Werewolf Town of Salem Werewolf V (Town, Executioner & Survivor win)

[SaintBilly]

Jmoo seems to think Rob isn’t evil so not sure what is going on there, but he has to be one of the neutral roles at a minimum. Strig is good imo.

The remaining “baddies” are MCBG, Pick, Dero, MP and ClarkeM?

I’m pretty confident Rob is neutral based on something jmoo said.

Jmoo I personally have on the same line as Porps yourself and zerg.

However when I did the check of all roles I noticed that would make two retributionists. So I started to question if zerg was being sincere.


Should we take a massive punt and lynch zerg today?

 

[jmoo wan]

To be fair, I used to have Strigoi on Ignore for like, two years during Covid.

But yes this was harsh, but it's a game so meh.

ignore is the best!

although i think serial thrilla has me on ignore

 

[jmoo wan]

I’m pretty confident Rob is neutral based on something jmoo said.

hmmm…. was it this?

i don’t think Robertio is evil, chuck him in the neutral pile for now

or maybe this

nah - he’s not evil, and not good, and we need to kill evil

 

[por_please_ya]

Noted...

 

[SaintBilly]

hmmm…. was it this?

or maybe this

I knew you were right to the point.

 

[ClarkeM]

Sorry Jmoo, got caught up in a conversation at work. I’ll PM you now.

 

[por_please_ya]

• Jailor = I know who this is
• Sheriff = Strigoi **
• Doctor = SaintBilly
• Investigator = por_please_ya
• Vigilante = kananooks - about to be nuked
• Random Town Investigative = BEaston (Investigator)
• Random Town Investigative = omgfridge (Lookout)
• Random Town Protective = Croweater (Bodyguard)
• Random Town Protective = NaturalDisaster (Doctor)
• Random Town Killing = Jack The Godfather (Vigilante)
• Random Town Support = eth-dog (Escort)
• Random Town = Town Killing, Chipmunk (Veteran)
• Random Town = Town Investigative, Elmer_Judd (Retributionist)
• Random Town = Town Support, sante (Mayor)
• Random Town = Town Investigative, Ligma (Psychic)
• Random Town = possibly IMS, Team Investigative (Sheriff) **
• Random Town = SPARE …. Pickitt ??? Not sure I trust Zerg anymore, but he could be Town Investigative (Retributionist)
• Godfather, still at large
• Mafioso, 3KZ is Football
• Random Mafia, CursingFijian (Hypnotist)
• Random Mafia, hotchilli (Consigilere)
• Random Mafia, JANITOR, still at large, possibly Zerg
• Coven Leader = Senor M
• Medusa, still at large
• Random Coven = Greenery (Hex Master)
• Random Coven = Tarkyn_24 (Poisoner)
• Random Coven = Necromancer (possibly Wiz??) Unless Zerg faked being poisoned to clear himself, which I thought was unlikely, but you never know…. And then he would know the mechanics of his role and how it would look, because the Retributionist has a similar role but for Town
• Random Neutral Killing = Serial Killer, still at large
• Random Neutral Killing = Werewolf, still at large
• Random Neutral Evil = Executioner/Jester, still at large
• Random Neutral Benign = Survivor more likely than Amnesiac, still at large

PEOPLE LEFT WHO ARE UNCONFIRMED

Pickitt
DERO
MP_
Clarke = some kind of neutral
Robertio = some kind of neutral
MCBG
Pie 4 Life
Strig = probably good
IMS = not sure anymore but could really only be same role as Strig based on his results. Hasn't been helpful since though

Wiz being cleaned has really ****ed us up actually cause you can't account for it anywhere. The only role he couldn't be is Mafia, only in Coven, Neutral, or a good role.

 

[Robertio]

I know you’re insane clarkey and you’ve been a lot of fun. Sometimes when you don’t understand the rules it is fun to just act crazy. But to be honest the suns don’t add up that you would have a Town role.


sante curious what makes you think mcbg is the play? Your point on ims is good but why not say Pickitt or pie4life?

Any one of them is the play.

 

[Robertio]

Thoughts on jmoo strig and Rob?

Rob not evil.

 

[SaintBilly]

Rob not evil.

I know you’re not evil. I wanted to know what sante thought. It was a test because I wanted to see if sante knew what I knew.

 

[ClarkeM]

Jailor = I know who this is

Same, I just better not reveal his identity. I’ll keep it in my PM though.

 

[por_please_ya]

Same, I just better not reveal his identity. I’ll keep it in my PM though.

Well you kinda said it before lol I think it's obvious though.

 

[ClarkeM]

Well you kinda said it before lol I think it's obvious though.

Yeah for sure. Hope he survives the night!

 

[SaintBilly]

Same, I just better not reveal his identity. I’ll keep it in my PM though.

You do that.

 

[ClarkeM]

You do that.

Are you claiming Jailor?

 

[por_please_ya]

There are plenty here who haven't offered ANYTHING in terms of their role and what it does. Most of the good roles are exposed.

