Play Nice Tippett Nominates Sydney - Part II

[Andrew Mc]

Take this shitty deal or we'll get him to put a huge price on his head that no other club in the league can afford, and then you will get nothing for him.

NICE.

Good on Sydney, they see a chance to shaft another club, and they took it.

Still hurting from the shafting your club received at their hands on Saturday, 29th September, 2012 I see.

 

[Draft Bored]

And yet your club was willing to give him a longterm contract making him the highest paid player at your club...

What does that have to do with anything? I'm not having a go at Sydney, just the smart assed comment insinuating that Catsmaninamerica's comment was ridiculous and not based on any evidence.

Just providing a neurosurgeons view that was mentioned in an article earlier this year.

Jesus, defensive much?

 

[Thenewguy!]

"Jeffrey Rosenfeld, a leading neurosurgeon, states that three lifetime concussions should mean that the athlete not compete or train in contact sport again."

He suffered 3 in 5 weeks.

Talia will get 3 in a quarter after Tipray stands on his head!

 

[Sydney Bloods]

Take this shitty deal or we'll get him to put a huge price on his head that no other club in the league can afford, and then you will get nothing for him.

NICE.

Good on Sydney, they see a chance to shaft another club, and they took it.

And when did the club ever say that?
It was the crows that threatens to send him to the PSD if they weren't happy with the trade.

We called their bluff and said go ahead.

You still haven't answered why you think we should pay more then we have to? The crows made it clear this deal had no gentlemen's agreement and they were out to get the most they could from the trade.

Turns out they are getting **** all, there's no competitor for Tippett its just us why should we pay more then we have to?

Still bleating on with your uninformed cola rubbish as well I see.

 

[Blacky]

I love how 2 days ago Tippett was a gun that Sydney should be giving up Rohan and 22 for, and now all of a sudden he is one noogie away from death.

The trade stinks, I don't like it as it sets a bad precedent. I also feel for the Adelaide guys whose premiership hopes are dampened by this, Kurt is obviously a dickhead. I hope you guys manage to find a gun with 22.

Also, I'm fairly sure there would be some sort of concussion clause in the contract to mitigate the risk involved.

 

[MrPresident]

Which is even more reason why he's a dud. Not being able to get a game in a side that couldn't score to save themselves. I don't want him within a hundred miles of footy park. Far prefer leaving Sydney to delist him, we already have more talented players on our list who should hit their straps soon, in McKernan and Jenkins. Don't want White spudding it up stopping their development.

We scored the 5th most points in the comp this year. We scored more than Collingwood, West Coast and Geelong.

 

[worthy]

Still hurting from the shafting your club received at their hands on Saturday, 29th September, 2012 I see.

That is such a pathetic retort, congrats to Sydney on their premiership victory, pretty sure i've not said a bad word about it. So no, that's not the case.

Lol @ Sydney Bloods, I can imagine him giggling away liking your retort.

 

[MrPresident]

What does that have to do with anything? I'm not having a go at Sydney, just the smart assed comment insinuating that Catsmaninamerica's comment was ridiculous and not based on any evidence.

Just providing a neurosurgeons view that was mentioned in an article earlier this year.

Jesus, defensive much?

And I'm saying people are bringing up a complete non issue because if his own club who knows his medical situation better than anyone else was willing to pay him big money and in a long term deal than obviously he is healthy with no bigger chance of a career ending injury than anyone else and the crazies saying he's one headache from retirement are completely wrong.

 

[worthy]

I love how 2 days ago Tippett was a gun that Sydney should be giving up Rohan and 22 for, and now all of a sudden he is one noogie away from death.

The trade stinks, I don't like it as it sets a bad precedent. I also feel for the Adelaide guys whose premiership hopes are dampened by this, Kurt is obviously a dickhead. I hope you guys manage to find a gun with 22.

Also, I'm fairly sure there would be some sort of concussion clause in the contract to mitigate the risk involved.

Good on you for your honesty

And with that, i'm done with this thread.

 

[Sydney Bloods]

But you didn't answer my question!

 

[worthy]

But you didn't answer my question!

I won't be dragged back into this thr............DOH

 

[Andrew Mc]

That is such a pathetic retort, congrats to Sydney on their premiership victory, pretty sure i've not said a bad word about it. So no, that's not the case.

