Tom Hawkins best CHF of the last 25 years

[vast]

Here is the weekly personal best from the AFL site. Tom has kept with tradition of being biased

His list.

1. Wayne Carey
2. Jonathan Brown
3. Billy Brownless
4. Dermott Brereton
5. Lance Franklin
6. Warren Treadrea
7: Cam Mooney
8. Garry Lyon
9. Nick Reiwoldt
10. Barry Stoneham

My List:

1. Wayne Carey
2. Dermot Brereton
3. Jonathon Brown
4. Scott Lucas
5. Chris Grant
6. Warren Treadrea
7. Lance Franklin
8. Barry Hall
9. Nick Reiwoldt
10. Barry Stoneham

 

[Mancey]

Lol, thought thread title was stating hawkins was the best in the last 25 years. Was totally lolwut

Surely Richo deserves a guernsey. Mooney is laughable

 

[Mega Flog]

mooney > reiwoldt?

oh dear.

 

[Kaan]

Lol, thought thread title was stating hawkins was the best in the last 25 years. Was totally lolwut

 

[the_interloper]

Lol, thought thread title was stating hawkins was the best in the last 25 years. Was totally lolwut

Yep that's how I read it too. He's definitely up there, don't forget about Earl Spaulding though.

 

[Necromancer Beth]

Lol,

Mooney > Riewoldt
Brownless > Franklin

Brown is horribly overrated as well.

Surley he's taking the piss

 

[Rustin Cohle]

I wonder if people will be so up in arms about Hawkins' list like they were about Maxwell's, especially considering he has Mooney on it.

 

[Matching Mole]

This thread title is a few possessive apostrophes short of a complete mind melt.

 

[Necromancer Beth]

I wonder if people will be so up in arms about Hawkins' list like they were about Maxwell's, especially considering he has Mooney on it.

Maxwells was fine IMO.

Mooney, Stoneham and Brownless are all plebs who shouldn't be anywhere near that list.

 

[vast]

oops, should have arranged the title better but at least the thread will get hits haha

 

[Hawker55]

Would Buddy be counted as a CHF though? He might play around that area but he's a completely different player to pretty much every other player on that list (not necessarily better, just different).

 

[alfy!]

cue geelong haters trolling hawkins list

it's his personal opinion list, of course it will be bias

 

[Necromancer Beth]

cue geelong haters trolling hawkins list

it's his personal opinion list, of course it will be bias

He is trying to say that Brownless & Mooney are better players than Riewoldt & Kernahan. That's beyond bias, that's lunacy.

 

[bombermick]

His Cats bias is completely unjustifiable. The Cats don't have 1 CHF in the top 10, let alone 3.

 

[seanoff]

Kernahan was a pretty decent CHF, ropey kick but certainly should be on this list and above 5 if serious

Brownless has obviously been telling him stories.

hello all, nice to be back

 

[Heisenberg_]

That is the the worst list I have seen in my life no Kernahan or Richo.

Mooney shouldn't even be close

 

[Furn]

Nice troll by big Tom.

 

[sherb]

Kernahan was a pretty decent CHF, ropey kick but certainly should be on this list and above 5 if serious

Brownless has obviously been telling him stories.

hello all, nice to be back

Kernahan was a bit better than "prettty decent". Considerably better in fact.

 

[Palmer Stoat]

He is trying to say that Brownless & Mooney are better players than Riewoldt & Kernahan. That's beyond bias, that's lunacy.

Yes, have to agree. Rank stupidity.

 

[Furn]

Kernahan was a bit better than "prettty decent". Considerably better in fact.

Kernahan was better than everyone on those lists bar Carey and maybe Derm.

 

[Necromancer Beth]

That is the the worst list I have seen in my life no Kernahan or Richo.

Mooney shouldn't even be close

We all agree Brownless & Mooney shouldn't be near the list. Richrdson would probably be 5th, 6th or 7th and Kernahan should be top 3 no questions asked. Brown probably shouldn't be in that list either.

 

[Heisenberg_]

Wasn't Brownless a FF anyway?

 

[2010premiership]

Hah.. Billy is #3

 

[Bluelegs]

I love subjective top 10 lists. No matter who says it, who's in it or where they're ranked people will be throwing hissy-fits about an over-simplistic arbitrary ranking.

 

[Necromancer Beth]

Pretty shit full forward if he was. Only 441 goals from 198 games.