-
AFLW 2024 - Round 4 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Trade Hypotheticals
- Thread starter adam10
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Re: 2011 Trade Prediction's
Very shrewd adam10.
I just hope you don't get your want, especially from the Carlton perspective.
Very shrewd adam10.
I just hope you don't get your want, especially from the Carlton perspective.
Re: 2011 Trade Prediction's
Can someone fill me in as to who Brad Crouch is?
Can someone fill me in as to who Brad Crouch is?
Re: 2011 Trade Prediction's
A clever bunch to be targetting, as all may possibly now be picked up relatively cheaply and are capable of offering well beyond their current outputs.
A clever bunch to be targetting, as all may possibly now be picked up relatively cheaply and are capable of offering well beyond their current outputs.
Igloo
Not a mod
Re: 2011 Trade Prediction's
One of the 17 year olds. Inside mid, named on the HBF in the AA team. Can play outside as well though, but his inside game is more developed.
One of the 17 year olds. Inside mid, named on the HBF in the AA team. Can play outside as well though, but his inside game is more developed.
Re: 2011 Trade Prediction's
I think a swap of Cruize Garlett for a fringe player from another team (similar if younger age, HBF'er) may happen.
We would also entertain of getting O'Meara, but like a few clubs such as Richmond, don't have the picks/fringe quality to compete with the likes of Melbourne (Scully picks), Gold Coast (pick 4, thousands of top youth) or even Port (pick 6 + something else) without giving up a 'valuable commodity'
It seems on here, most posters seem to think they can attract guns without giving up their own guns through draft picks/their 14th best player. For example Tiger supporters would say Deledio/Cotchin/Martin/Vickery/Conca/Riewoldt/Rance off limits..North fans might say Ziebell/Wells/Swallow/Goldstein etc are off limits...won't get any real quality like O'Meara with that attitude.
Now I'm going to throw out some ideas. Note that I'm not predicting them, or getting a perfect trade, but more what I believe could be starting negotiations between teams
Think Kosi will be traded, has some value left in him, new coach might want to give Lynch/Walsh/Stanley more game time. Could go to Brisbane in return for 2nd rounder and Sheldon (I'm not trying to predict exact trades, just ideas, but Sheldon is a fringe youngster, and is just an example). Don't believe Kosi would attract much more, if Brisbane get a first rounder for Clark they could put that into the deal.
Clark for pick 16 and a player
Brisbane then have 8, 16, 30 and 48. Maybe 16 and Hanley for Kosi + 38....Hanley gives the Saints the option of getting rid of Peake/Ray if they develop him into a wingman, or Gram if as a HBF.
O'Meara for 4 + Hickey.
GWS have 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 (Patton, Coniglio, Wingard, Tyson, Longer), plus Hickey to help back up Brogan/Giles/Longer
Gold Coast get O'Meara and add him to the midfield of Ablett, Rischitelli, Iles, Swallow, McKenzie, Prestia, Bennell and Weller
A couple of Geelong fringe players may be looking elsewhere. Simpson while at start of year was from what I heard, in front of West/Vardy.
Simpson for pick 29 (Port Adelaide). Might not be fair to Geelong, but if he wants to leave, the Cats will get the best available deal without pushing Port to take him in the pre season draft. Simpson/Lobbe is a young ruck combo, but building with Hartlett/Gray/Boak and with Westhoff as a possible pinch hitter and a couple of others in Redden/Bass not quite regular AFL players, would be quite good for Port.
I think Richmond will entertain trading Daniel Jackson. Really not worth much, if the new Saints coach thinks he can have 1 last crack at the big one, Jackson as an experienced midfielder might help out Hayes. 38 and 56 for Jackson and 32...
Throwing out some possible situations
I think a swap of Cruize Garlett for a fringe player from another team (similar if younger age, HBF'er) may happen.
We would also entertain of getting O'Meara, but like a few clubs such as Richmond, don't have the picks/fringe quality to compete with the likes of Melbourne (Scully picks), Gold Coast (pick 4, thousands of top youth) or even Port (pick 6 + something else) without giving up a 'valuable commodity'
It seems on here, most posters seem to think they can attract guns without giving up their own guns through draft picks/their 14th best player. For example Tiger supporters would say Deledio/Cotchin/Martin/Vickery/Conca/Riewoldt/Rance off limits..North fans might say Ziebell/Wells/Swallow/Goldstein etc are off limits...won't get any real quality like O'Meara with that attitude.
Now I'm going to throw out some ideas. Note that I'm not predicting them, or getting a perfect trade, but more what I believe could be starting negotiations between teams
Think Kosi will be traded, has some value left in him, new coach might want to give Lynch/Walsh/Stanley more game time. Could go to Brisbane in return for 2nd rounder and Sheldon (I'm not trying to predict exact trades, just ideas, but Sheldon is a fringe youngster, and is just an example). Don't believe Kosi would attract much more, if Brisbane get a first rounder for Clark they could put that into the deal.
Clark for pick 16 and a player
Brisbane then have 8, 16, 30 and 48. Maybe 16 and Hanley for Kosi + 38....Hanley gives the Saints the option of getting rid of Peake/Ray if they develop him into a wingman, or Gram if as a HBF.
O'Meara for 4 + Hickey.
GWS have 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 (Patton, Coniglio, Wingard, Tyson, Longer), plus Hickey to help back up Brogan/Giles/Longer
Gold Coast get O'Meara and add him to the midfield of Ablett, Rischitelli, Iles, Swallow, McKenzie, Prestia, Bennell and Weller
A couple of Geelong fringe players may be looking elsewhere. Simpson while at start of year was from what I heard, in front of West/Vardy.