So anyone not talking about their 'good role', is likely evil or a neutral.

I'm pinning this on MCBG, DERO, MP_, Wiz* (possibly one of the evil we can't confirm, anything BUT Mafia) in particular. IMS is a bit of a loose cannon. Clarkey and Robertio neutral. I think Pie may be neutral too. Pick, who knows.

So yeah, take your pick from the list.

• Mafia: Kill all Coven, Neutral Killing and Town Killing roles, and outnumber remaining Town* + Neutral Evil + Neutral Benign.
• Coven: Kill all Mafia, Neutral Killing and Town Killing roles, and outnumber remaining Town* + Neutral Evil + Neutral Benign.

Mafia AND Coven need Neutral Killing roles dead. Clarke mentioned that him dying would benefit evil which I thought was an interesting comment to make.

 

[sante]

I know you’re not evil. I wanted to know what sante thought. It was a test because I wanted to see if sante knew what I knew.

I’m pretty much a villager in this game

 

[SaintBilly]

I’m pretty much a villager in this game

Yea but importantly you’re a CONFIRMED villager.


Until you were revealed as mayor I was 50/50 on you but that reveal pretty much confirmed everything else was true but one claim was not.

 

[ClarkeM]

There are plenty here who haven't offered ANYTHING in terms of their role and what it does. Most of the good roles are exposed.

So anyone not talking about their 'good role', is likely evil or a neutral.

I'm pinning this on MCBG, DERO, MP_, Wiz* (possibly one of the evil we can't confirm, anything BUT Mafia) in particular. IMS is a bit of a loose cannon. Clarkey and Robertio neutral. I think Pie may be neutral too. Pick, who knows.

So yeah, take your pick from the list.

• Mafia: Kill all Coven, Neutral Killing and Town Killing roles, and outnumber remaining Town* + Neutral Evil + Neutral Benign.
• Coven: Kill all Mafia, Neutral Killing and Town Killing roles, and outnumber remaining Town* + Neutral Evil + Neutral Benign.

Mafia AND Coven need Neutral Killing roles dead. Clarke mentioned that him dying would benefit evil which I thought was an interesting comment to make.

I've offered SO MUCH and yet no one seems to believe me.

 

[ClarkeM]

Yea but importantly you’re a CONFIRMED villager.


Until you were revealed as mayor I was 50/50 on you but that reveal pretty much confirmed everything else was true but one claim was not.

Yep. Important and to be fair, I think the timing of this reveal was somewhat perfect timing.

 

[ClarkeM]

There are plenty here who haven't offered ANYTHING in terms of their role and what it does. Most of the good roles are exposed.

So anyone not talking about their 'good role', is likely evil or a neutral.

I'm pinning this on MCBG, DERO, MP_, Wiz* (possibly one of the evil we can't confirm, anything BUT Mafia) in particular. IMS is a bit of a loose cannon. Clarkey and Robertio neutral. I think Pie may be neutral too. Pick, who knows.

So yeah, take your pick from the list.

• Mafia: Kill all Coven, Neutral Killing and Town Killing roles, and outnumber remaining Town* + Neutral Evil + Neutral Benign.
• Coven: Kill all Mafia, Neutral Killing and Town Killing roles, and outnumber remaining Town* + Neutral Evil + Neutral Benign.

Mafia AND Coven need Neutral Killing roles dead. Clarke mentioned that him dying would benefit evil which I thought was an interesting comment to make.

What about Jmoo?

Oh that's right...

 

[SaintBilly]

Welp. Not long to go.

At the end of the day just do the right thing.

Remember there are four neutral roles but TWO of them are ones we need dead - SK and Werewolf.

Ok oes out.

 

[serial_thrilla]

NIGHT 5 NOTIFICATIONS

kananooks (Vigilante) committed suicide due to guilt.
LAST WILL
i have nfi whats going on.

ClarkeM (Werewolf) executed by the Jailor.
LAST WILL
This game is weird and I really didn’t have a clue what was happening, clearly. But thanks for playing along with me!

MC Bad Genius (Bodyguard) killed by a Serial Killer.
LAST WILL
Roses are red
Violets are blue
I had no interest
In protecting any of you




It is now Day 5.
Voting deadline is at 4pm AEDT.
There are 12 players remaining, so 7 votes required for a lynch.

Night 6 phase is Thursday 4pm-6pm AEDT (2 hours).
Day 6 phase is Thursday 6pm-12am AEDT (6 hours).
Night actions may be placed in advance.

Pie 4 Life
por_please_ya
MP_
sante
Strigoi
SaintBilly
Itsmyshow
Robertio
ZergMinion
jmoo wan
DERO
Pickitt

 

[por_please_ya]

There's not enough time to go through posts again now that we know more. No time to look at voting patterns

I think Village is screwed but I don't know

 

[ClarkeM]

serial_thrilla That is not my WILL

EDIT: Thanks for fixing, appreciate it.