Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
2024 has a bit of a 2015 smell about itIt is fine to have these threads, it is a discussion platform after all, but really football has really become a week to week proposition, moreso than anytime since it commenced.
We are starting to develop a stronger game style and more players are becoming more consistent.
Reality is whether B Smith is with us next season is becoming irrelevant to out opportunity over the next couple of seasons.
Some early losses this year whilst adjusting to the new game style and coaching structure, as well as getting games into 8 to 9 players may cost us in 2024.
If we make finals we will be dangerous, but the big issue will be improving again next season which would make us a genuine threat
On SM-S926B using BigFooty.com mobile app
And Sydney and other interstate sides sook it up about not getting to play on the GWait, let me get this straight...
We play more games this year at the Adelaide Oval than we do at the MCG?
Wow.
It is beyond silly that Collingwood play us at Marvel but play Port at the G. They should play their two contacted marvel games against interstate sides. We should never be the away team at Marvel against the Pies, Tigers, Demons etc...And Sydney and other interstate sides sook it up about not getting to play on the G
In 2016, Sydney played more games there than we did
I agree. By all means i'm not on St Kildas level and want to play home games at the G when we can't even fill Marvel.It is beyond silly that Collingwood play us at Marvel but play Port at the G. They should play their two contacted marvel games against interstate sides. We should never be the away team at Marvel against the Pies, Tigers, Demons etc...
Hypothetical:Baz would be one hell of a sub if we were to make finals and he is ready to go. Imagine bringing that kind of running power on in the 4th.
Except that that one's not a hypothetical!Bloody hell DW…this is like choosing between Albo and Dutton
Doesn't work like that though with existing contracts and AFL's interests, as much as I agree with you on principle.It is beyond silly that Collingwood play us at Marvel but play Port at the G. They should play their two contacted marvel games against interstate sides. We should never be the away team at Marvel against the Pies, Tigers, Demons etc...
Clearly Brisbane or GC didn’t t request to play us in Queensland….haven't played either of them up here for 2 years - surely the fixture isnt that rigid that they cant make sure every team gets at least one game in each state every year. Especially now there is gather round in Adelaide, its possible to drop some teams off playing there against Port or Adelaide in some years as their fans have already had a chance to see them play liveDoesn't work like that though with existing contracts and AFL's interests, as much as I agree with you on principle.
Considering all this, you end up in the situation where it's highly likely that Pies host Dogs at Marvel.
- AFL are specifically contracted to play a certain division of games between the two Stadiums in Melbourne
- Under the previous ownership AFL had to play a small number of blockbuster games that would get 60,000, if played at the G, at Marvel. AFL now own the stadium, but presumably want to keep a roughly similar amount of 'blockbuster' type games to profit off a stadium they own, and to justify things like the taxpayer investment in the recent refurbishment.
- Collingwood are contracted to play two games at Marvel
- Collingwood are contracted to play five designated away games at the MCG, and gain certain benefits for reserved seat holders and their team using the home change rooms despite being the designated away team
- Other teams are contracted to play a certain number of home games at the MCG, or want to play as many as possible
- You can't stack too many Marvel or MCG games in a certain week, or have two games on a single day
- This needs to fit into all other fixturing constraints with days breaks, who plays who twice etc.
Obviously not knowing all the demands and fixture and contract requirements I can't map out an alternative fixture myself, but I don't doubt all reasonable fixture possibilities lead to it being highly likely.
It's similar to our two Ballarat games. Ideally, we would want these games to be against only the four opponents of Adelaide, Port, GWS and GC - the two Perth teams don't need extra travel and Brisbane and Sydney have enough Melbourne-based supporters. We ideally want these two games played early in the season, before winter makes the weather too bad, but not our literal first home game, where signing up members or making an effort to attend the first home game is a tradition. Some fixturing elements are absolute - like we would never play a Melbourne-based team in Ballarat - but some things are desired and requested, but impossible to accommodate - the above.
As such we have not had all of our desired elements, we've played Ballarat games vs. Brisbane (not great, as we miss out on the revenue generated by Brisbane away fans in Docklands), and this year, we played our first home game in Ballarat and we play a late-season game in Ballarat. Not ideal, but impossible to make a fixture if every desired request was fulfilled.
I wouldn't say it's beyond silly that Pies host us, at least without referencing broader contracts and commercial interests (some of Pies' contracts where they get home-ground benefits as the away team at the MCG is the silly element of it all!).
