List Mgmt. Trade & Free Agency talk Pt 8

[_RT_]

 

[Cleansweep17]

Philips is a poor man’s Tom Scully (both 181cm). Given Philips is small, just not sure what we’re hoping he turns into? A depth midfielder? He’s too small for a modern day wingman. He’s not dynamic enough or have goal kicking in his repertoire to be a HFF. So we are relying on him becoming what to make the 3 x $400k and the trade worthwhile? A smaller but maybe slightly better version of Dow? A better version of Sonsie (both 181cm).

Let’s make sure anyone we bring into the club is young AND a walk up best-18 in 2025… otherwise we are just list clogging. (I’d make an exception if it was a punt with upside and filled a need… a developing ruck or KPF). We don’t need small, C-grade midfielders.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

If last nights game wasn’t proof, we need to stop drafting short asses. The intercept marks around the ground are killing us, for some reason we can’t even spoil it anymore.

Hawks dropped sitters, that’s pretty much the only time we got the ball in a 1v1 on the wing.

 

[Tigerbob]

If last nights game wasn’t proof, we need to stop drafting short asses. The intercept marks around the ground are killing us, for some reason we can’t even spoil it anymore.

Hawks dropped sitters, that’s pretty much the only time we got the ball in a 1v1 on the wing.

Matty Clarke loved the absolute small short people.

What a legacy he has left!

Chris Toce comes in and bang! Two KPP. **** your short people over in the West Clarkey!

 

[tunksy]

I was only half gaggin, don’t be surprised if they do shop him , he’s too injury prone for me , not unlike lynch

they've genuinely improved. if lewis had of played every game to this point they could very well have been in the 8

 

[Cleansweep17]

Matty Clarke loved the absolute small short people.

What a legacy he has left!

Chris Toce comes in and bang! Two KPP. **** your short people over in the West Clarkey!

Yup,

Which is why we need to gut the list imo.

Grimes (retire), Cumbo (delist), Short (trade/retire), Prestia (retire, too injured), Baker (trade), Graham (trade), Naismith (retire), Mate Colina (delist), Macintosh (retire), Pickett (retire)

Either get 3 top 20 kids in the draft or 5 top 30.

Done.

 

[Bojangles17]

Chol 4G higgo 5G this weekend , if a player kicked more goals than they laid tackles dimma dead set despised them , leaving us with mansell cumbo and kozi to feast on our entries , oh Ty dimma , no thank you

 

[Cam Payner]

Yup,

Which is why we need to gut the list imo.

Grimes (retire), Cumbo (delist), Short (trade/retire), Prestia (retire, too injured), Baker (trade), Graham (trade), Naismith (retire), Mate Colina (delist), Macintosh (retire), Pickett (retire)

Either get 3 top 20 kids in the draft or 5 top 30.

Done.

Dow should be first delisted.

 

[Bojangles17]

they've genuinely improved. if lewis had of played every game to this point they could very well have been in the 8

Wil day has made the difference he missed first 5-6w of season , he’s a star

 

[tunksy]

Wil day has made the difference he missed first 5-6w of season , he’s a star

absolutely agree, very good player

 

[TigerPaul71]

Yup,

Which is why we need to gut the list imo.

Grimes (retire), Cumbo (delist), Short (trade/retire), Prestia (retire, too injured), Baker (trade), Graham (trade), Naismith (retire), Mate Colina (delist), Macintosh (retire), Pickett (retire)

Either get 3 top 20 kids in the draft or 5 top 30.

Done.

We need to keep Mac.

 

[Dragonbait0o0]

Yup,

Which is why we need to gut the list imo.

Grimes (retire), Cumbo (delist), Short (trade/retire), Prestia (retire, too injured), Baker (trade), Graham (trade), Naismith (retire), Mate Colina (delist), Macintosh (retire), Pickett (retire)

Either get 3 top 20 kids in the draft or 5 top 30.

Done.

We need to keep Baker

 

[Tigerbob]

Grimes (retire), Prestia (retire), Short (trade), Naismith (delist), Coulthard (delist), Dow (delist), Graham (FA), Cumberland (delist) Pickett (retire).

That’s what I would do. Cut deep but keep our some core. Hoping Dusty stays for one more year but have some doubts. If we can keep Baker I definitely would. Short is expendable, hoping we get a decent pick back for Graham.

 

[Bojangles17]

If last nights game wasn’t proof, we need to stop drafting short asses. The intercept marks around the ground are killing us, for some reason we can’t even spoil it anymore.

Hawks dropped sitters, that’s pretty much the only time we got the ball in a 1v1 on the wing.

Our aerial ability has been shite for a couple of seasons , get blight into boost our stocks , the likes of cumbo who refuse to even compete don’t help

 

[Bojangles17]

Grimes (retire), Prestia (retire), Short (trade), Naismith (delist), Coulthard (delist), Dow (delist), Graham (FA), Cumberland (delist) Pickett (retire).

That’s what I would do. Cut deep but keep our some core. Hoping Dusty stays for one more year but have some doubts. If we can keep Baker I definitely would. Short is expendable, hoping we get a decent pick back for Graham.

Fairly close but I can see us losing baker or rioli or both , just my spider senses

 

[Tigerbob]

Fairly close but I can see us losing baker or rioli or both , just my spider senses

Yeah I can see that. Last week I was firm on Baker leaving from a source but yesterday I was told there was a shift in this. Who knows, up in the air. Until he signs with us he is vulnerable to leave.

Rioli I can’t see it. Maybe that’s wishful thinking.

If they request to leave, we will get back a lot. Enough to almost rebuild the list.

 

[Cleansweep17]

We need to keep Mac.

Idk man, he was dropped to VFL and has only come back in out of necessity.

I’d rather take a punt on some kids playing wing. We aren’t competing so it’s not really a risk.

 

[Sol23]

Don’t trade shai.
Needs to be full time mid. No more fwd.

 

[Groupie_]

Don’t trade shai.
Needs to be full time mid. No more fwd.

what can we get for him
is the question

hes not good

 

[nugget_12]

We’re guna get shafted from the proposed new bid rules aren’t we?
I just have a feeling from that Laura Kane interview that they will bring the new rules in from this draft and our stock pile of picks will be useless.

 

[Sol23]

what can we get for him
is the question

hes not good

2 first rounders

 

[Groupie_]

2 first rounders

 

[Rocco sifreddi]

2 first rounders

I'll drive him to the airport

 

[Cam Payner]

2 first rounders

+ Reid...

 

[Groupie_]

+ Reid...

tony modra

 

[Rocco sifreddi]

+ Reid...

Riley?

 

[Cam Payner]

Riley?

Oliver