Event This Sunday 8th DEC 7pm HERE Rookies Rising Star Award season 38

Remove this Banner Ad

Reader mode
Hello S38 Rookies,
the opening page is continuously being contructed as information on the award comes into focus, the latest installment is the history of the creation of the RSA award by the creator Ant Bear.
Fascinating stuff!
I will tag you all again when it's all completed.
Cheers.

458258190_920761733425959_2105324710218290428_n.jpg

Trying on outfits to wear today in the urban jungle.
 
for the best rookie of the season, the EKA, which is announced in the Mobbenfuhrer Medal (SFA B&F) Night.The SFA Rising Star award is different. It's not only different, but better.
Click to expand...
Pamcake1 said:
This is an award that has endured and has captured the hearts of the freshmen and women of the SFA league, in a way that the more prestigious but elitist EKA Medal never has.
Click to expand...
Wow. You R.S. recipients seem obsessed with EKA.
Given the bitterness umm, strong spirit on display here from winners of best 'players stats' and the most 'posts', :sneaky: I will graciously step aside from the honorable position bestowed upon me from the committee chairperson. I would not want to get in the way of the wonderful and creative re-framing of what the R.S. is and will become. I suggest the committee consist of players who scored more highly than this little horsie.
The R.S. now aspires to stand for greater things. Longevity and active participation outside of game day. This is a worthy and noble ambition.
One I can't be arsed aspiring to.

I wish the commitee and next R.S winner all the best.
😊🐎🍎🥕

Ps. Any EKA's out there, I lost that golden key pass to our elite pm. Help out a sister?
 
Last edited:
myblueroan said:
Wow. You R.S. recipients seem obsessed with EKA.
Given the bitterness umm, strong spirit on display here from winners of best 'players stats' and the most 'posts', :sneaky: I will graciously step aside from the honorable position bestowed upon me from the committee chairperson. I would not want to get in the way of the wonderful and creative re-framing of what the R.S. is and will become. I suggest the committee consist of players who scored more highly than this little horsie.
The R.S. now aspires to stand for greater things. Longevity and active participation outside of game day. This is a worthy and noble ambition.
One I can't be arsed aspiring to.

I wish the commitee and next R.S winner all the best.
😊🐎🍎🥕

Ps. Any EKA's out there, I lost that golden key pass to our elite pm. Help out a sister?
Click to expand...
The either or postition doesn't need to be a continual issue.
In reporting on the history you and others can see it has been politicised as being so but I don't see it as such.
The Eka & the RSA are parallel awards, each covering different issues with a large cross over area.
In the embracing of both awards as being meritous and without privileging one over the other, it is possible and consequently preferable as it is all for the benefit of the Rookies and with a long term view of the health of SFA league itself.

That the RSA being the more democratic of the two by being judged by the sophomores of the league and therefore of it's time and adaptable to their concerns builds in a flexibility that the EKA doesn't have.
This should be embraced by all as it allows a creative approach to the awarding of merit.

I hope all participants, Rookies and Sophomores embrace both awards with open hearts and minds and the RSA in the spirit of which it has been initiated rather than continue a base resentment that one is better than the other when the league and the Rookies themselves benefit from both.
 
Last edited:

Log in to remove this ad.

Alright, well if you don't post negative comparisons that will be good.They should co-exist in a positive way, and referring to EKA at all is not necessary and unhelpful.

I for one will welcome the changes in criteria to win this award. (Is the originator of this award ok with changes?)

I think the most important change needs to be removing sim based player stats as a part of it. Hard to take seriously with this, Despite so many worthy past winners. And quality over quantity of posts.

And if you are going to re write the criteria, it needs to differ from the EKA enough that they don't just merge into one medal.
 
myblueroan said:
Alright, well if you don't post negative comparisons that will be good.They should co-exist in a positive way, and referring to EKA at all is not necessary and unhelpful.

I for one will welcome the changes in criteria to win this award. (Is the originator of this award ok with changes?)

I think the most important change needs to be removing sim based player stats as a part of it. Hard to take seriously with this, Despite so many worthy past winners. And quality over quantity of posts.

And if you are going to re write the criteria, it needs to differ from the EKA enough that they don't just merge into one medal.
Click to expand...
The Rising Star Award has changed and evolved from the history as posted in the opening page, that's one of the beauties of it.
I agree with you and I have not personally posted any negative comments of comparison between awards and nor do I wish for that to become a focus because it is a redundancy.
Both awards are very worthy and both awards are something for all of the Rookies to aspire to obtain.
The originator of the award Ant Bear is hands off and has been since the first year, he built that into the RSA Award with purpose.
The Sim has no standing or major effect and the season 38 Rising Star Awards criteria is currently being nutted out.
The fundemental difference between how the two Rookie awards are granted, judged and controlled doesn't lend itself to a merger so that will not be of consideration foreseeably.
 
Raz said:
i upset too many people and never win popularity contests .

The problem being an aspie!
Click to expand...
It’s not the beez mate, and ironically the Nerd Club tried to kill it.

