The official "X v Y" thread

[Electric Mayhem]

I thought i'd decided on my team but just checked out pre-season stats and was surprised with Kurt Tippett's numbers.

Any thoughts on him over Hamish McIntosh?

And who should i start on the field out of Broughton, Petrenko or Suban?

 

[marshie_blues]

pav vs reiwoldt

and

delidio vs buddy

 

[DeadlyAkkuret]

The only reason im considering dalziell is because - haha most teams are looking so damn similar - and i just think most guys wont take the punt on dalziell - and my tale of picking him in my midfield will turn out like a feel good hollywood movie with that dude who does the voice on all trailers narrating

Dalziell will be a gun, I'm very confident he'll be a big point getter.

 

[Teak_Pies]

Enright vs Newman????

 

[marshie_blues]

pav vs reiwoldt

and

delidio vs buddy

ok i hav 3 combos i can go with

reiwoldt and delidio

pav and buddy

pav and delidio

which one do ppl think is best

 

[Teak_Pies]

Pav and Deledio

 

[kreuze control]

ok i hav 3 combos i can go with

reiwoldt and delidio

pav and buddy

pav and delidio

which one do ppl think is best

lol i actually think the only one you didn't have is the best one.

i have buddy and deledio in my team and not the other 2. you can't really go wrong with them 2 and pavlich but riewoldt might be worth overlooking as he's the only one with a serious injury question mark which may or may not be true.

 

[marshie_blues]

Pav and Deledio

yeh thats what i hav mate
think ill stick with it leaves me with 35000
so pretty happy

i know this has been asked alot
but i wanna hear one last opinion

houlihan vs raines

i did hav both but traded houlihan down to krakouer to get selwood
so now im thinkin bout it again

 

[marcmurphy3]

A few last decisions.

Selwood vs Gibbs vs Wells vs Ball

I've had Gibbs for ages but I'm starting to lean torwards Selwood but I'm worried about the possibilty of having 3 Geelong mids in the future. I have Ablett atm and will get Bartel later.

 

[marcmurphy3]

yeh thats what i hav mate
think ill stick with it leaves me with 35000
so pretty happy

i know this has been asked alot
but i wanna hear one last opinion

houlihan vs raines

i did hav both but traded houlihan down to krakouer to get selwood
so now im thinkin bout it again

I'd go Houlihan. Is safer. Guarantee to score between 75 and 85. Raines is more like between 60 and 85.

 

[Hot Tiges]

Ahhh, go Selwood buddy.. Haven't heard much about Gibbs..

Bock,Houlihan and J Riewoldt VS Malceski, Krakour and sub 561 defender Have Fisher and Newman atm.. Any ideas?Bit worried about Goddard's hammy as well.

 

[marshie_blues]

A few last decisions.

Selwood vs Gibbs vs Wells vs Ball

I've had Gibbs for ages but I'm starting to lean torwards Selwood but I'm worried about the possibilty of having 3 Geelong mids in the future. I have Ablett atm and will get Bartel later.

yeh i had gibbs and decided to swap him for selwood so id say its a good idea
luckily for me made a few changes and managed to get them both in the team

 

[marcmurphy3]

Ahhh, go Selwood buddy.. Haven't heard much about Gibbs..

Bock,Houlihan and J Riewoldt VS Malceski, Krakour and sub 561 defender Have Fisher and Newman atm.. Any ideas?Bit worried about Goddard's hammy as well.

Um for the sub 560k defender I'd go Gilbee

 

[trossa]

Just looking for some advice on this scenario:

Pavlich + Ryan Houlihan + Andy Otten
OR
Chapman + N. Krakouer/Skipworth + Travis Tuck

What do you think? Also, bit torn on Krakouer and Skippy.. so yeah, thought please?

I got my mate to post the thread for me, since my comp was being weird with BF so yeah, thanks

 

[Spartan]

For those with M.Robinson..

Aaron Joseph vs Mitch Robinson?

Blues dont really have a tagger (besides Squibbs).. so Joseph might keep his spot better than Robinson?

Thoughts?

 

[trossa]

Robinson. If Joseph tags he'll really sacrifice his own game and won't get much of the ball.

 

[Spartan]

Robinson. If Joseph tags he'll really sacrifice his own game and won't get much of the ball.

So who makes way for Stevens from the listed side?

He might score less but will play more games?

Joseph is only averaging about 8 pts less than Robinson.

 

[trossa]

Well I'm really suprised Joseph is playing this round, I don't see him playing that many more this year to be honest. I think Robbo will play 15+

 

[Koutafidamedis]

Gilbee / Richo (33k left over)
or
Enright / S. Johnson ( 70k left)

 

[DeadlyAkkuret]

J. Brown V B. Harvey V Deledio

Dalziell V Cousins

 

[inter09]

Gilbee / Richo (33k left over)
or
Enright / S. Johnson ( 70k left)

id go gilbee and rich

and for DeadlyAkkuret
id say probably for me personally deledio and dalziel, though that is tough, id prefer wells or foley to both personally!

um what about adock vs scott stevens?

 

[Carlton Kid]

I need 4 of the following 5....

Judd
Burgoyne
Selwood
Gibbs
Wells

 

[Carlton Kid]

id go gilbee and rich

and for DeadlyAkkuret
id say probably for me personally deledio and dalziel, though that is tough, id prefer wells or foley to both personally!

um what about adock vs scott stevens?

Go Adock, new vice captain at Bisbane he'll score well

 

[00Stinger]

ok here is one for you
Bock v Drummond???

 

[strategy]

Robinson. If Joseph tags he'll really sacrifice his own game and won't get much of the ball.

When Joseph tagged Ablett he got 29 SC points and Ablett 84 SC points