Top 10 Current Port Players Based on Potential

[cosmicwinduptoy]

It depends on what you rate.

Port members have a habit of rating players who play at their best in the big moments and the big games.

Evans and Burgoyne have already shown a greater potential to do that IMO.

Burgoyne could shoot the lights out over the next few years and still won't get close to achieving what Rozee has already achieved in his career. Two top 10 finishes in the AFL coaches votes award. Club Captain. Do you think Burgoyne will get close to that? It's a ridiculous call.

 

[shewho]

Leader Board After Post #50

196- JHF
179- Butters
134- Rozee
121- Georgiades
90- Bergman
81- Lukosius
55- Berry
54- Burgoyne
41- Evans
28- Whitlock
26- Sinn
19- Visentini
13- Walsh
11- Moraes
8- Jones
6- Sweet, Drew
5- Farrell
4- Wines, BZT
3- Marshall, SPP
2- Burton, Aliir

(a minimum of 8 players had to be nominated to count)

 

[Sewer de Lance]

Anyone excluding Rozee (or placing him 10th) is just being petty.

You would be hard-pressed to argue that he could end his career with 3/4 AA jumpers, and even go close to winning a brownlow under the right circumstances

Based on that, it's hard to place him anywhere but top 3 in a list like this. Unless you seriously think guys like Burgoyne or Evans have a higher potential than that

At the end of their careers, Evans will have more AA jumpers than Rozee.

 

[jackag24]

At the end of their careers, Evans will have more AA jumpers than Rozee.

Evans will be a good player, but I'd wager he won't get a single AA jumper

 

[Rash]

At the end of their careers, Evans will have more AA jumpers than Rozee.

Nice joke

Evans wont go near a AA blazer, might make the sqaud in the future though.

 

[Shaucob_Burjan]

I know I'm higher on Bergman than others but I do genuinely believe he could be the best defender in the AFL

 

[MALTSY]

1. JHF
2. Butters
3. Rozzee
4. Evans
5. Burgoyne
6. Bergman
7. Georgioudes
8. Sweet
9. Lorenz
10. Jones

 

[Jonts]

For the purpose of this exercise if they've reached their peak and it will never return I haven't counted them

JHF
Butters
Rozee

All 3 could win a Brownlow/coaches award and if wouldn't surprise me

Georgiades
Bergman
Lukosuis
Whitlock
Burgoyne
Berry
Sinn

 

[Peninsula Boy]

At the end of their careers, Evans will have more AA jumpers than Rozee.

That's a big call Caro.

 

[Peninsula Boy]

I know I'm higher on Bergman than others but I do genuinely believe he could be the best defender in the AFL

I'll double down on Bergman and say he could become a big bodied inside midfielder in the mold of Nat Fyfe.

 

[Duck Farmer]

Leader Board After Post #50

196- JHF
179- Butters
134- Rozee
121- Georgiades
90- Bergman
81- Lukosius
55- Berry
54- Burgoyne
41- Evans
28- Whitlock
26- Sinn
19- Visentini
13- Walsh
11- Moraes
8- Jones
6- Sweet, Drew
5- Farrell
4- Wines, BZT
3- Marshall, SPP
2- Burton, Aliir

(a minimum of 8 players had to be nominated to count)

I sense a disturbing lack of Cheese ITT.

 

[dirty2]

1. JHF
2. Rozee
3. Butters
4. Bergman
5. Lukosius (I hope he takes his chances at port)
6. Mitch G
7. Logan Evens
8. Sinn (needs injury free run)
9. Burgoyne
10. Marshall (but I think he is finished )

 

[davesnothere]

I'll double down on Bergman and say he could become a big bodied inside midfielder in the mold of Nat Fyfe.

Geelong can piss off he's contracted.

 

[shewho]

Leader Board After Post #62

226- JHF
205- Butters
159- Rozee
137- Georgiades
108- Bergman
92- Lukosius
65- Burgoyne
57- Berry
52- Evans
32- Whitlock
---------------------------------------------
30- Sinn
19- Visentini
13- Walsh
11- Moraes
9- Jones, Sweet
6- Drew
5- Farrell
4- Wines, BZT, Marshall
3- SPP
2- Burton, Aliir, Lorenz

(a minimum of 8 players had to be nominated to count)