Strange then how big_icky (a Nerd Club leader) ended up running it last season ….. but then again, he won it in S26 (as Dav).
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Pamcake1 said:
View attachment 2098713

Rising Star Rookie Award Season 38

View attachment 2098724

Greetings to Rookiesville Sweet FA Season 38



Welome all Rookies of the Sweet FA you are all eligible for the Rising Star Award that will be announced in mid Dec 2024.

Judged by the previous season’s rookie class it's aim is to identify and reward that one Rookie that is considered the bees knees and the cats pyjamas of their season with a view to many years ahead of productive participation in the Qootysphere.



Judging criteria for the award is via the secret recipe handed down through the decades and will differ from the EKA, that other Rookie award. We will be judging the Rookie contributions across all aspects of the Sweet FA.

No pressure it's the quality of your contributions that really counts.

The entire Sweet FA family wants you and values you as a contributor for a long time not just this season.



With this in mind we will not be nominating a weekly rising star. All rookies will be deemed eligible when the Rising Star committee meets to adjudge the winner. The purpose of this thread prior to the award ceremony is to highlight contributions made by a rookie. Sweet FA community- feel free to highlight something you think a rookie has done well if you wish.



We sincerely wish you a pleasant Sweet FA journey and look forward to all your contributions.



Thanks from the Chairperson of the Rising Star Award Season 38 and Season 37 Rising Star winner Pamcake1



Eligible Rookies Season 38
FreoGirl (Oobs) manicpie (Royals) jamesclean (Royals) Mr Cheese (Royals) p4p1 (Demons) Orange crush (Furies) brian_muz (Warriors) raffrox (Warriors) Raz (Swamprats) Giant YoYo (Wonders) The_Wookie (Gumbies) HinkleysHeroes (Roys) SSSSSS (Bears) PaPaPete (Bombers) mcgrath_truther (Bombers)​
Click to expand...
 
Chief said:
I don't recall anything about the medal at all. Talk to the game admins.


What's a rookie?
Click to expand...

Pamcake1 said:
View attachment 2098713

Rising Star Rookie Award Season 38

View attachment 2098724

Greetings to Rookiesville Sweet FA Season 38



Welome all Rookies of the Sweet FA you are all eligible for the Rising Star Award that will be announced in mid Dec 2024.

Judged by the previous season’s rookie class it's aim is to identify and reward that one Rookie that is considered the bees knees and the cats pyjamas of their season with a view to many years ahead of productive participation in the Qootysphere.



Judging criteria for the award is via the secret recipe handed down through the decades and will differ from the EKA, that other Rookie award. We will be judging the Rookie contributions across all aspects of the Sweet FA.

No pressure it's the quality of your contributions that really counts.

The entire Sweet FA family wants you and values you as a contributor for a long time not just this season.



With this in mind we will not be nominating a weekly rising star. All rookies will be deemed eligible when the Rising Star committee meets to adjudge the winner. The purpose of this thread prior to the award ceremony is to highlight contributions made by a rookie. Sweet FA community- feel free to highlight something you think a rookie has done well if you wish.



We sincerely wish you a pleasant Sweet FA journey and look forward to all your contributions.



Thanks from the Chairperson of the Rising Star Award Season 38 and Season 37 Rising Star winner Pamcake1



Eligible Rookies Season 38
FreoGirl (Oobs) manicpie (Royals) jamesclean (Royals) Mr Cheese (Royals) p4p1 (Demons) Orange crush (Furies) brian_muz (Warriors) raffrox (Warriors) Raz (Swamprats) Giant YoYo (Wonders) The_Wookie (Gumbies) HinkleysHeroes (Roys) SSSSSS (Bears) PaPaPete (Bombers) mcgrath_truther (Bombers)​
Click to expand...
 

Attachments

  • Madonna .jpg
    Madonna .jpg
    259.9 KB · Views: 0
Reader mode

Remove this Banner Ad

Event This Sunday 8th DEC 7pm HERE Rookies Rising Star Award season 38

Similar threads

Tigerturbulance
Event ⭐The B.O.O.B AWARD NIGHT SEASON 38🏆
3 4 5 6 7
Replies
162
Views
2K
Harvey Manfrenjensenden
Harvey Manfrenjensenden
Headless
  • Poll
Discussion To whom should we award the Season 38 premiership?
Replies
8
Views
190
Bluelegs
Bluelegs
AnUltimateRessie
Media Season 38 Posting Analysis
29 30 31 32 33
Replies
802
Views
10K
DragoDelph
DragoDelph
FootyGuy13
Media Season 38 Mobbs Predictor: Okay, I was wrong last season.
2
Replies
26
Views
657
FootyBot13
FootyBot13
AnUltimateRessie
Media Every Players Season 38 Performance Ranked
2
Replies
30
Views
588
AnUltimateRessie
AnUltimateRessie
Tonga Bob
Official Team Thread Coney Island Warriors | Season 38 Team Thread | Here We Go Again
3 4 5 6 7
Replies
167
Views
4K
Tonga Bob
Tonga Bob
TheInjuryFactory
Media TiFmedia Sweet FA Power Rankings - Season 38
3 4 5 6 7
Replies
155
Views
3K
serial_thrilla
serial_thrilla

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top