Tom Hawkins best CHF of the last 25 years

[AG]

Carey, Brown and Riewoldt are the indisputable top 3 the rest you can argue about.

Tredrea was better than Brown and Riewoldt imo. Your opinion is very disputable.

Don't know why we all excuse bias for things like these. What's the point then?

 

[Lunchlady Doris]

Yeah, dumb by me

 

[Gongswan]

Carey may well belong at the top of teh list, still sickens me to put such a complete douche there though

 

[MC_9]

Carey, Brown and Riewoldt are the indisputable top 3 the rest you can argue about.

Ahh nah.

You say indisputable. Yet in the last 10 years alone you could have Tredrea, Richardson and Franklin, not to mention the likes of Kernahan and Brereton ahead of Riewoldt and Brown. Brown in particular is often rated for what he can do rather then what he has done.

 

[Honeyboy Wilson]

Hahaha Jonathan Brown above Tredrea. Always makes me laugh.

 

[Pj.Rj.Hj]

Carey
Brereton
Kernahan, Tredrea, Grant and Lowe all have good claims on no. 3.

Out of the Geelong 3, Stoneham would be the closest to being in that top 10.

 

[Cousin of Daicos]

Mooney?

hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha.

 

[CF]

My List for the last 25-30 years:

Wayne Carey
Dermott Brereton
Stephen Kernahan
Bernie Quinlan (I will just sneak him in)
Nick Reiwoldt
Lance Franklin
Jonothan Brown
Warren Tredrea
Matthew Richardson
Barry Stoneham

 

[The Dustbin]

No bias, but Mooney was better than Lucas/Richardson/Kernahan, and to show I am not joking he is better than Riewoldt. Yeah ok Tom.

 

[mufassa]

Carey may well belong at the top of teh list, still sickens me to put such a complete douche there though

It is best player list - not best bloke - a lot of great players were complete douche's - does not take away from how good on the field they were.

 

[deledio7]

Tredrea has been overrated massively in this thread. His best was exceptional but he didn't achieve a level of consistency (injuries to blame) to claim honours over Brown and Riewoldt.

My list

Carey
Brereton
Kernahan
Riewoldt
Brown
Richardson
Tredrea
Franklin
Hall
Lucas/Lowe

 

[mollyfud]

Although most only remember him from post 2000 when his shoulder was shot, Nick Holland should be in consideration! Gun mark. Second best CHF to Carey in that era. Would hate to think the number of frees he would get if he played with modern arm chopping rules!

 

[Gongswan]

It is best player list - not best bloke - a lot of great players were complete douche's - does not take away from how good on the field they were.

I didn't say it did, I simply said he sickens me

 

[Ravenous Crow]

Tredrea has been overrated massively in this thread. His best was exceptional but he didn't achieve a level of consistency (injuries to blame) to claim honours over Brown and Riewoldt.

All-Australian 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004, robbed IIRC 2005.

 

[greennick]

I don't know why they bother with these, they are so biased they aren't worth anything.

 

[DTRAIN87]

If you think realistically though Hawkins is unlikely to even remember some of those players like Brereton and Kernahan play at their best.

 

[Necromancer Beth]

Tredrea has been overrated massively in this thread. His best was exceptional but he didn't achieve a level of consistency (injuries to blame) to claim honours over Brown and Riewoldt.

My list

Carey
Brereton
Kernahan
Riewoldt
Brown
Richardson
Tredrea
Franklin
Hall
Lucas/Lowe

Lol, this site is funny.

Tredrea acheived about twice as many individual honours as Matthew Richardson.

 

[Magpie Since 1986]

Love how OP accuses Hawkins of "bias" and then proceeds to put Lucas in the top 5, comedy.

 

[deledio7]

Lol, this site is funny.

Tredrea acheived about twice as many individual honours as Matthew Richardson.

It's a lot easier in a strong team. Richo's individual stats are every bit as good as Tredrea's if not better. I'm rating the players purely as footballers.

Tredrea had 5 or 6 very good seasons but due to injury didn't perform at a level close to that in other years. Richo kicked 800 goals dont forget.

 

[Jade]

My List:

1. Wayne Carey
2. Dermot Brereton
3. Jonathon Brown
4. Scott Lucas
5. Chris Grant
6. Warren Treadrea
7. Lance Franklin
8. Barry Hall
9. Nick Reiwoldt
10. Barry Stoneham

I have serious man love for Scott Lucas - but he can't be above Tredrea or Nick Riewoldt.

 

[Necromancer Beth]

It's a lot easier in a strong team. Richo's individual stats are every bit as good as Tredrea's if not better. I'm rating the players purely as footballers.

Tredrea had 5 or 6 very good seasons but due to injury didn't perform at a level close to that in other years. Richo kicked 800 goals dont forget.

Fair enough.

I don't have a massive problem with your list, just would have Tredrea higher and Brown shouldn't even be in there. Franklin being only 25 should get near the top two or three by careers end if he keeps playing well.

 

[Necromancer Beth]

I have serious man love for Scott Lucas - but he can't be above Tredrea or Nick Riewoldt.

He isn't above any of those players.

 

[Jade]

It's a lot easier in a strong team. Richo's individual stats are every bit as good as Tredrea's if not better. I'm rating the players purely as footballers.

Tredrea had 5 or 6 very good seasons but due to injury didn't perform at a level close to that in other years. Richo kicked 800 goals dont forget.

Hey Port fans; want to do this dance again? I had a ball last time.

 

[DTRAIN87]

Franklin is not a CHF.

 

[Necromancer Beth]

Franklin is not a CHF.

Well he's not a full forward either. He plays a variety of poisitions, CHF would be the closest.