Simpson for pick 29 (Port Adelaide). Might not be fair to Geelong, but if he wants to leave, the Cats will get the best available deal without pushing Port to take him in the pre season draft. Simpson/Lobbe is a young ruck combo, but building with Hartlett/Gray/Boak and with Westhoff as a possible pinch hitter and a couple of others in Redden/Bass not quite regular AFL players, would be quite good for Port.
I think Richmond will entertain trading Daniel Jackson. Really not worth much, if the new Saints coach thinks he can have 1 last crack at the big one, Jackson as an experienced midfielder might help out Hayes. 38 and 56 for Jackson and 32...
Throwing out some possible situations
Re: 2011 Trade Prediction's
Would not mind Garlett
Sheldon is a role player. No way would we give up Hanley and pick 16 for Kosi and 38. Have you not seen Hanley this year? You obviously don't watch a lot of Football. Kosi is worth a 3rd rounder, 2nd at most.
Would not mind Garlett
Sheldon is a role player. No way would we give up Hanley and pick 16 for Kosi and 38. Have you not seen Hanley this year? You obviously don't watch a lot of Football. Kosi is worth a 3rd rounder, 2nd at most.
Bucking Beads
Brownlow Medallist
Pearce Hanley won't be traded because he is worth much more than what any team will pay. What use is kosi to the lions who are developing a list??
Joshen
Norm Smith Medallist
Re: 2011 Trade Prediction's
+ an avid North supporter from the Ballarat region (just as a bit of extra knowledge). Want (for us).
+ an avid North supporter from the Ballarat region (just as a bit of extra knowledge). Want (for us).
Igloo
Not a mod
Re: 2011 Trade Prediction's
A few of the 17 year olds are north supporters from what I have seen. Jake Stringer is as well, and he is another I would like us to get.
Damn you North.
A few of the 17 year olds are north supporters from what I have seen. Jake Stringer is as well, and he is another I would like us to get.
Damn you North.
Re: Saints and Freo lose coaches - what about player movements?
Did you just cross over 2 completely different threads Chris?
Did you just cross over 2 completely different threads Chris?
Chris25
Moderator
- Oct 30, 2007
- 11,963
- 14,198
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- West End Redbacks, Cleveland Browns
- Moderator
- #13
Re: Saints and Freo lose coaches - what about player movements?
A couple of threads were merged together earlier today, and then I just whacked the last few posts from the monster trade thread here for part 2. It is a bit messy though...
A couple of threads were merged together earlier today, and then I just whacked the last few posts from the monster trade thread here for part 2. It is a bit messy though...
year of the roo
Brownlow Medallist
Veteran
10k Posts
North Melbourne - 2014 Daw, Black, Gibson Player Sponsor
North Melbourne - 2013 Daw, Black and Gibson Player Sponsorship
North Melbourne - North 2012 Player Sponsor
North Melbourne - North 2011 Player Sponsor
North Melbourne - North 2010 Player Sponsor
North Melbourne - North 2008 Player Sponsor
- May 12, 2003
- 26,598
- 14,423
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
Re: 2011 Trade Prediction's
You really think o'meara is worth pick 4 and a player?
He's an unproven 17 year old with POTENTIAL, much rather pick 4 for Tippett.
We have plenty of young kids but what we desperatly need is big body up forward.
You really think o'meara is worth pick 4 and a player?
He's an unproven 17 year old with POTENTIAL, much rather pick 4 for Tippett.
We have plenty of young kids but what we desperatly need is big body up forward.
Re: 2011 Trade Predictions - Part II
The idea that the lions could trade hanley is laughable! Not going to happen
The idea that the lions could trade hanley is laughable! Not going to happen
Igloo
Not a mod
Re: 2011 Trade Predictions - Part II
Plays for the Pioneers, but broke his leg this year, so he missed some of the TAC cup.
Very versatile, can play forward or back. He is a bit over 190cm IIRC. Very good prospect, imo.
Plays for the Pioneers, but broke his leg this year, so he missed some of the TAC cup.
Very versatile, can play forward or back. He is a bit over 190cm IIRC. Very good prospect, imo.
Re: 2011 Trade Predictions - Part II
Gilbert for Higgins? Had similar years.
Gilbert for Higgins? Had similar years.
Igloo
Not a mod
Re: 2011 Trade Predictions - Part II
I would prefer Higgins. More naturally talented.
I would prefer Higgins. More naturally talented.
Igloo
Not a mod
Re: 2011 Trade Predictions - Part II
Debatable. Gilbert was 3rd B&F last year and pushed for AA.
halfback dasher
Norm Smith Medallist
Veteran
Hawthorn Hawks - Lowden, Anderson, Woodward Player Sponsor 2014
Hawthorn Hawks - Box Hill 2013 Sponsor
Hawthorn Hawks - Box Hill 2012
Hawthorn Hawks - Lowden, Anderson, Woodward Player Sponsor 2013
Hawthorn Hawks - Smith and Savage 2011 Player Sponsor
Hawthorn Hawks - Smith and Savage 2012 Player Sponsor
Hawthorn Hawks - Box Hill 2011 Sponsor
Re: 2011 Trade Predictions - Part II
1. Hawks WILL be pro-active in trying ta get the No.1 mini draft pik......
2. Hawks will make a play for a key Def .....starting with Thompson ( Nth )
3. Lisle will be a key ta trades for Hawks.
1. Hawks WILL be pro-active in trying ta get the No.1 mini draft pik......
2. Hawks will make a play for a key Def .....starting with Thompson ( Nth )
3. Lisle will be a key ta trades for Hawks.
Similar threads
