The Player A Vs Player B SUPERMEGATHREAD!!

[football2008]

fraser and cross

or

cox and reilly

thoughts?

 

[the hairy cat mooney]

heres a hard 1 for u guys haha

birchall, cooney, demsey and N.thompson

vs

johncock, mclean, murpy and rioli

awwwwwww im so0o confused!!

 

[hellfire]

fraser and cross

or

cox and reilly

thoughts?

Geez I'm in a very similar situation.

Cox and Lucas.

or

Fraser and Riewoldt

Decisions, decisions. The only question mark for me is Fraser staying fit. Because if he can stay 100%, I have no doubt he'll average 85+. If someone could peer into the future and tell me he won't miss a game, I'd definately take the second option. Arrrrgghhhhhh I dunno.

 

[football2008]

heres a hard 1 for u guys haha

birchall, cooney, demsey and N.thompson

vs

johncock, mclean, murpy and rioli

awwwwwww im so0o confused!!

I would have to go the second lot..cooney over priced i feel, pretty inconsistent and dont really know what to expect of thompson..id take birchall over johncock though

 

[football2008]

Geez I'm in a very similar situation.

Cox and Lucas.

or

Fraser and Riewoldt

Decisions, decisions. The only question mark for me is Fraser staying fit. Because if he can stay 100%, I have no doubt he'll average 85+. If someone could peer into the future and tell me he won't miss a game, I'd definately take the second option. Arrrrgghhhhhh I dunno.

I think cox and lucas for sure. or even lucas and fraser and upgrade elsewhere, riewoldt got a niggling injury and lucas would only ever average a few less than him, had a good preseason too. any help on mine? haha

 

[hellfire]

Well I think the gap between Cross and Reilly is much bigger than the gap between Cox and Fraser. Cross is going to have a huge year IMO, so I'd go the first option mate.

 

[the hairy cat mooney]

I think cox and lucas for sure. or even lucas and fraser and upgrade elsewhere, riewoldt got a niggling injury and lucas would only ever average a few less than him, had a good preseason too. any help on mine? haha

yeaaa i need the money though ... only problem!! ... cheers 4 the advice

 

[the hairy cat mooney]

HANSEN, Lachlan or Henderson for brisbane who is likely to get more game time

 

[Scott Thompson > Judd]

Alan Diak + Nathan Thompson

or

Travis Cloke + Cyril Rioli

 

[WoodyIsGod]

Pendlebury or Judd???

 

[Pie Legend]

Re: Prismall or Dyson?

been trying to decide on this one for a while

Same here, but also with Houli in the equation

For what its worth, I have Prismall At the Moment

 

[GmeUP]

Re: Prismall or Dyson?

Dyson. He's already in the midfield only ahs to hold his spot. Prismall will find it alot harder with Geelong's midfield so will either play less, play less TOG or play out of position.

 

[jezza you beauty]

Will attempt to answer the three above me:

Hansen v Henderson
Hansen - had a few big wraps on him being a high draft pick, and is reported to have a big engine, so possibly a spot on the wing has been thrown around. But didnt score well in the pre-season and i was burnt by him last year, so im not confident. Henderson is another tall (i think), how will he go in the brissy forward line with the likes of Brown and Bradshaw and either berger or charman floating down there? I would lean on Hansen as the roos would be wanting to get their big name draft pick on the park and start the development

Didak+ Thompson v Cloke + Rioli

Havent looked at prices, but what about Didak and Rioli with some cash left over.
Didak could spend a little more time in the midfield which should help his score, whilst Rioli being a 1st year player has much greater potential to increase in price.
Thompson and Cloke are key position players, so they're scores will be very up and down. 2 questions for these guys. 1. Cloke improved a lot last year, will he improve that much more? 2. How will Thomo come back from a year off. Could be a slow start.
BUT if i had to pick from the 2 choices you gave.....i would lean towards Didak (potential midfield run now and then) and Thompson (should be a target up forward for the roos and should increase in price well, maybe back to $300,000 or more?)

Judd V Pendlebury.
I guess you would have to go judd. Has been a proven superstar, and IF he's fit and ready to go, should return to that level.
Pendles is also a gun but im thinking he will continue to slowly rise year after year.
More potential from Judd, so he gets the nod

Hope that helps a little.

 

[jezza you beauty]

Now for a question of my own:

Can you rank these forwards, all returning from interupted seasons last year (or missed the whole season), but all have been worth a lot more in previous years.

Hall
Burton
Tredrea
Nathan Thompson
Bradshaw
Dew

2 questions -
1. who do you think will be the best out of this lot?
2. who do you think will increase in value by the most?

cheers

 

[pieman123]

q.lynch or lucas?

 

[chickens_law]

N. Thompson + Hayes
or
W. Tredrea + M. Murphy

 

[blue_boys]

How do you guys think Mitchell will go this year??

I can do:

Mitchell with L.Hansen and Fev (assume he isn't suspended)

or

Carrazzo/Ablett/Lappin/Mitchell with Scott D Thompson and R.Murphy

Which one ... and if second option which midfielder

 

[kenny712]

Tough decision for me, i know both could be massive improvers but Coughlan(195k) OR Dyson(201k)?

 

[Juddtastic]

B. Waters/ B. Jones or J.Gram???

 

[jezza you beauty]

This is a very pointless thread if people are only going to ask questions and no one is prepared to answer (or at least give opinions to) other peoples questions.

 

[dont bowl there]

q.lynch or lucas?

Quinten has more upside as I cant see Lucas improving on his 07 output.

N. Thompson + Hayes
or
W. Tredrea + M. Murphy

Probably the first one just because Hayes is a lock for the year and nobody else there is.

How do you guys think Mitchell will go this year??

I can do:

Mitchell with L.Hansen and Fev (assume he isn't suspended)

or

Carrazzo/Ablett/Lappin/Mitchell with Scott D Thompson and R.Murphy

Which one ... and if second option which midfielder

I would go second option with Thompson from Adel or from that list Carrazzo.

Tough decision for me, i know both could be massive improvers but Coughlan(195k) OR Dyson(201k)?

Dyson will start better as Cogs will get eased into the first few games.

B. Waters/ B. Jones or J.Gram???

Waters or Gram, depends on who you like more...both will score around the same imo


There now someone else can put an opinion on a few questions...if you ask a question you should have to answer a question first.

 

[JuddyisGod]

Bernie Vince or Stuart Dew?

Leunberger or Hampson or Kreuzer?

 

[tiger trooper]

Bernie Vince or Stuart Dew?

Leunberger or Hampson or Kreuzer?

Even tho burgs may play more few more games hapson has the potential to score higher and increase in value quicker.

DOnt know much bout vince but id personally go with dew.'

COX AND SYMES OR GODDARD AND MCINTOSH???????????

 

[JuddyisGod]

Even tho burgs may play more few more games hapson has the potential to score higher and increase in value quicker.

DOnt know much bout vince but id personally go with dew.'

COX AND SYMES OR GODDARD AND MCINTOSH???????????

defnitely Cox and Symes

 

[JuddyisGod]

defnitely Cox and Symes

Nicoski or Barlow or Roughead?