These players are gone:

[polakthetiger]

I don't see Kingsley & Schulz both being cut ( or traded ) at the same time. Kingsley was brought in as cover so the kids had time to learn, and they're not there yet. We don't need the extra cover any more, but still, losing both would be too much.

I could also see Hall kept as cover depending on what trades we can make for ruckmen. ( maybe not if we get pick 1 ). Hopefully he wouldn't need to play, but if we want/need to keep a older backup ruckman, he's probably a better option than Knobel fitness wise.

I like P.Bowden, but his position on the list must be in doubt unless he fires at the end of the season.

You want to see Kingsley, Hall and Bowden stay....who exactly is going to make way then for the new draftees ...please name at least 7.

 

[telsor]

You want to see Kingsley, Hall and Bowden stay....who exactly is going to make way then for the new draftees ...please name at least 7.

That's not what I said.

I said one of Schulz and Kingsley would probably stay ( I'd keep Schulz ), because if Richo went down, we wouldn't want Hughes and Jack as our KPP forward line ( yet ).

I said we wanted to keep Hall or Knobel if we couldn't get a decent older ruckman in trade ( or knew we'd get one in PSD ).

Both of these are simple list management.

I said P.Bowden was unlikely to stay unless he did well on his return from injury.

Apart from that, I agree with Marco Polo's list.

 

[polakthetiger]

That's not what I said.

I said one of Schulz and Kingsley would probably stay ( I'd keep Schulz ), because if Richo went down, we wouldn't want Hughes and Jack as our KPP forward line ( yet ).

I said we wanted to keep Hall or Knobel if we couldn't get a decent older ruckman in trade ( or knew we'd get one in PSD ).

Both of these are simple list management.

I said P.Bowden was unlikely to stay unless he did well on his return from injury.

Apart from that, I agree with Marco Polo's list.

No worries...my bad! I will go along with that...except Rayo...would hate to think we had to watch him run around as our ruckman next year. Can't see him improving much on what we are surviving on with now...Simmo, Patto, Polak and even Tuck can ruck before we keep Hall as a backup ruckman..time for him to make way...there will be a new ruckman on our list come next year!

 

[reliable source]

Gus, Howat, Hall, Gaspar, Moore, Bowden.P, Hartigan, Kingsley.

Trade: McGuane, Meyer, Pettifer, Schulz, Tivendale, Tuck.

Let's change 14 on our list in 1 year.
My you are smart.
Are you taking on the new role GM left vacant?
What a genius!
Maybe if i say everybody on the list is going to get traded or delisted when we get to november I can say "see I was right".



If you are going to post about delistments or tradings be specific not general.

 

[Richo Rules]

i really dont think tuck or petts will be going

ones who are in danger

P Bowden - didnt do anything this year when playing and disapeared without any news for a month then they told us it was his hip
he will be 50/50 depending on TW's mood

R Hall - is gone will get game 100 probaly in the last round then delisted unless someone wants to trade

B Hartigan - another tough one as he has done nothing because of injury so i say 50/50 depending if he has impressed wallace

C Hyde - wont get delisted but may be up for trade if right trade comes
he does have flashes of brilliance but is nowhere near consistant enough
gone if right trade comes

Kingsley - gone

Knobel - gone todays game you need running ruckmen like cox lade simmo and kreuzer

Krakouer - i will say he will be traded

Meyer - has done nothing and doesnt look happy maybe traded for messen from adelaide who is in same boat if not we wll keep him

Moore - gone not good enough and if he was he would be in seniors a long time ago

Schulz - should be kept but if right trade came then may be offloaded as another who isnt consistant enough

Tivendale - has enough talent to be one of the afl's elite but never goes to that level
seems he is happy playing average footy at te tiges so time to piss him off
i have no doubts whoever he ends up with he will be a star but he never does it for us

Howat - i doubt he will be retained
King and Graham i think will be retained

 

[CoggaRules]

i really dont think tuck or petts will be going

ones who are in danger

P Bowden - didnt do anything this year when playing and disapeared without any news for a month then they told us it was his hip
he will be 50/50 depending on TW's mood

R Hall - is gone will get game 100 probaly in the last round then delisted unless someone wants to trade

B Hartigan - another tough one as he has done nothing because of injury so i say 50/50 depending if he has impressed wallace

C Hyde - wont get delisted but may be up for trade if right trade comes
he does have flashes of brilliance but is nowhere near consistant enough
gone if right trade comes

Kingsley - gone

Knobel - gone todays game you need running ruckmen like cox lade simmo and kreuzer

Krakouer - i will say he will be traded

Meyer - has done nothing and doesnt look happy maybe traded for messen from adelaide who is in same boat if not we wll keep him

Moore - gone not good enough and if he was he would be in seniors a long time ago

Schulz - should be kept but if right trade came then may be offloaded as another who isnt consistant enough

Tivendale - has enough talent to be one of the afl's elite but never goes to that level
seems he is happy playing average footy at te tiges so time to piss him off
i have no doubts whoever he ends up with he will be a star but he never does it for us

Howat - i doubt he will be retained
King and Graham i think will be retained

You forgot Hyde with that dude. They are both destined to stardom, when the rest of the comp shares your no doubts, or realises that they have been watching 2 potential superstar elite players, and never noticed what only you have. LMAO....sheeeeesh...