really hope a fair trade is arranged ASAP.
I dont want to have to be at war with west coast fans on this site for the entirity of next season and beyond
I really hope a fair trade is arranged ASAP.
I dont want to have to be at war with west coast fans on this site for the entirity of next season and beyond
Re: Likelihood of us getting pick 1 for Judas?
Not necessarily. Richmond might want to intice Mitch Morton to come over by picking his brother Cale with their second pick. Which then leaves Cotchin to be availabe with the third pick.
Not necessarily. Richmond might want to intice Mitch Morton to come over by picking his brother Cale with their second pick. Which then leaves Cotchin to be availabe with the third pick.
What loyalty? He is walking out on the club - his loyalty's pretty negligible already. If he had any loyalty he'd have nominated nine clubs and left it to the Eagles to find a deal.
Team Eagle
Rookie
Re: Likelihood of us getting pick 1 for Judas?
Do we really want to look at a ruckman, I think we have that area covered. I reckon 3, 20 and a quality KPP would be the go, the best thing is that he has not gone to Collingwood thus limiting his impact against us and the rest of the comp. That is one thing we need to think about, which side is he going to cause the least amount of damage in. I would say Carlton, rather than Collingwood......for now
Do we really want to look at a ruckman, I think we have that area covered. I reckon 3, 20 and a quality KPP would be the go, the best thing is that he has not gone to Collingwood thus limiting his impact against us and the rest of the comp. That is one thing we need to think about, which side is he going to cause the least amount of damage in. I would say Carlton, rather than Collingwood......for now
Re: Message for all Coasters Fans
If I were a Collingwood supporter I'd be a lot happier that they stuck with Didak.
If I were a Collingwood supporter I'd be a lot happier that they stuck with Didak.
Team Eagle
Rookie
Re: Message for all Coasters Fans
Surely Woosha having been over at Caarrllttoonn has established some sort of repore between the clubs. Lets Face it, we will never replace a player like Chris Judd, all we want as a side is to get adequate compensation for him as you would with any other business transaction.
Surely Woosha having been over at Caarrllttoonn has established some sort of repore between the clubs. Lets Face it, we will never replace a player like Chris Judd, all we want as a side is to get adequate compensation for him as you would with any other business transaction.
- Banned
- #225
Re: Message for all Coasters Fans
Eagles fans don't worry a lot of Carlton fans are hoping that it will be a fair trade to you guys. And I think it will, I don't think we could every be able to match the true value of Judd for you guys but we definitely wont be ripping anyone off unlike the flith
Eagles fans don't worry a lot of Carlton fans are hoping that it will be a fair trade to you guys. And I think it will, I don't think we could every be able to match the true value of Judd for you guys but we definitely wont be ripping anyone off unlike the flith
