List Mgmt. Trade & F/A - 2020

[Jen2310]

Hartigan? No, thank you.

 

[stormskye]

If we trade Murphy at this stage we might as well fold the club

Bring him in for Phillips and chuck him on the wing. Bit of height may help us and give us kicking options to Stop this handball happy gameplay that good teams punish

 

[loki04]

We'll top up the midfield through the draft with Reef and Daicos in the next 2 years. So we could forseeably offload first round picks since we'll have academy prospect anyway (similar to how we did it with Quaynor).

I'm a fan of getting Ben Brown, and I'd love us to explore Tom McDonald to be a defender again.

I will vomit if we do that to our first rounder.

You should be looking at it as a priority pick to inject quality youth in 1 year.

Brown at 30yo is not worth a top 10 maybe even 6 pick. Incredibly short sighted.

 

[loki04]

There is absolutely zero chance we trade Treloar - it's not championship manager 2020 where you just trade players on a whim. Not that I'd be against it, especially now since he's showing that he's probably going to be sidelined to soft tissue injuries on a frequent basis, but the only way it happens is if he asks out and I can't see why he'd do that.

They asked him just last year when GC wanted him. He said no is why it didnt happen offered up pick 1 for him (Rowell).

 

[HFF]

Yeah we need another bloke sitting in his garage doing finger painting and eating our salary cap after Beams goes. It’s a mandatory list requirement at the pies now.

difference is he is training and available.....he isn’t an exclusive finger painter

 

[Apex36]

difference is he is training and available.....he isn’t an exclusive finger painter

He’s about 5 minutes away from it.

 

[Soups]

lol who?

For Murphy maybe? But I wouldn’t believe anything from that twitter. Polson is trash anyway.

 

[kaistar]

Hartigan is solid. No two ways about it. A very solid player, on the cheap, would be hard to say critic. However until we get a key forward, our list management team is ****ing useless.

 

[stormskye]

Seriously if crouch leaves adel and they get pick 2, I give up.. that will be such a rort

 

[Harry O]

AFL website has an article today saying list changes in 2021 will likely see a reduction to either 38 plus 2 rookies or just 40 with rookies abolished
With Cat 2 rookies likely to remain outside the 40

 

[whiskeytown]

The answer? 10 key forwards Collingwood should target

If Collingwood is serious about adding to their premiership tally with this list, it is time to get the cheque book out for a key forward 📝👇

www.zerohanger.com

For mine Finlayson or Wright are the ones on that list that are

- affordable, unlike Cameron and B Brown

- poachable, unlike Hawkins


- has several years left in them, otherwise you risk age related injuries or players past their peak (think Q Lynch to us or Cloke to the Bulldogs)

The caveat is that neither are 50 goal a year forwards. But I think a 30 goal a year forward like Finlayson or Wright is enough if they share a forward line with De Goey, Elliot, Mihocek, Stephenson, etc

 

[Matt_352]

For mine Finlayson or Wright are the ones on that list that are

- affordable, unlike Cameron and B Brown

- poachable, unlike Hawkins


- has several years left in them, otherwise you risk age related injuries or players past their peak (think Q Lynch to us or Cloke to the Bulldogs)

The caveat is that neither are 50 goal a year forwards. But I think a 30 goal a year forward like Finlayson or Wright is enough if they share a forward line with De Goey, Elliot, Mihocek, Stephenson, etc

Lol how isn't Brown affordable? North dreaming if they think they're getting anymore than a late first

 

[whiskeytown]

AFL website has an article today saying list changes in 2021 will likely see a reduction to either 38 plus 2 rookies or just 40 with rookies abolished
With Cat 2 rookies likely to remain outside the 40

I’m fine with that. Rookie list is neither here nor there nowadays. I say a list of 40 plus Cat B rookies.

Draft then works as follows:

1st rd picks get 3 year contract

2nd-3rd rd picks get 2 year contract minimum

4th rd picks, Delisted Free Agents, mid year draftees, etc get a 1 year minimum contract

Everyone senior listed except Cat B rookies

 

[Leviathan Pie]

You listed Dangerfield twice and forgot Fyfe... amateur

You're correct, Moorey. My apologies.

Edited.

 

[whiskeytown]

Lol how isn't Brown affordable? North dreaming if they think they're getting anymore than a late first

Draft picks aside. What are we gonna pay him with? The bloke will want market value... his manager will want more.

 

[Apex36]

Lol how isn't Brown affordable? North dreaming if they think they're getting anymore than a late first

Salary cap. Cameron is a free agent, so he clearly wasn’t talking about trade cost.

 

[Matt_352]

Draft picks aside. What are we gonna pay him with? The bloke will want market value... his manager will want more.

Few players we have will be traded/delisted/retired

 

[Apex36]

Few players we have will be traded/delisted/retired

Other players need to be recruited in their place though. It’s not like all the cash they free up can be taken by one player...

 

[Quicky]

Absolutely no club would want to take on treloar's contract who is reportedly contracted for another 5 years.

What's the source for that? I don't recall it being announced. Was it reported somewhere?

 

[Jen2310]

What's the source for that? I don't recall it being announced. Was it reported somewhere?

yeah.
"
The Herald Sun also reported Treloar had signed a four-year contract extension with the Magpies — a deal the club has opted not to publicise.

Treloar originally signed a six-year deal on around $650,000 per season when he was traded from the GWS Giants to Collingwood during the 2015 AFL exchange period."

AFL trade news: Adam Treloar Gold Coast Suns trade, Pick 1 Collingwood

Gold Coast reportedly made a bold play for Collingwood star Adam Treloar during secret trade talks held in the back-half of the 2019 season.

www.foxsports.com.au

.

 

[gouki88]

I will vomit if we do that to our first rounder.

You should be looking at it as a priority pick to inject quality youth in 1 year.

Brown at 30yo is not worth a top 10 maybe even 6 pick. Incredibly short sighted.

Trading a 1st round pick for a 30 year-old Brown would be terrible. Hopefully we don't do that in 3 years time, when Brown is actually 30

 

[Apex36]

Trading a 1st round pick for a 30 year-old Brown would be terrible. Hopefully we don't do that in 3 years time, when Brown is actually 30

2 years and a couple of months. If you’re going to criticise an age exaggeration then don’t do it yourself too.

 

[gouki88]

2 years and a couple of months. If you’re going to criticise an age exaggeration then don’t do it yourself too.

But he wouldn't be 30 during the AFL season until 2023, so it's not an exaggeration, it's just irrelevant entirely

 

[Matt_352]

Other players need to be recruited in their place though. It’s not like all the cash they free up can be taken by one player...

Fair

 

[Apex36]

But he wouldn't be 30 during the AFL season until 2023, so it's not an exaggeration, it's just irrelevant entirely

If you’re trying to get technical, if we were to trade for a 30 year old Brown it would be in 2 years, given the trade period runs in October. He would literally be a matter of weeks from turning 30. In 3 years we’d basically be trading for a 31 year old Brown. As I said, you’ve exaggerated. Time to end the conversation unless you’re going to argue that a couple of weeks is equal to a year.