-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
The Player A Vs Player B SUPERMEGATHREAD!!
- Thread starter Blue Dimension
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Banned
- #402
Let's see....Prismall not even getting a look in at Geelong even with Wojcinski down and Dyson who is a certainty for the Dons...
Yeah I figured as much. I suppose it all comes down to Kosi's health.
Id go Marc Murphy and Dyson for your questions.
Im looking for a cheapie forward:
Leroy Jetta, Ben Reid or downgrade someone else to get someone actually decent?
That's a fair call, but i think Prismal will get some games. Murphy vs Johnstone on the other hand is doing my head in.
T.Cloke and save 30K.
That is another tough call, almost take a random guess.
Johnstone has black, Lappin, Power to protect him
Murphy has Stevens, Judd to protect him
I keep leaning towards Johnstone for some strange reason, I think it is because I have Stevens already in my team and I get stressed when I see two players from the same team in my lineup.
Micheal Johnston vs N Bock?
A Monfires vs D Thomas?
A Monfires vs D Thomas?
- Banned
- #408
i like johnson (i assume this means the freo johnson) a bit more, can get a lot from being the spare man in defence. i would say thomas as monfries didn't really have a great season last yr, and obviously thomas has more capacity to dominate.
a few of my dilemmas:
didak vs hall
koschitzke vs robert murphy
what does everyone think??
- Banned
- #410
i think cross is a bit more consistent.
two more: who do you think will score better out of jake edwards and scott thompson (kangas)??
and also out of rhys palmer and david armitage??
two more: who do you think will score better out of jake edwards and scott thompson (kangas)??
and also out of rhys palmer and david armitage??
- Aug 2, 2006
- 5,585
- 3,094
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Baltimore Ravens, Arsenal
which option is better....currently have 100+ k in the bank
Bowden and Hall
Symes and Pavlich
and also i am struggling to decide between hayes/cross/standton.....i think i am leaning towards Hayes at the moment due to everyone having Cross and stanton
Bowden and Hall
Symes and Pavlich
and also i am struggling to decide between hayes/cross/standton.....i think i am leaning towards Hayes at the moment due to everyone having Cross and stanton
symes pavlich imo as i am worried about bowden in the past he usually also plays as a key defender and this year he is going to be competing for the flanking possessions against king, newman and mcmahon.
cant go wrong with hayes cross or stanton. cross is amazingly consistent but lenny and stanton can score much higher than him.
IS NICOSKI WORTH IT? other option is barlow who i cant see getting 22 games unless sydney do poorly which i guess they might.
nicoski or barlow or neither?
- Aug 2, 2006
- 5,585
- 3,094
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Baltimore Ravens, Arsenal
Nikoski's confidence is not in existence at the moment...he looks liek he is in poor form and there are better options
- Banned
- #414
Nicoski isn't worth it IMO, I think he still has a lot of players in front of him
I'd personally spend 3 more grand and go for Ellis who I think will massively increase in value, most Dork supporters see him playing a lot of his time in the guts this year.
My dilemma;
Do I go for Richo/Lloyd and Deledio (I think Lids will step up this year, and Richo averages a good 85-90)
OR
Browny and Hall (or anyone in this similar range, providing it's under 304,500)
Personally I don't think there is a HUGE difference between Brown and Richo, on average it's only like 8 points, but Richo tends to be more up and down which hurts.
Then I see that Lids can do a lot more then Hall at this stage, which is why I've lent towards Richo and Lids, but I'm interested on hearing others opinions
Cheers
I'd personally spend 3 more grand and go for Ellis who I think will massively increase in value, most Dork supporters see him playing a lot of his time in the guts this year.
My dilemma;
Do I go for Richo/Lloyd and Deledio (I think Lids will step up this year, and Richo averages a good 85-90)
OR
Browny and Hall (or anyone in this similar range, providing it's under 304,500)
Personally I don't think there is a HUGE difference between Brown and Richo, on average it's only like 8 points, but Richo tends to be more up and down which hurts.
Then I see that Lids can do a lot more then Hall at this stage, which is why I've lent towards Richo and Lids, but I'm interested on hearing others opinions
Cheers
Wish I knew the answer to these two questions.
Personally I place Armitage infront of Palmer, just because has been in the system longer.
J Edwards and S Thompson, I would "guess" Thompson.
- Aug 2, 2006
- 5,585
- 3,094
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Baltimore Ravens, Arsenal
Brown>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Richo
- Banned
- #417
You realise that Brown only averages 8 more points then Richo yes?
TheBurningReD
Debutant
H Shaw/B Jones vs Guerra/Gram ?
- Aug 2, 2006
- 5,585
- 3,094
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Baltimore Ravens, Arsenal
Take Richo if you want, but i am telling yoou Brown is better by a long way
cant see ellis playing 22 games this year but oh well. ellis it is.
any other recommendations anyone?
Don't be spoon feed like that. If you don't like Ellis don't get him. IMO he's the an OK option for that price. There's not a whole lot there. But then again you don't have to get someone at that price. You can go lower or higher and re-jig other parts of your team.
People come on here with certain idea's in there heads and get talked in to other options. It's not that the advice is bad, it's just that it's no longer your team if you just accept people's recommendations so utterly and blindly. In fact that's the whole problem with this thread, if you go through it, not a lot of noted good dreamteamers post in here.
- Aug 2, 2006
- 5,585
- 3,094
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Baltimore Ravens, Arsenal
Ellis
Newman
IF you have the money to spend get Gibbs, but at Dyson's price it is hard too look past him
yeah yeah chill back i know i dont just go and unclick nicoski and click ellis i weigh it all up myself. i aint stupid *
* but as no one else anywhere has talked about anyone else besides barlow being possible to get ellis would be the one i would change unless i can some mo money. also what are peoples opinions on JOSH HILL? got him in my line up. think i should have him on bench or not at all?
Similar threads
