Mega Thread Trade and List Management discussion

[MrDOK]

I believe that was sentinel

Hmmmmmmmmmmm…

Looks like Sentinel posted it first on the 21st Sept:

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threa...umour-and-source.1111915/page-6#post-41030052


McCraeBF posted their comment 3 days earlier on the 18th Sept:

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threa...nt-discussion.1012344/page-2010#post-40962122

Just saying….

 

[Zeno The Great]

"Our understanding is that he's met with Carlton and he'll meet with St Kilda and the Western Bulldogs in the next few days," Dodoro said."

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2015-09-29/demons-offer-to-bomber-jake-melksham-is-too-good-to-refuse

Looks like we have our meeting with Carlisle confirmed.

On another note...Melbourne my god trading a spud like Melksham in on a big deal....If that was a publicly listed company their CEO would be going to jail!

 

[paul scholes]

The problem is Dodoro wastes time and energy trying to bend clubs over .The whole Crameri for pick four was insane, and pick 26 was about right. Carlisle for pick 11 is about right also, but no doubt Dodoro will put some rediculous offer that will be knocked on the head.

 

[goodcop badcop]

Pick 11 for Carlisle is a reasonable swap. I'd probably be trying to push for something like pick 11 + our 2nd for Essendon's 2nd or a swap of 3rd rounders.

 

[VitalDread]

Hmmmmmmmmmmm…

Looks like Sentinel posted it first on the 21st Sept:

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threa...umour-and-source.1111915/page-6#post-41030052


McCraeBF posted their comment 3 days earlier on the 18th Sept:

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threa...nt-discussion.1012344/page-2010#post-40962122

Just saying….

i tend to ignore McCrae half the time

 

[paul scholes]

Pick 11 for Carlisle is a reasonable swap. I'd probably be trying to push for something like pick 11 + our 2nd for Essendon's 2nd or a swap of 3rd rounders.

A swap of picks would take place you'd think

 

[CaptainMurphy]

Hmmmmmmmmmmm…

Looks like Sentinel posted it first on the 21st Sept:

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threa...umour-and-source.1111915/page-6#post-41030052


McCraeBF posted their comment 3 days earlier on the 18th Sept:

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threa...nt-discussion.1012344/page-2010#post-40962122

Just saying….

I stand corrected.

 

[Beasley]

We will have the announcement Thursday that Jake has asked to be traded to Western Bulldogs.

Bombers want pick 11 and 30
Bulldogs want to give pick 30 and Talia

Carlton only offering 3 year deal
St Kilda want to use second round pick only and a player? 5 year deal
Bulldogs offered 4 year deal with the promise of CHB position a lock by the coach..

This is not a rumor and I would rather my club went for Tomlinson GWS

Bullsh*t

 

[ErnieSigley]

Depends on the sort of bloke he is I guess? $450k to rot in the magoos, or $300k to play 2 or 3 more seasons in the big show?

Why is it a blot on his character? Most would choose the money.
No guarantees elsewhere either. It's highly unlikely to happen. What's more likely is if we find another ruck and we don't want minson , we will need to subsidise him.

 

[smashh]

Why is everyone all over McCraeBF?
Just by the looks of it had the Talia info very early, and yet everyone is jumping all over for sharing a very realistic bit of info they've received.

Why would anyone wanna share anything round here...

 

[FoochPackage]

Why is everyone all over McCraeBF?
Just by the looks of it had the Talia info very early, and yet everyone is jumping all over for sharing a very realistic bit of info they've received.

Why would anyone wanna share anything round here...

Because unless this info comes from 2 or 3 certain posters then it just cant be true. How dare he post something he may know

 

[Pannalstaroz]

STOP THE PRESSES!!!!!!
I've got POTY sewn up!

This is the best rumour I've heard

 

[grassman75]

STOP THE PRESSES!!!!!!
I've got POTY sewn up!

