Top 10 players uve ever seen

[magic51]

1 carey
2 ablett
3 voss
4 hird
5 lockett
6 grant
7 dunstall
8 harvey
9 williams
10 hawkins

 

[Whitey_666]

Colin Sylvia

 

[Adelaide Hawk]

What I meant was that Plugger and Dunstall are both leading forwards as opposed to Modra who did the high jumping speccy marks and kicked a few ripper goals (I probably didn't word it correctly ). I just found Modra enjoyable to watch.

Fair enough

Cheers.

 

[WA ROO]

not in any order
Wayne Carey enough said
Greg Williams mean nasty got that job done killed you with precise disposal
Stephan Micheal the best ruckman I have seen
Gary Ablett snr again enough said
Tony Lockett the best full forward ever
Leigh Matthews see Williams with more nasty
Micheal Voss inspirational leads by example and bloody good
James Hird great skills leads from the front
Peter Matera 92 & 94 awesome
Paul Kelly loved watching him play

 

[chipsticks]

Richard Tambling Aka Bling Bling, enough said!

 

[SaveFeriss]

Best players Ive ever seen.

1. Gary Ablett (snr)
2. Wayne Carey
3. Tony Lockett
4. Dermott Brereton
5. Greg Williams
6. James Hird
7. Robert Harvey
8. Maurice Rioli
9. Gary Hocking
10. Micheal Voss

 

[Bolt]

Bias is one thing, but I've read some bulls**t in this thread. Either that or some people in here have only been watching the game for a year or two.

 

[WZA]

I fail to see how Dunstall and Lockett rank so high on everyones list. Their full fowards who had brilliant midfields are their disposal. Midfielders make their full fowards, you think Matthew Lloyd would kick as many goals and take as many marks without Johnsons, Hird, Soloman and the midfield that is Essendon? He has it on a silver platter at times, as did Dunstall and Lockett.

 

[m.diddy]

I fail to see how Dunstall and Lockett rank so high on everyones list. Their full fowards who had brilliant midfields are their disposal. Midfielders make their full fowards, you think Matthew Lloyd would kick as many goals and take as many marks without Johnsons, Hird, Soloman and the midfield that is Essendon? He has it on a silver platter at times, as did Dunstall and Lockett.

lockett didn't have a great midfield all he had was harvey and everyone knows he cant kick. Apart from that there was burke and he didn't really kick it a lot he was an in and under player so the delivery mainly came from winmar or stewart loewe not exactly a good delivery from the midfield

 

[Grendel]

Matthews
--------
Carey

Bartlett

S.Madden

Blight

Ablett

Williams

Lockett

Dempsey

Roos

Keeping it to strictly who I've seen (i.e I've still to see play from Voss, Hird, R.Harvey, Figgie.. yea it's an 'out' but a fair one from my pov ). Also Matthews aside (as he's clearly the best I've seen) I kept Hawthorn players out of it to remove what bias I could.

Many names could slot in, Doull, Flower, Shimma, Dougie, Lyon, Watson etc but it's probably not a selection.

 

[WZA]

lockett didn't have a great midfield all he had was harvey and everyone knows he cant kick. Apart from that there was burke and he didn't really kick it a lot he was an in and under player so the delivery mainly came from winmar or stewart loewe not exactly a good delivery from the midfield

He played for Sydney too mate

 

[eddiesmith]

1. Lockett
2. Buckley
3. G.Ablett
4. Voss
5. Daicos
6. S.Rocca
7. M.Lloyd
8. W.Tredrea
9. L.Matthews
10. J.Akermanis

The ten best to play and the best to watch play from what I've seen

 

[hirdy_is_champ]

You only 6?

oh yea like im gonna remember stuff from wen i was under 6.
stupid

 

[hirdy_is_champ]

I honestly hate you hird_is_champ. You never seize to amaze me.

y?? coz i didnt put buckley in. he can go in the outsiders list. but i honestly think every player on that list i put in were the best ive seen

 

[scholltzy]

In no particular order. They're all too different to compare....

Daicos
Ablett snr
Lockett
Dunstall
D Jarman
R Harvey
M Lloyd
W Tredrea
M Voss
J Hird

have u lived on this planet?
or were u born last yr
u didnt put in carey..

 

[CaptainDangerfield]

In no particular odrer:

Carey,
Lockett,
Ablett
Kernahan,
Lloyd,
Knights,
Roos,
McLeod,
Voss,
Lynch.

Hird, Tredrea, Modra and Roo are thereabouts.

 

[Thierry Henry]

Mcleaod dosent deserve to be there. He could be but he bludges to much of late.

 

[bergkamp_scores]

Carey
Ablett Snr
Lockett
Voss
Hird
Buckley
Peter Matera
Mcleod
Robert Harvey
Judd

 

[CaptainDangerfield]

Mcleaod dosent deserve to be there. He could be but he bludges to much of late.

I wonder if that has anything to do with dodgey knees?? You don't win two Norm Smiths if you're a hack.

 

[Yze_Magic]

best player i have seen is David Schwarz in 1994, pre-knee

made Carey and Ablett look second rate

 

[nut]

1. Gary Ablett

2. Darren Jarman

3. Wayne Carey

4. Jason Dunstall

5. Tony Lockett

6. Greg Williams

7. Dale Wieghtman ( Always dominated for Victoria)

8. Robert Harvey

9. James Hird

10. Alister Lynch

 

[wooshta_9]

Gary Ablett
Wayne Carey
Jason Dunstall
Michael Voss
James Hird
Tony Modra
Andrew McLeod
Nathan Buckley
Peter Matera
Glen Jakovich

Outsiders: Dean Kemp, Robert Harvey, Ben Allan.

 

[WZA]

y?? coz i didnt put buckley in. he can go in the outsiders list. but i honestly think every player on that list i put in were the best ive seen

Your spelling hun, your spelling. I have no problem with your opinions, just the way you write, i can hardly understand.

 

[The Doctor]

In no order

Tony Lockett
Leigh Matthews
Alex Jesaulenko
Gary Ablett
Gary Dempsey
Wayne Carey
Robbie Flower
Tim Watson
Glen Jakovich
Greg Williams

 

[ztien]

1. Carey
2. Hudson
3. Jesaulenko
4. Ablett
5. Hird
6. Flower
7. Lockett
8. Voss
9. Hart Royce
10. Stewart Ian