The official "X v Y" thread

[sava]

I'd got with the first option .. always a strong believer of points on the board beats money in the bank and taking adcock is a bigger risk than a gilbee or fisher .. adcock will sometimes get defensive roles under voss if playing in the midfield as black and power arent taggers ..

Can someone answer my questions above ^^^^

 

[mondaymorningblues]

cox and leuenberger or hille and kreuzer??

 

[Johanpetro]

cox and leuenberger or hille and kreuzer??

Cant go wrong with Cox, and Leuenberger should increase his value throughout the year.

Which two of the three:

Jesse.W.Smith, R.Houlihan, A.Raines.

 

[Sunday Red]

Cant go wrong with Cox, and Leuenberger should increase his value throughout the year.

Which two of the three:

Jesse.W.Smith, R.Houlihan, A.Raines.

Raines

Chapman vs Deledio

 

[UpTheGuts]

Raines

Chapman vs Deledio

Both are set for v good years. Lids is pretty resolient and has barely missed a game. Chapman is more likely to go well early.

Absolutely line ball. I have both and would hate to split them

 

[Sunday Red]

Both are set for v good years. Lids is pretty resolient and has barely missed a game. Chapman is more likely to go well early.

Absolutely line ball. I have both and would hate to split them

Ok then... let's add another one to the mix!

Chapman v Deledio v Franklin

 

[eugene_tomas]

id go chappy
1st pre season in years is a good sign

hille and buddy or
hille and boomer or
petrie and buddy

is the much difference in hille or petrie??

 

[Hot Tiges]

id go chappy
1st pre season in years is a good sign

hille and buddy or
hille and boomer or
petrie and buddy

is the much difference in hille or petrie??

Hille/Boomer is the safest bet VS Buddy/Petrie is risky but would be different
Another one..
Tuck/McIntosh VS Swallow/Sandilands (Already have Cox) Too much money in the ruck perhaps?

 

[eugene_tomas]

swallow sandi for sure

 

[trix17]

I'd go with Selwood and Gibbs .. both arent the number 1 midfielders at their club with blokes like Ablett and Judd to get the heavy tag they will be free to rome the midfield and gather possesions at will ... while pendlebury will become collingwoods number 1 midfielder this year and hasnt had to deal with a tag because swan has always got the tag .. pendlebury got tagged in the nab cup by hocking from essendon and ling from geelong and posted some pretty underwhelming scores ..


Brent Harvey and Hasleby or Fevola and any midfielder under 530,000 ?

please note the midfield already contains Ablett Judd Ball Selwood
the forward line already contains Franklin Deledio Chapman

id go with boomer and haselby, your midfield is already strong enough

 

[C-Dog]

Currie vs Jacobs?

 

[EFL Boy]

currie.

two options here....

Goddard, S.Fisher, Gilbee, C.Cornes, Malceski, Raines and Hill

or

Goddard, Gilbee, P.Burgoyne, C.Cornes, Adcock, Raines and Hill

 

[UpTheGuts]

currie.

two options here....

Goddard, S.Fisher, Gilbee, C.Cornes, Malceski, Raines and Hill

or

Goddard, Gilbee, P.Burgoyne, C.Cornes, Adcock, Raines and Hill

toss a coin

 

[C-Dog]

what do people think about going hill suban and broughton down back?

 

[Johanpetro]

currie.

two options here....

Goddard, S.Fisher, Gilbee, C.Cornes, Malceski, Raines and Hill

or

Goddard, Gilbee, P.Burgoyne, C.Cornes, Adcock, Raines and Hill

I like option 2 better.

H.McIntosh and Jesse.W.Smith with 106 grand in the bank

VS

D.Hille and A.Raines with 2 grand

 

[Will.B.Worth.Da.Waite]

I like option 2 better.

H.McIntosh and Jesse.W.Smith with 106 grand in the bank

VS

D.Hille and A.Raines with 2 grand

Newman vs Gilbee vs Enright?

 

[EFL Boy]

thats exactly what im going through right now...

except mine is

Newman vs Gilbee vs enright vs fisher?

already have gilbee but i have the money to upgrade him to one of the other 3, but i'm not sure.

 

[Windas_Magic]

Newman vs Gilbee vs Enright?

I'd go with Gilbee, but if you feel he is too much of a risk then Newman would be my second option.

Houlihan + Judd + Ottens

OR

Gilbee + Cross + Leunberger

*Hille is my number one ruckman.

 

[reddahaydn1]

gilbee cross and leuenberger by a long way

Options

1. jack watts + pav

2. Reiwoldt + yarran

3. reiwoldt + reid

 

[EFL Boy]

watts is injured

so riewoldt and yarran

 

[C-Dog]

Riewoldt and Yarran.

enright or fisher?

 

[johno_1989]

Riewoldt and Yarran.

enright or fisher?

Fisher

B. Johnson vs Fev vs Roughead vs Stokes

 

[trix17]

fev, i dont have him, but have a feeling about him this year

T.Tuck or Ray?

ray would be a different pick that not many teams have and has performed well over the pre-season, not sure how he will go in the season proper? tuck has been talked about enough on bigfooty, so thoughts on this problem are very much appreciated
Cheers

 

[Carlton Kid]

Mackay or Swallow

and

Swallow/Mackay and Ablett or Wells and A.Walker?

 

[TheNextBigThing]

Dean Cox and Nick Melceski or Josh Fraiser and Darren Milburn?