Lol @ Sydney Bloods, I can imagine him giggling away liking your retort.

So who else have Sydney shafted in the past at the trading table? If you're going to throw that around, at least back it up with something.

 

[tonk]

Make no mistake Syd reputation has been tarnished with the salary cap issue and this trade, most clubs try to trade fairly as have seen by the cats in their priemiship years trading players on for nothing picks.

Wouldn't be surprised if other clubs in the future will refuse to trade fairly with the Swans or tries to screw them over due to their behaviour since the flag was won.

I doubt it.

 

[tazhawk]

So who else have Sydney shafted in the past at the trading table? If you're going to throw that around, at least back it up with something.

Fixed it for you champ.

Dude everyone knows Vlad does the trading at the Swans.

Get with the times man.

 

[tonk]

Not one person has said anything along those lines. We're annoyed that Tippett is holding us ransom. We'll get over it when we outperform Sydney in 2013.

'if'

 

[Andrew Mc]

Fixed it for you champ.

Dude everyone knows Vlad does the trading at the Swans.

Get with the times man.

Stop trolling you ****wit.

 

[Draft Bored]

And I'm saying people are bringing up a complete non issue because if his own club who knows his medical situation better than anyone else was willing to pay him big money and in a long term deal than obviously he is healthy with no bigger chance of a career ending injury than anyone else and the crazies saying he's one headache from retirement are completely wrong.

I'm not sure you can call them crazies. I was very worried Tippett was going to be ruled out for the remainder of 2012 after his third for the year. There were doctors and neurosurgeons everywhere ranting about it. I'll be surprised if the AFC doesn't cop a lawsuit from Tippett when he's 40+ years old for allowing him to continue playing.

Honest question: What do you think will happen if he gets concussed 2 or 3 times next year (afl, kurt, doctors etc)?

 

[MaccasNeighbour]

All thats happened is that Tippett wanted out...not even contracted. He tells his club he's going then does the right thing and doesnt dutch auction himself and simply nominates a club that has made him an offer.

 

[Jars458]

Another Hawk on a Crows crusade. How noble. No doubt you had a flinching for them also, after the Gunston get.

Payback for the reaming the umps gave us in the Prelim. We would have belted the Swans in the granny as well.

 

[Numbered Days]

Fixed it for you champ.

Dude everyone knows Vlad does the trading at the Swans.

Get with the times man.

LOL. Which Swans fan owns this account? It's just set up to make fun of Hawthorn right? Every post is three lines usually something about bandwagoners, vlad and screwing Adelaide. I imagine someone mouthing the words as they type ... little fat fingers banging against the keyboard ... spittle flying out of their mouth.

Bravo, makes me smile everytime. So who really owns the account?

 

[barry fu]

Payback for the reaming the umps gave us in the Prelim. We would have belted the Swans in the granny as well.

Quite possibly Jars...
One wonders if some of the Hawks horde, would have been as concerned for club Crows over Tippetts ta ta. If that had been Septembers showdown.

 

[MaccasNeighbour]

But why should we give up a player we want?

Seriously? I wonder if that works for other things in life......'Sure the price of that car is $40,000 but I only want to pay $10,000'

 

[TripleB]

Honest question: What do you think will happen if he gets concussed 2 or 3 times next year (afl, kurt, doctors etc)?

Two things.

1. He will retire immediately
2. Every Adelaide supporter will be on the Swans BF board, giving it to us in spades.

PS. I'm more confident that 2. will happen than 1.

 

[MF]

Seriously? I wonder if that works for other things in life......'Sure the price of that car is $40,000 but I only want to pay $10,000'

Most car dealers wouldn't be stupid enough to put themselves in a position where they had to accept either 10k or nothing for a 40k car, when they'd been given fair warning.

Once in that position you'd also hope they wouldn't be stupid enough to complain about the customer not being "fair" just because they didn't pay 30k more than they had to.

Seriously... Blame Tippett, and blame your own staff. This isn't Sydney's fault.

 

[TripleB]

Seriously? I wonder if that works for other things in life......'Sure the price of that car is $40,000 but I only want to pay $10,000'

But if at 5pm it is going to be placed on the back of a tow truck and taken away, never to be seen again, at 5 minutes to 5 that 10K will look better than nothing...