Write down all the elements that go into creating a fixture. It isn't just 6 games being played at 2pm on a Saturday anymore.Clearly Brisbane or GC didn’t t request to play us in Queensland….haven't played either of them up here for 2 years - surely the fixture isnt that rigid that they cant make sure every team gets at least one game in each state every year. Especially now there is gather round in Adelaide, its possible to drop some teams off playing there against Port or Adelaide in some years as their fans have already had a chance to see them play live
I understand all the fixture constraints and I think you've outlined them well.Write down all the elements that go into creating a fixture. It isn't just 6 games being played at 2pm on a Saturday anymore.
Commercial interests, 5 and 6 days breaks, interstate teams not travelling consecutively too often, blockbuster fixtures, double-up fixtures from last year's ladder positions etc. etc.
What would take a hit is the commercial side of the game - they want good teams playing Thursday and Friday nights, and they want the big 4 vic teams playing each other twice ever year - so in order to achieve what you're suggesting, we'd have to cop boring blockbuster games and less money from less big 80,000 crowd MCG games. Maybe they should, but that's the direction they've taken. AFL has locked itself in with more weird fixturing quirks because of a desire to make more and more things and absolute priority to include. Right or wrong AFL has clearly prioritised certain commercial matches above the idea of every team playing in every state.
And Bont went into the temple of EJ, and cast out all them that sold and bought in the temple, and overthrew the tables of the money changers, and the seats of them that sold TV rights and hospitality boxes, And said unto them, It is written, My house shall be called the house of fair play and equal opportunity for all clubs; but ye have made it a den of thieves.
— with apologies to Matthew 21:12–13
Good on you for having a crack. I get that there is still 6 games left but I think we have a big enough sample size to say we’re too inconsistent and not a finals side. I don’t want to be relying on other teams to fall over for us to fall in.What we need to do play finals. Trying to simplify this crazy season GWS 7th, Dees 8th and Port 9th are one game ahead us but we have a better percentage. So, we need to win one more game than 2 of them and all teams have difficult draws (see below). I think we need to win 4 of the last 6. Three and we would need a lot to fall our way. I have us making it with 4 wins in the last 4 games but losing the next 2. We really need to beat our nemesis the cats next week to take some pressure off. Hard to see us beating the swans in Sydney.
GWS PREDICTION
Suns H W
Dees A L
Hawks H W
Lions A L
Freo H W
Dogs A L
Melbourne
Freo A L
GWS H W
Dogs A L
Port H W
Suns A L
Pies H W
Port
Tigers H W
Carlton A L
Swans H L
Dees A L
Crows H W
Freo A L
Dogs
Cats A L
Swans A L
Dees H W
Crows A W
Roos H W
GWS H W
I’m torn - while the goal is to play finals,on one hand it would be great to get these young kids a taste of finals footy on the other if we just miss out, does it fuel their hunger moreGood on you for having a crack. I get that there is still 6 games left but I think we have a big enough sample size to say we’re too inconsistent and not a finals side. I don’t want to be relying on other teams to fall over for us to fall in.
Interestingly, with that draw we could be play well and still only win 2 games…
Definitely want to make it in. 4 game run is all we need and our best can beat anyone. But especially want to make it as we don't have a R1 pick!I’m torn - while the goal is to play finals,on one hand it would be great to get these young kids a taste of finals footy on the other if we just miss out, does it fuel their hunger more
I think getting in is a better result because you never know what can happen
I respect your opinion but I believe the most Bulldogs thing to do would be to lose to Geelong (because it's what we do), upset Sydney in Sydney (also what we do), pull of a "Carlton-game-esque" like performance to knock off Melbourne, only to then drop the game against Adelaide with Riley Thilthorpe kicking 7.1.13 wins and good % likely gets you in.
Which would mean 4-2 from us assuming our % stays healthy.
Probably the most Bulldogs thing to happen from here would be lose the next 2, win the next 3 and set up a win or go home against GWS in the final round.
I respect your opinion but I believe the most Bulldogs thing to do would be to lose to Geelong (because it's what we do), upset Sydney in Sydney (also what we do), pull of a "Carlton-game-esque" like performance to knock off Melbourne, only to then drop the game against Adelaide with Riley Thilthorpe kicking 7.1.
Beat LOLNorf in an uninspiring display, leaving us still able to knock GWS out of 8th spot and claim it for our own, before getting our pants pulled down by Callum Brown, of all spuds, who kicks 3 final quarter goals from the pockets at Marvel.
I don't think you can get much more "Bulldogsy" than that.