This is the best rumour I've heard

View attachment 178952

Well he better bloody well give his chair back then...ungrateful sod

 

[smashh]

Because unless this info comes from 2 or 3 certain posters then it just cant be true. How dare he post something he may know

Bit of a boys club on an internet forum it seems...
Some heads need to be pulled out of arses.

 

[VitalDread]

STOP THE PRESSES!!!!!!
I've got POTY sewn up!

This is the best rumour I've heard

View attachment 178952

I know the admin of that page and i believe he deleted it hahaha

 

[Norm De Guerre]

This'll be good for at least 25 pages.

 

[Mingo]

I know the admin of that page and i believe he deleted it hahaha

Yeah can't find it. I joined just to read the comments When I couldn't find it I promptly vacated.

 

[Testekill]

The problem is Dodoro wastes time and energy trying to bend clubs over .The whole Crameri for pick four was insane, and pick 26 was about right. Carlisle for pick 11 is about right also, but no doubt Dodoro will put some rediculous offer that will be knocked on the head.

Dodoro probably thinks that he's more clever than anyone else. So he thinks putting pressure on a club by asking massively overs means that they'll crack when he gives them a later, slightly less silly offer.

 

[TheHoneyBadger]

Bit of a boys club on an internet forum it seems...
Some heads need to be pulled out of arses.

He's been called out for posting unsubstantiated garbage on multiple occasions. Throw enough shit and some of it will stick.

 

[yebiga]

He's been called out for posting unsubstantiated garbage on multiple occasions. Throw enough shit and some of it will stick.

Be nice

 

[smashh]

He's been called out for posting unsubstantiated garbage on multiple occasions. Throw enough shit and some of it will stick.

Just went through posts... Nothing is really off?
Had Talia goss before anyone else had even the slightest sniff - so quite obviously has a source.
Mentioned Talia -> Crows, Carlisle -> Dogs and Danger -> Cats in June.
Claimed WHE wanted to come to Dogs which wasn't far off at the time.
Said Dahl would sign 3 yr deal announced Feb 2015. BS calls were thrown around then too. Dahl signed a 3 yr deal announced March 2015.

That Talia break isn't exactly 'throwing shit at a wall' - to me it clearly indicates they have a great source. Things don't always eventuate but I don't doubt the source - and when someone has that and is willing to post info here they shouldn't be shot down.

 

[dergert]

No boys club here. Ridiculous to even suggest it, in all of my time here everyone has been nothing but respectful. Don't spoil it for the rest of us who don't have connections within the industry who want to feel a little bit more connected.

 

[Zgope1]

He's been called out for posting unsubstantiated garbage on multiple occasions. Throw enough shit and some of it will stick.

i'm glad i just asked. Because that Talia info is the first time i've ever seen something from Macraebf that has come up true.

 

[Zgope1]

Just went through posts... Nothing is really off?
Had Talia goss before anyone else had even the slightest sniff - so quite obviously has a source.
Mentioned Talia -> Crows, Carlisle -> Dogs and Danger -> Cats in June.
Claimed WHE wanted to come to Dogs which wasn't far off at the time.
Said Dahl would sign 3 yr deal announced Feb 2015. BS calls were thrown around then too. Dahl signed a 3 yr deal announced March 2015.

That Talia break isn't exactly 'throwing shit at a wall' - to me it clearly indicates they have a great source. Things don't always eventuate but I don't doubt the source - and when someone has that and is willing to post info here they shouldn't be shot down.

interesting. Ill pay more attention from here on maybe

 

[Mattdougie]

No boys club here. Ridiculous to even suggest it, in all of my time here everyone has been nothing but respectful. Don't spoil it for the rest of us who don't have connections within the industry who want to feel a little bit more connected.

Sorry mate but there is at least a little "clique" here that like to back slap and support each other when someone insults their tender egos.

They been pretty good lately but like the dark side they are in the background waiting to see weakness and then they pounce

Too much self lightsaber stroking I suggest