Player Watch Tim Broomhead - (Delisted 2020)

[Daicos Torpedo]

I haven't read the thread since the broken leg...
My point is obvious and has been stated.. .
Grundy and the Broom are best mates ....
Broom deserves a 1 year contract .
Grun dog would be a happy chappy ..
We kept 2 Blokes after St Kilda beach drug stuff up for 2 years
Keep the broom...

 

[pablo disco bar]

Hope he comes back and does well
Spew this happened

 

[jackcass]

Still waiting for your expert opinion on why Broomhead is a good player, oh that's right, you can't be bothered, funny how people who have no idea all of a sudden don't want to respond, we should get together some time chump and share some stories

I'm yet to see any unreasonable assessments in relation to Broomy but the kid has shown his pace and skills could enable him to make the grade. Restricted to 35-40 games through injury, what amazes me is posters who definitively claim they know he can't make it. At least the projection that he COULD is evidence based, whereas the projection he can't is purely a guess.

 

[76woodenspooners]

Any news on Broomhead?

Understand he’s out for the season - but it’s been nearly 4 months since he broke his leg and surely he’d be in rehab by now? Has he been seen on the training track at all?

 

[whiskeytown]

Any news on Broomhead?

Understand he’s out for the season - but it’s been nearly 4 months since he broke his leg and surely he’d be in rehab by now? Has he been seen on the training track at all?

Had the same thought yesterday. Strangely feel now that if he can make a full recovery, that he will be decent depth in late 2019. Like Richmond our gameplan now requires that we have speedy hard running players to call upon if needed

 

[TradeDraft]

Any news on Broomhead?

Understand he’s out for the season - but it’s been nearly 4 months since he broke his leg and surely he’d be in rehab by now? Has he been seen on the training track at all?

Nothing but he could Easily Signed a New Contract and Club would not Announce it

 

[76woodenspooners]

Nothing but he could Easily Signed a New Contract and Club would not Announce it

24 year old ..

... played 36 games in 6 seasons ...

... small forward player who has kicked 27 goals in those 36 games ...

... he’s competing with players like JT and Stephenson who have both kicked more goals (28) in just this season alone. Add Elliott to that who is yet to come back and obviously Elliott is ahead in the pecking order.

... although other players he is competing with for the position include Kirby (out indefinitely, will probably retire?), Blair (only played 2 games this season, players of his experience who play that little rarely get a contract extension, will be delisted?) and Fasolo (Free agent, might look for better opportunities elsewhere?).

 

[Tarkyn_24]

Personally think he goes to the rookie list on a one year deal.

 

[lenny20]

Agree with Tarkyn, I would definitely re-rookie. Looking back at his first year in the seniors, he's a clean, fast, hard footballer. He hasn't had a fair run at it since then.

Shades of Josh Thomas - there's a chance he can come back after a long absence and deliver on the promise of his early outings.

 

[jackcass]

I agree on rookie listing but if push came to shove even an additional year on the senior list wouldn't be such a bad thing. Wouldn't be on huge money. Love to see Broomy get a decent crack at it.

 

[parvey]

Just delist him, absolute list clogger along with Blair, Smith and Wells, get some height into the team instaed of these useless dwarfs

 

[left at home]

Just delist him, absolute list clogger along with Blair, Smith and Wells, get some height into the team instaed of these useless dwarfs

The dwarfs seemed to be going ok at the moment.

 

[OniAu]

Just delist him, absolute list clogger along with Blair, Smith and Wells, get some height into the team instaed of these useless dwarfs

Agree with delisting the other 3. Broomy is different, has some elite qualities in his speed and natural football ability. Plus hes only 25 next year.

 

[Maggie5]

Just delist him, absolute list clogger along with Blair, Smith and Wells, get some height into the team instaed of these useless dwarfs

They are 180/181, may as well get rid of Elliott at 178, Adams at 181, Sidebottom at 184 and Treloar at 182 as well, right?

 

[TradeDraft]

They are 180/181, may as well get rid of Elliott at 178, Adams at 181, Sidebottom at 184 and Treloar at 182 as well, right?

Elliot,Adams,Sidebottom and Treloar as so far much better players it's not Funny

 

[Maggie5]

Elliot,Adams,Sidebottom and Treloar as so far much better players it's not Funny

It is if the only thing is to get rid of players based on their height. Would mean that Daicos and Brown are also no good because of their height.

 

[TradeDraft]

It is if the only thing is to get rid of players based on their height. Would mean that Daicos and Brown are also no good because of their height.

Very True but Shorter Players just don't have Upside as Taller Players do

 

[parvey]

The dwarfs seemed to be going ok at the moment.

There's good dwarfs and there are bad dwarfs

 

[Maggie5]

Very True but Shorter Players just don't have Upside as Taller Players do

Don't think I can agree with that, they all have a role and not sure that a few centimetres makes that much difference.

Supporters get just as excited when they see players like Rioli or a Franklin bring to the team/game.

 

[DrDavoren]

Very True but Shorter Players just don't have Upside as Taller Players do

Bloke called Lethal went alright so did KB, too many others too mention.
Plenty of tall spuds clogging up lists too TD.

 

[TradeDraft]

Don't think I can agree with that, they all have a role and not sure that a few centimetres makes that much difference.

Supporters get just as excited when they see players like Rioli or a Franklin bring to the team/game.

I think this is Something over the Time that we Disagree on a bit

 

[TradeDraft]

Bloke called Lethal went alright so did KB, too many others too mention.
Plenty of tall spuds clogging up lists too TD.

That was a Totally Different Era

 

[Gambit78]

Bloke called Lethal went alright so did KB, too many others too mention.
Plenty of tall spuds clogging up lists too TD.

I still think Corey Gault will come good...

 

[Finnishpie]

I still think Corey Gault will come good...

Steve McKee is ready to make this season his own, as long as Ben Kinnear doesn't take his place....

 

[TradeDraft]

Steve McKee is ready to make this season his own, as long as Ben Kinnear doesn't take his place....

McKee at least had 1 Good Season